Transcript
[0:01] Hello, this is Dr. Jeff Tarrant,
[0:02] director of the Neuro Meditation
[0:04] Institute. And in this lesson we wanted
[0:07] to begin exploring heart rate
[0:09] variability biofeedback. So, what it is
[0:13] and then how you might use this in
[0:16] conjunction with certain styles of
[0:18] meditation.
[0:20] So, to begin with I want to explain that
[0:22] we're the software you're we're using is
[0:24] called emWave e m w a v e. It's by a
[0:28] company called HeartMath.
[0:30] There are other companies that you can
[0:31] use for biofeedback for heart rate
[0:33] variability biofeedback. I like this
[0:36] software and hardware because it's easy
[0:38] to use, it's pretty cost efficient, and
[0:41] it's accessible.
[0:43] So, I will be providing links to
[0:47] their website in the text that
[0:49] accompanies this lesson so you can check
[0:51] it out for yourself if you're
[0:52] interested.
[0:53] So, the first thing to explain is that
[0:56] basically there's a hardware and a
[0:58] software component. The hardware is
[1:00] actually very simple. So, you can see
[1:02] that it's a USB plug right here,
[1:07] connected to a long wire
[1:09] that has an ear clip.
[1:11] And that's it. So, this is one of the
[1:13] things I really appreciate about this
[1:15] type of system is that you don't need
[1:17] any gel or goop. You don't actually you
[1:20] don't even have to clean anything in
[1:22] terms of the skin. You do have to clean
[1:25] the sensor, obviously, but
[1:27] this is all you need from a hardware
[1:29] perspective. So, we'll plug this into
[1:32] the USB port,
[1:34] and you can see on the computer screen
[1:36] I've already got pulled up the software.
[1:42] You have to be able to find the USB
[1:44] port.
[1:48] Great.
[1:49] And so now I'm going to attach the
[1:51] sensor to my
[1:53] volunteer.
[1:54] Is it okay if I attach this to your ear?
[1:56] Yeah. Okay. And so all I'm going to do
[1:58] is take this little clip and attach it
[2:00] to the bottom of the earlobe. In fact,
[2:03] let me do it on the other side so you
[2:03] can kind of see it a little bit better.
[2:08] And that's it. That's the hookup.
[2:09] There's an additional
[2:11] uh
[2:13] little clip right here so that you can
[2:14] attach it to the side of the shirt so
[2:15] that it doesn't pull on the ear.
[2:18] And that's it. Um
[2:20] So, again, like I was saying, it's a
[2:21] very easy setup. It's something that's
[2:23] uh very accessible.
[2:25] Now, what we're going to be looking at
[2:27] is
[2:29] measurements of the heart rate, heart
[2:31] rate variability that we're actually
[2:33] picking up from her earlobe.
[2:36] So, you can actually measure the heart
[2:38] rate and aspects of heart rate anywhere
[2:40] on the body because the heart is a very
[2:42] powerful electromagnetic generator. So,
[2:46] you can pick up those signals anywhere
[2:47] if you have a sensitive enough
[2:50] equipment.
[2:52] So, now if you look at my computer
[2:54] screen, we started the session, and on
[2:56] the bottom what you were seeing there
[2:58] was simply the pulse. So, it was just
[3:01] the heart rhythm, you know, bum bum bum
[3:04] bum bum bum, the heartbeat.
[3:06] And then after about 20 seconds, the
[3:08] screen shifted into more of a
[3:10] biofeedback mode.
[3:12] Now, if you look at the bottom of the
[3:13] screen, there's a little area that says
[3:16] current HR,
[3:18] and you'll see a number in there.
[3:21] And essentially this is the running
[3:23] average of Ray's heart rate.
[3:27] So, it's just telling you kind of what
[3:29] her heart rate is right now.
[3:31] And again, it's an average.
[3:33] You'll notice when you watch that number
[3:34] that it doesn't stay static. It's not
[3:36] the same moment to moment. So, if it's
[3:39] at 75, it doesn't stay at 75. It'll
[3:42] fluctuate.
[3:44] And this is actually really important
[3:45] because
[3:46] what we are measuring with this system
[3:48] is heart rate variability, how the heart
[3:51] rate varies. Recognizing that the heart
[3:53] rate is not static, it's not a
[3:55] metronome, it doesn't behave that way.
[3:58] In fact, we don't want it to behave that
[3:59] way. That'd be bad if your heart just
[4:01] consistently had the exact same rhythm.
[4:04] So, if you look at the top of the screen
[4:07] where there is this line kind of moving
[4:10] up and down,
[4:11] this is what we're interested in. It's
[4:13] it's part of what we're interested in.
[4:15] You'll see on that graph that on the
[4:17] side is beats per minute. So, it's
[4:21] literally showing us
[4:23] what Ray's
[4:25] average heart rate is over this time
[4:28] period that we've been recording.
[4:30] And again, you can see very clearly when
[4:31] it's mapped out like this that the heart
[4:34] rate goes up, it goes down, it goes up,
[4:36] it goes down, it fluctuates.
[4:38] This is an aspect of heart rate
[4:41] variability, how it varies. Sometimes
[4:43] it's higher, sometimes it's lower.
[4:46] Now, why do we care about this?
[4:49] The main reason that we care about heart
[4:51] rate variability is because it's an
[4:53] excellent measure of nervous system
[4:55] balance.
[4:57] So, if you think about it,
[4:59] we have a sympathetic nervous system,
[5:02] this part of the autonomic nervous
[5:03] system, and the sympathetic nervous
[5:05] system is activating.
[5:07] That we think of it as our fight or
[5:09] flight system. So, if there's a danger,
[5:11] if there's something in the environment
[5:13] we have to respond to, it turns
[5:15] everything on, right? So, it dilates our
[5:19] pupils, it increases blood flow to the
[5:21] large muscle groups, it increases our
[5:24] heart rate. So, it's all part of the
[5:26] sympathetic arousal network.
[5:29] There's also a parasympathetic network,
[5:31] which is the opposite. So, you could
[5:33] think of this as the rest and digest
[5:37] system. And literally its functions are
[5:39] the exact opposite of the sympathetic
[5:41] nervous system.
[5:43] So, rather than activating things, it
[5:44] actually quiets things, turns things
[5:46] down.
[5:48] So, in relation to the heart rate, it
[5:50] decreases the heart rate.
[5:52] So, what you're actually seeing here
[5:54] when you're watching the fluctuation of
[5:56] the heart rate on the screen is you're
[5:59] literally seeing
[6:00] sympathetic activation when the heart
[6:03] rate goes up, parasympathetic activation
[6:05] when the heart rate goes down.
[6:08] So, this is why it's important to have
[6:11] movement. You don't want that wave to
[6:14] just be static because that would
[6:15] essentially mean you're stuck in either
[6:18] sympathetic or parasympathetic mode.
[6:20] And we don't want that. We want a
[6:21] balance.
[6:23] The way that we're able to show balance
[6:25] in this system is by a fluctuation. You
[6:28] spend a little time in sympathetic, and
[6:30] then you spend a little time in
[6:31] parasympathetic. And then you spend a
[6:33] little time in sympathetic and a little
[6:35] time in parasympathetic. Your body can't
[6:37] do both at the same time.
[6:39] It has to choose. It can only be in one
[6:41] or the other.
[6:43] So, the best way to find balance is to
[6:44] take turns.
[6:46] So, that's literally what we're wanting
[6:47] to see on the top of the screen is the
[6:50] movement. And the bigger the movement,
[6:52] the better. So, the larger the heart
[6:54] rate variability,
[6:56] the more it's connected to things
[6:57] related to health.
[6:59] You can think of this as indicating that
[7:01] your nervous system is flexible and
[7:02] adaptive if there's a lot of
[7:04] variability, if there's a lot of
[7:06] movement.
[7:07] So, you can see right now that Ray's got
[7:10] a really nice variability pattern.
[7:13] There's a lot of movement happening
[7:14] here. There's a lot of up, a lot of
[7:16] down. There's
[7:17] sort of a semi-consistent pattern
[7:20] beginning to develop.
[7:22] So, now what we do with the software,
[7:24] what the software does, is it takes this
[7:26] information about your variability
[7:29] pattern,
[7:30] and it analyzes it in some statistical
[7:34] ways that we're not going to get into in
[7:35] this lesson.
[7:37] And it calculates something that it
[7:39] calls coherence.
[7:40] So, if you look at the bottom corner of
[7:42] the screen where it's got the
[7:43] thermometers, there's a a red,
[7:46] a blue, and a green thermometer.
[7:49] And those reflect low, medium, and high
[7:51] coherence.
[7:53] Now, what this essentially means is that
[7:56] if your heart rate variability pattern
[7:58] is stable and consistent, if there's a
[8:01] lot of variability, but there's a stable
[8:03] and consistent pattern,
[8:05] then that's high coherence, meaning your
[8:08] system is in balance, your nervous
[8:10] system is in balance.
[8:12] If it's kind of sort of balanced, but
[8:14] not all the way, it's going to be
[8:15] medium, and then the blue light is going
[8:17] to light up.
[8:19] And if you're not so balanced at the
[8:21] moment, it's going to be the red. So,
[8:23] this is part of the feedback. You're
[8:24] getting additional information about the
[8:28] balance of your nervous system by
[8:31] whether you're in low, medium, or high
[8:34] moment to moment.
[8:35] So, you can watch the top
[8:38] graph of information showing the
[8:41] variability. You can look at the
[8:42] thermometers at the bottom to kind of
[8:44] give you a sense of where you are in
[8:46] terms of coherence.
[8:48] So, the trick, of course, is to learn
[8:51] how to intentionally shift yourself into
[8:54] more medium and high coherence and spend
[8:57] less time in low coherence.
[8:59] So, there are a
[9:01] vast array of strategies to do this
[9:06] because we are a mind-body.
[9:08] Everything you think, everything you do,
[9:11] everything you feel affects the balance
[9:13] of your nervous system.
[9:15] So, what this means is that you can
[9:16] intervene in this system through your
[9:20] thoughts, through your feelings, through
[9:22] your breath,
[9:24] through visualization.
[9:26] Virtually anything that you do that
[9:27] affects your mind-body is going to have
[9:29] an impact here.
[9:31] So, this is why this becomes a very
[9:32] powerful tool is because it opens itself
[9:35] to a wide range of strategies on how to
[9:38] influence it and how to how to keep your
[9:40] nervous system in a better state of
[9:42] balance.
[9:43] Great tool for stress and anxiety. It's
[9:45] great for PTSD. It's actually a a lot of
[9:48] research using this with traumatic brain
[9:49] injuries.
[9:51] So,
[9:52] this was the introduction just so that
[9:53] you have an orientation to what
[9:55] biofeedback is, what heart rate
[9:57] variability biofeedback is.
[10:00] In the next lesson, we're really going
[10:02] to dive in a bit further so that you can
[10:05] see how you might use this specifically
[10:08] with a focused meditation.
[10:13] All right, welcome back. This is Dr.
[10:15] Jeff Tarrant, director of the
[10:16] NeuroMeditation Institute. And we wanted
[10:20] to follow up on the heart rate
[10:21] variability biofeedback lesson
[10:24] to look at ways that you might use this
[10:27] type of technology
[10:29] in conjunction with a focused meditation
[10:31] or as a tool to assist in a focused
[10:33] style of meditation.
[10:36] So, we've already discussed in the
[10:37] previous lesson
[10:38] what's happening on this screen that
[10:40] we're looking at. Again, we're using the
[10:41] HeartMath software mWave Plus
[10:45] and
[10:46] we're just using the basic screen.
[10:48] There's actually a lot of other screens
[10:49] that come with this software, different
[10:52] games and and visualizers and things
[10:54] like that. We're actually using the
[10:55] basic screen because there's a lot of
[10:57] information on here that can be really
[10:59] helpful, particularly if you're using it
[11:01] the way that we're going to be using it.
[11:03] So,
[11:05] uh
[11:06] if you kind of look at what's happening
[11:07] on the screen right now, we've just been
[11:08] letting it run for a while
[11:11] and you can see there's a lot of
[11:12] variability. There's also some little
[11:14] choppy parts on here and some things
[11:17] like this.
[11:18] This is going to be related to all kinds
[11:20] of different aspects of what Ray's up to
[11:23] right now. So, whatever she's thinking
[11:25] about, probably the fact that she's on
[11:27] camera and I'm talking about her right
[11:29] now, that'll probably add a little bit
[11:30] of stress and anxiety. Um so, we might
[11:33] see She just laughed. Look, you can see
[11:35] where her heart rate jumped up a little
[11:37] bit cuz she laughed. So, um you know, we
[11:39] can see kind of what's happening right
[11:41] now in real time.
[11:44] Now, the first step if you're going to
[11:45] use this as a meditation tool is to help
[11:47] people learn how to get into a good
[11:49] state of coherence.
[11:51] And so, the first strategy that I
[11:53] usually teach people is how to use their
[11:55] breath
[11:56] as a way to develop a more coherent
[11:58] heart rate variability pattern.
[12:01] So,
[12:02] Ray, what I'd like you to do is just
[12:04] kind of watch the top of the screen up
[12:05] here. Don't worry about this so much
[12:07] right now.
[12:09] And just focus on belly breathing.
[12:12] So, just as you're breathing in that
[12:14] most of the
[12:16] uh
[12:17] movement is going to come from the belly
[12:18] region. So, as you inhale, the belly
[12:20] sticks out
[12:22] and then as you exhale, the belly will
[12:25] retract back. So, just let the breathing
[12:27] be nice and slow
[12:30] and steady coming from the belly.
[12:36] And you can see that as soon as she
[12:37] changes her breathing, look what happens
[12:39] to the heart rate variability pattern.
[12:43] So, not only did the heart rate
[12:44] variability increase dramatically, so it
[12:48] went from maybe, you know, maybe a five
[12:50] beats per minute fluctuation to now it's
[12:53] almost a 20 beat per minute fluctuation.
[12:56] And you remember from the previous
[12:57] lesson that we were saying that the
[12:58] greater the variability, the better it
[13:00] is for health and well-being.
[13:03] So, just by changing the breathing into
[13:05] a belly breathing pattern that's soft
[13:06] and gentle, we get this
[13:08] really large heart rate variability, but
[13:11] also look at how smooth and consistent
[13:13] it is.
[13:14] This is exactly what we want. This is
[13:16] what the system designates as high
[13:19] coherence. And if you look at the bottom
[13:21] of the screen, you can see that the
[13:23] green is lit up and that's where she's
[13:27] kind of racking up percentage points.
[13:29] It's keeping track of the percentage of
[13:30] time that she has been in each one of
[13:32] these
[13:33] uh different levels of coherence.
[13:35] So,
[13:37] this is beautiful. This is perfect. And
[13:39] so, what I would like you to do is
[13:41] simply keep this pattern up by using
[13:44] your breath.
[13:45] So, watching your breath
[13:48] watching this pattern and seeing if you
[13:50] can keep each one of these waves
[13:53] essentially identical
[13:55] just by using your breath.
[13:56] You can also kind of follow
[13:59] as it goes up
[14:01] coordinating that with your inhalation
[14:03] and as the line comes down, coord-
[14:04] coordinating that with your exhalation.
[14:09] So, just kind of following.
[14:28] If you see places on the screen where
[14:29] there's like a blue line, sometimes
[14:32] you'll also see a red line, that's
[14:34] simply where
[14:35] we lost the signal for a moment and so,
[14:38] the software is compensating for that.
[14:42] So, it's it's not a problem, but uh you
[14:45] will see that periodically when you're
[14:46] measuring somebody's
[14:48] heart rate variability pattern.
[14:51] So, you can see that Ray's doing a
[14:53] really nice job here with this. And so,
[14:55] think about the instructions that I just
[14:57] gave her.
[14:59] So, I'm asking her to watch her breath
[15:02] and to coordinate her breathing with
[15:03] what she's seeing on the screen and just
[15:05] to stay right there.
[15:07] Now,
[15:08] we're starting to see that it's it just
[15:10] got a little bit more shallow.
[15:12] So, I'm going to want to check in with
[15:14] at some point and find out what happened
[15:15] right there.
[15:16] Um
[15:17] but what I want you to start to pay
[15:19] attention to is how this is actually a
[15:22] breath focused meditation.
[15:24] Now, we think of breath focused
[15:25] meditation as an eyes closed practice
[15:27] where you're
[15:29] internally watching your breath.
[15:31] Right? You're just watching what's
[15:32] happening. You're watching as you
[15:34] breathe in through your air through the
[15:35] nostrils and breathe out through the
[15:37] mouth.
[15:38] Or feeling the cool air as you breathe
[15:41] in and the warm air as you breathe out.
[15:43] Or feeling the belly expand or feeling
[15:45] the belly contract with each breath.
[15:48] And that that is what you're focused on
[15:50] for a focused meditation. This is a very
[15:52] common way to practice.
[15:54] Well, guess what? You can take those
[15:56] same principles
[15:58] and add the biofeedback and it makes the
[16:01] process much more engaging.
[16:04] It's much easier to hold your attention
[16:05] because you have something external
[16:07] giving you information about what your
[16:09] breathing is doing. So, you still have
[16:11] to watch your breathing in your body.
[16:13] You still have to pay attention to
[16:14] what's happening here, but you have
[16:16] additional information, additional
[16:18] feedback to help you stay on track.
[16:21] Every time you see a fluctuation
[16:24] that's information. Something changed
[16:27] there. Perhaps the mind wandered or
[16:30] perhaps the breathing became more
[16:31] shallow
[16:32] or perhaps there was sort of feeling
[16:34] state that got engaged somehow.
[16:38] This is exactly what you do with a
[16:39] meditation practice, right? You're
[16:41] watching your breath, the mind gets
[16:43] distracted, it gets pulled off by
[16:45] something else. You recognize that the
[16:47] mind got pulled off
[16:50] and you bring it right back.