BrightStar
BlogMy Tickets
BlogMy Tickets
Saved events
Help & contactSign UpLog in
Events
  • Browse All Events
  • For Seekers
  • Yoga
  • Meditation
  • Breathwork
  • Qigong
  • Sacred Music
  • World Music
  • Medicine Music
  • Sound Healing
  • Ecstatic Dance
  • Ceremony
  • Plant Medicine
  • Energy Healing
  • Satsang & Wisdom
  • Tantra
  • Retreats
  • All Categories →
Destinations
  • Bali
  • Sedona
  • Los Angeles
  • Costa Rica
  • Tulum
  • Byron Bay
  • San Francisco
  • Austin
  • New York
  • San Diego
  • Seattle
  • Portland
  • Miami
  • London
  • Maui
  • Boulder
  • Oakland
  • All Cities →
Platform
  • List Your Event Free
  • Autopilot
  • Join the Movement
  • Sell Globally
  • For Creators
  • For Teams
  • For Writers
  • For Teachers
  • For Kirtan Artists
  • For Studios
  • For Festivals
  • For Retreat Centers
  • For Nonprofits
  • Brand Ambassador
  • Free Ticketing
  • Elevate
  • Amplify
  • The Ecosystem
Features

Ticketing and checkout

  • Ticket categories
  • Assigned seating
  • Custom questions
  • Coupon codes
  • Smart pricing
  • Ticket sharing
  • Waitlist
  • Flexible refunds
  • Digital waivers
  • Tip jar
  • Donations and sliding scale
  • Embed widget
  • Mindful checkout
  • Recurring events
  • Private sessions
  • Online courses
  • Summits
  • Rooms and stays
  • Ticket scanner

Marketing and growth

  • Abandoned cart recovery
  • Visitor recovery
  • Upsells and add-ons
  • Affiliate engine
  • Upsell affiliate network
  • Brand ambassador
  • Meta retargeting
  • Verified buyer network
  • Outbound email marketing
  • Email sequences
  • SMS and WhatsApp
  • Event upsell network
  • Direct mail campaigns
  • SEO engine
  • Syndication
  • Event sharing
  • Custom event pages
  • Artist profiles
  • Link in bio
  • Event blog
  • Blog newsletter

Payments

  • Payments, powered by Stripe
  • Buy now, pay later
  • Apple Wallet
  • Multi currency

Data and operations

  • Team access
  • Message center
  • Reports
  • Analytics reporting
  • Performance reporting
  • Customer data
  • Integrations
  • Switch from another platform

AI

  • Maestro
  • AI FAQ assistant
  • All Features →
Company
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Glossary
  • Inspiration
  • Help Center
  • API Docs
  • Brand Assets
  • Press
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy

Events

  • Browse All Events
  • For Seekers
  • Yoga
  • Meditation
  • Breathwork
  • Qigong
  • Sacred Music
  • World Music

Destinations

  • Bali
  • Sedona
  • Los Angeles
  • Costa Rica
  • Tulum
  • Byron Bay
  • San Francisco
  • Austin

Platform

  • List Your Event Free
  • Autopilot
  • Join the Movement
  • Sell Globally
  • For Creators
  • For Teams
  • For Writers
  • For Teachers

Features

  • Community Network
  • Abandoned Cart Recovery
  • Ticket Categories
  • Recurring Events
  • Assigned Seating
  • Affiliate Engine
  • Waitlist / Notify
  • All Features →

Company

  • About
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Glossary
  • Inspiration
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
Read more

Events

  • Medicine Music
  • Sound Healing
  • Ecstatic Dance
  • Ceremony
  • Plant Medicine
  • Energy Healing
  • Satsang & Wisdom
  • Tantra
  • Retreats
  • All Categories →

Destinations

  • New York
  • San Diego
  • Seattle
  • Portland
  • Miami
  • London
  • Maui
  • Boulder
  • Oakland
  • All Cities →

Platform

  • For Kirtan Artists
  • For Studios
  • For Festivals
  • For Retreat Centers
  • For Nonprofits
  • Brand Ambassador
  • Free Ticketing
  • Elevate
  • Amplify
  • The Ecosystem

Company

  • Help Center
  • API Docs
  • Brand Assets
  • Press

Ticketing and checkout

  • Ticket categories
  • Assigned seating
  • Custom questions
  • Coupon codes
  • Smart pricing
  • Ticket sharing
  • Waitlist
  • Flexible refunds
  • Digital waivers
  • Tip jar
  • Donations and sliding scale
  • Embed widget
  • Mindful checkout
  • Recurring events
  • Private sessions
  • Online courses
  • Summits
  • Rooms and stays
  • Ticket scanner

Marketing and growth

  • Abandoned cart recovery
  • Visitor recovery
  • Upsells and add-ons
  • Affiliate engine
  • Upsell affiliate network
  • Brand ambassador
  • Meta retargeting
  • Verified buyer network
  • Outbound email marketing
  • Email sequences
  • SMS and WhatsApp
  • Event upsell network
  • Direct mail campaigns
  • SEO engine
  • Syndication
  • Event sharing
  • Custom event pages
  • Artist profiles
  • Link in bio
  • Event blog
  • Blog newsletter

Payments

  • Payments, powered by Stripe
  • Buy now, pay later
  • Apple Wallet
  • Multi currency

Data and operations

  • Team access
  • Message center
  • Reports
  • Analytics reporting
  • Performance reporting
  • Customer data
  • Integrations
  • Switch from another platform

AI

  • Maestro
  • AI FAQ assistant
Get the app
Download on theApp StoreGet it onGoogle Play
© 2026 BrightStar. All rights reserved. Photo credits ·
Inspiration

Life's Origin Mystery: Why Physics Alone Can't Explain It

Big Think
Big Think
Nov 6, 2026
12 min read

From Big Think

Theoretical physicist and cosmologist Paul Davies has spent decades chasing one of science's most stubborn riddles: how non-life becomes life. It's a question that defies the usual toolkit of physics—not because we lack data, but because we lack the right conceptual framework. Standing at Arizona State University's Beyond Center for Fundamental Concepts in Science, where he serves as director, Davies has come to believe that the missing piece isn't another exotic particle or hidden force. It's information itself, and the moment chemistry learned to encode, copy, and pass along its own instructions.

Read · 7 sections

What We Mean When We Say "Life"

The first obstacle isn't empirical; it's linguistic. Any serious investigation into life's origins must begin by admitting we don't have a clean definition. Davies himself reaches for a tongue-in-cheek comparison: "There is a very famous definition of life which is based on the definition of pornography: I know it when I see it." But the working definition that has gained traction in recent years is far more productive—life is chemistry plus information.

This distinction matters enormously. If you broke a human being down to their molecular constituents and tried to sell those components on the open market, Davies notes, you wouldn't get more than a few cents. The hardware of life—the atoms and molecules—is unremarkable. Carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen: nothing rare, nothing special. What makes life extraordinary is not what it's made of but what it does. That behavior, that dynamic organization, lives in the realm of software.

This hardware-software distinction traces back further than most scientists realize. In the 1944 book What Is Life?, physicist Erwin Schrödinger, one of the founders of quantum mechanics, identified the informational content of life as central to its operation. Schrödinger proposed a beautiful metaphor: biological information would have to be stored in something like an "aperiodic crystal"—a structure that is stable like a crystal but varied in its pattern, capable of encoding complex, specific information rather than merely repeating a simple geometry. What Schrödinger intuited without the language of modern biology was essentially the concept of a code.

Yet this insight remained mostly theoretical for decades. The 1953 Miller-Urey experiment, in which chemist Harold Urey and student Stanley Miller recreated what they imagined as early Earth conditions—gases, water, electrical sparks—and successfully synthesized amino acids, was celebrated as a proof of concept. Brown sludge collected at the bottom of a flask seemed to point toward life. But Davies is blunt about the experiment's limitation: it addressed the hardware problem while sidestepping the software entirely. It showed how chemistry might produce the building blocks of proteins. It said nothing about how those blocks came to be organized according to an abstract code—or how that code came to be self-replicating and self-correcting.

The Puzzle of Genetic Code

The central mystery, then, is this: how did chemistry come to write its own code? The genetic code is not a force of nature in the way gravity is. It's not an inevitable consequence of molecules bumping together. It's an abstract mathematical system—arbitrary, elegant, and utterly dependent on a context that only life itself can provide. DNA is information inscribed in molecules, but the meaning of that information exists nowhere in chemistry alone. The same molecule might mean one thing in one context and nothing at all in another.

When Davies speaks of information in this technical sense, he draws a distinction rarely made in popular science. Information, in the physicist's sense, can be precisely quantified. There is an entire branch of science and engineering built on information theory—the mathematics of encoding, transmission, and storage. But that mathematical rigor captures only one aspect of what makes genetic information special. The genetic code carries semantic content; it means something. A book might be physically identical to another book but carry completely different information. The same book might be printed in English or Mandarin. And both books might mean nothing whatsoever to a reader who doesn't understand either language.

The question is not how complex molecules formed. The question is how those molecules came to carry instructions that something could read and act upon. The genetic code didn't emerge because the laws of physics forced it into being. The laws of physics, working locally through forces and interactions, cannot account for the emergence of abstract codes. This is Davies's core argument: at the point where abstract mathematical information first appeared in the history of Earth, something new entered the picture. Something that cannot be explained by forces and interactions alone.

Entropy, Order, and the Missing Laws

Life presents a thermodynamic paradox. The second law of thermodynamics states that in a closed system, entropy—disorder, the spread of energy—never decreases. Everything tends toward chaos. Yet living organisms do precisely the opposite. They build order. They resist decay. They create structure and information where there was none before.

The standard response is to note that life isn't a closed system. The Earth receives energy from the Sun, so locally, we can reverse entropy's arrow. Living things are permitted to become more ordered because they're dumping their waste heat into their environment. This is true as far as it goes, but Davies argues it doesn't go far enough.

Maxwell's demon, a thought experiment proposed by physicist James Clerk Maxwell in the 19th century, illustrates the deeper issue. Imagine a container of gas at uniform temperature, divided in half by a wall with a tiny door. A clever demon watches gas molecules on one side and opens the door only when a fast-moving (hot) molecule approaches, allowing it through while keeping slow (cold) molecules out. The result would be one side heating up and one cooling down, all without any energy input—a violation of the second law. The resolution, physicists determined, is that the demon must do work to gather information about the molecules' speeds, and this information-gathering itself dissipates energy in a way that counterbalances any apparent violation.

Life, Davies suggests, is nature's version of Maxwell's demon. Living organisms use information as fuel. They gather data about their environment—through sensory systems, chemical receptors, neural networks—and use that information to do work, to build order, to resist entropy. Life has discovered something the second law permits: organized systems can trade energy and entropy with their environment to create local pockets of order, so long as they're using information as a tool.

But this raises a deeper question: does the physics we have—the laws as written—actually explain how this happens? Or are we missing a category of law altogether? Davies believes the latter. The laws as currently formulated describe forces and their effects. They say nothing about information, context, or meaning. If life's essential operation involves the use of information as fuel, then perhaps the universe operates according to laws we haven't yet articulated, laws that explicitly govern how information flows and what work it can do.

Beyond the Genome: Epigenetics and Cellular Memory

The conventional story of life has focused on DNA—the genetic code written in a four-letter alphabet along a double helix. But recent decades have revealed that DNA is not the only information system life uses. Epigenetics—the study of how genes are switched on and off, how patterns of chemical modification can alter what a gene does without changing its sequence—suggests that organisms carry multiple layers of information simultaneously. These patterns can be passed to offspring. They can even persist across generations in ways that don't involve copying the DNA sequence itself.

Michael Levin's experiments with flatworms present a striking illustration. Working with the model organism Planaria, Levin's team discovered something startling: they could surgically create two-headed worms and, more remarkably, the two-headed morphology persisted. When these worms reproduced, their offspring retained the two-headed structure even though genetically they were identical to normal worms. Something about the cellular organization—some form of information storage that transcends genetic code—was being inherited.

This phenomenon points to a broader truth: life stores information in ways that bypass or supplement DNA entirely. Cellular patterns, chemical modifications to DNA and histone proteins, three-dimensional folding of proteins—all of these encode instructions for how an organism develops and behaves. The genetic code is not the whole story. It's not even clear it's the primary story. The question of how organisms read, write, and pass along this multifaceted information remains largely unanswered.

Are We Alone? And What Would We Know If We Weren't?

If life emerged once on Earth, through a pathway we barely understand, what are the odds it emerged elsewhere? Davies frames the puzzle differently than scientists typically do. The conventional assumption has been that life requires specific chemical ingredients and specific conditions. But if Davies is right—if the origin of life hinges not primarily on chemistry but on information and abstract codes—then the question becomes radically more difficult.

The search for extraterrestrial life has traditionally focused on liquid water, stable temperatures, and other conditions compatible with Earth-based biochemistry. But what if life exists on a foundation entirely foreign to our own? What if elsewhere in the cosmos, information is encoded in a substrate we don't recognize? What if the codes are written in physics or chemistry that works by utterly different principles?

Davies raises another possibility: that any truly advanced extraterrestrial civilization might not be biological at all. As technology advances, an organism has the ability to design and engineer intelligence in ways that far exceed its own cognitive capacities. If humans can create artificial intelligences, then presumably sufficiently advanced aliens could do so too—and might do so almost immediately after reaching a certain technological threshold. The search for extraterrestrial life, Davies suggests, may ultimately be a search for extraterrestrial artificial intelligence.

But there's another scenario Davies takes seriously: the shadow biosphere. Life on Earth is assumed to be monophyletic, descended from a single common ancestor. But what if that's false? What if at some point in Earth's history, life emerged independently more than once? A "shadow" biosphere—a lineage of organisms fundamentally different from all known life—could be hiding in plain sight. It might operate on different chemistry, different principles of heredity, different definitions of what makes something alive. We wouldn't recognize it as life because we don't know what to look for.

The challenge of detecting life radically unlike our own is profound. How would you distinguish it from non-living chemistry? If an organism doesn't use DNA or RNA, doesn't metabolize, doesn't reproduce in ways we'd recognize—on what basis would we call it alive? Davies suggests that we lack the conceptual tools even to begin this search. We've defined life so narrowly around our own biochemistry that we've probably blinded ourselves to possibilities beyond it.

Fine-Tuning and the Deepest Mystery

The universe itself presents a puzzle that physics alone may not solve. The fundamental constants—the strength of gravity, the mass of an electron, the strength of the electromagnetic force—appear to be precisely calibrated for the existence of complex chemistry and ultimately life. Change any of these values by a few percent, and no stars form, or atoms don't bind, or chemistry doesn't work. This is known as the fine-tuning problem, and it haunts physics.

Davies has proposed that there are potentially four explanations. The first is brute luck: the universe just happened to have the right constants, an astronomical coincidence with no deeper reason. The second is design: some intelligence or agent deliberately set the constants to allow life to emerge. The third is the multiverse: countless universes exist with different constants, and we necessarily find ourselves in one compatible with our existence (a tautology, but perhaps a true one).

Davies's fourth way is more subtle. It suggests that the universe itself may be participating in a feedback loop. Physics and information, laws and life, are not separate domains but deeply intertwined. The universe is not merely fine-tuned for life; perhaps life and information play an active role in shaping the universe's character. This idea draws on concepts like Wheeler's delayed choice experiment, which suggests that observation—the gathering of information—can retroactively influence physical outcomes.

The deepest mystery, Davies implies, is not whether the universe was designed for life or life for the universe, but whether that distinction even makes sense. At the foundation of physical law, information and meaning may not be secondary or emergent. They may be fundamental.

Where to go from here

The origin of life remains unsolved not because we lack laboratories or microscopes but because we lack a theory adequate to the phenomenon. The Miller-Urey experiments and their successors have produced interesting chemistry, but no one has synthesized a self-replicating information system from scratch. No one has shown how abstract codes arise from non-living matter. No one has bridged the explanatory gap between forces and meaning.

Davies suggests that the next phase of research must be more ambitious in its conceptual scope. It must integrate what we know about physics, chemistry, and information theory into a unified framework that actually explains, rather than merely describes, how life begins. It may require new laws, new principles, new ways of thinking about what it means for matter to organize itself not just into complexity but into meaning.

The question is not whether life exists elsewhere in the universe or whether we can synthesize living matter in a test tube. The question is whether we can understand, at a truly fundamental level, what allows the inert to become animate—what allows nature to write its own instructions.

Comments

Loading the conversation…

Transcript

[0:00] My name is Paul Davies. I'm a theoretical  physicist and cosmologist by profession.  

[0:05] I'm a region's professor at Arizona State  University where I'm also the director of  

[0:10] the Beyond Center for Fundamental Concepts  in Science. I've written over 30 books. Uh  

[0:15] the most recent is what's eating the universe and  other cosmic questions and before that the demon  

[0:23] in the machine which is all about the nature of  life. This Big Think interview is brought to you  

[0:28] by Pangram. Navigating an internet filled with  AI generated content is a [music] frustrating  

[0:34] experience. It is becoming harder to separate real  from fake and human from machine. Pangram is the  

[0:41] most trusted AI detector backed by rigorous  public research. Pangram can tell you how  

[0:46] much of what you're reading is AI generated.  If there's an image you think was made by AI,  

[0:51] Pangram can detect that, too. To regain trust  over what you read and see, go to www.pangram.com.

[1:00] And now back to the interview.

[1:05] [sighs] Chapter one, what is life? Definition  and information. There are really three  

[1:15] origin mysteries. I like to say there's the  origin of the universe, the origin of life,  

[1:20] and the origin of consciousness. Uh now most of my  career I've been working in cosmology and I would  

[1:26] say that we actually understand the origin of the  universe pretty well. The origin of consciousness  

[1:30] is a really tough one because we don't even know  how to frame the questions. We don't know the  

[1:35] right conceptual structure uh to apply when it  comes to the nature of consciousness. I think  

[1:42] it's still deeply mysterious. The origin of life  is a tough one, but we're sort of on the case, and  

[1:48] I can imagine that within a few decades, we might  have a pretty good understanding. There's always  

[1:53] a danger of getting hung up on the words and and  the definitions. There's a very famous definition  

[2:00] of life which is based on the definition of  pornography. I know it when I see it. But if you  

[2:06] want a snappy definition, one that's quite popular  at the moment is that life is chemistry plus  

[2:12] information. You know, it's not like life is some  sort of magic matter or it's got some extremely  

[2:20] rare ingredients. If you take uh human being and  uh break them down to their molecular structure  

[2:28] and then try and sell the components on the open  market, you wouldn't get more than a few cents  

[2:34] uh for the stuff that we're made of. You know,  there's nothing very special or rare uh inside  

[2:40] our our bodies. So it's not what we're made of,  not the hardware. Uh it is really uh what we do,  

[2:47] our behavior. Uh and that's where in the realm  of uh what we might call software. So I would  

[2:53] express it this way. I'd say it's hardware and  software. These are parallel narratives. They're  

[2:59] not in conflict. But I would say that the software  aspect has really been rather neglected until  

[3:07] recently when it comes to trying to understand  the origin of life. But it's clear that to have a  

[3:12] full understanding of life. We have to integrate  those two. I think we are very far from having  

[3:16] done that. And the question of what is life of  course is not a new one. It's not just part of the  

[3:24] scientific era. It goes back thousands of years  in the history of philosophy because living things  

[3:29] do stand out and they struck the early Greek  philosophers as being something really special.  

[3:36] For example, Aristotle had a thought about how to  connect living organisms with the wider scheme of  

[3:43] things. And his view uh the nature of causation  was such that one could really attribute lifelike  

[3:49] properties not just to living organisms themselves  but to the universe as a whole. Uh that is when  

[3:57] you drop a stone it falls to the ground. Why is  that? not as we would think today because of the  

[4:02] force of gravity uh but because it had a natural  place uh down there. it was trying to get to its  

[4:08] uh its natural place. And so in that sense it was  goal oriented. And if we go back 100 150 years,  

[4:16] there was this notion that well, you know,  maybe uh uh life requires some additional  

[4:22] um force or uh lam vital as what it was expressed  in French or some some uh something to animate the  

[4:32] matter that you might have complex matter but  you need to sort of have some other uh type of  

[4:38] uh essence which would infuse it and would make  it come alive. um uh and do its amazing things.  

[4:45] And so that was known as vitalism and uh over the  years came to be associated with a number of other  

[4:53] things in physics like electricity perhaps or  maybe radioactivity you know or some mysterious  

[5:00] force that we didn't uh yet fully understand.  Um and and those ideas I think became pretty  

[5:08] thoroughly discredited. Now Darwin had a brilliant  theory of how life evolves once it gets going on  

[5:15] planet earth, how it has evolved over billions of  years to give us the complexity of the biosphere  

[5:20] that we see today. But he wouldn't be drawn on how  life got started in the first place. So addressing  

[5:26] the question of what is life, you inevitably come  up against this question, well how does non-life  

[5:31] turn into life? You know, what is that extra  special thing it acquires on that pathway? Darwin  

[5:37] said it's a wonderful quote. It's mere rubbish at  this time talking of the origin of life. One might  

[5:42] as well talk about the origin of matter. But by  about the 1920s, uh there was increasing interest  

[5:49] in the what we might call the chemical pathway.  I think it's pretty obvious that life is based  

[5:54] on chemistry. So what sort of chemical magic  took place to conjure life into being in the  

[6:02] uh first stages? And there were attempts to  cook up life in the lab. In the early 1950s,  

[6:09] the chemist Harold Yuri managed to interest a  young student Stanley Miller in attempting to  

[6:15] recreate the conditions on the early Earth. They  didn't really know what those conditions were,  

[6:20] but they had a guess that there would be certain  gases in the atmosphere and water and lightning  

[6:26] and and so on. And so Miller did this uh early  experiment in which he put a number of um gases  

[6:34] in a in a flask and sparked electricity through  it for a week and was gratified to find that the  

[6:41] building blocks of proteins called amino acids,  simple molecules, um were made in this process.  

[6:48] And there was sort of brown sludge in the bottom  of the flask. And so that really looked like  

[6:53] uh that was uh that was on the pathway to life.  But again um you see this this lacked a definition  

[7:00] of life. It it was an attempt to define life in  terms of its chemical components not in terms  

[7:06] of what it does. So I would say that that was  addressing the problem of the hardware of life  

[7:12] but not the software. And if we fast forward to  today I think this is still a very deep problem.  

[7:18] If you want to focus a definition of life just  on the hardware, just on its chemical components,  

[7:25] uh well, we made a bit of progress. Um not much  I might say from that early Miller experiment. Um  

[7:31] there people have gone on to do more of these  prebiotic experiments, but they haven't got  

[7:37] very far down that pathway to life. Now quantum  mechanics with its brilliant uh start in 1925 went  

[7:45] on within a very few years to explain the nature  of matter all the way from subatomic particles  

[7:52] up to stars and Irvin Schroinger he was one of  the founders of quantum mechanics wrote a book  

[7:57] called what is life and in his book Schroinger  drew attention to the fact that life is as I've  

[8:03] stated it earlier chemistry plus information that  the information content of life was key to how it  

[8:10] operates. He was also very clear that uh for  the stability of that information, one had to  

[8:15] use quantum mechanics. He came up with a metaphor  which is a rather beautiful one. He said that this  

[8:21] biological information uh would have to be stored  in something like an aeriodic crystal. What does  

[8:28] that mean? Well, a crystal is of course familiar  to everybody. It's a very simple thing. It's a  

[8:32] very stable structure. Think of a salt crystal.  It's just a geometrically repeating pattern of  

[8:37] atoms. no problem about that except that that  can't store very much information because it's  

[8:43] just too simple. So he wanted something that had  the stability of a crystal uh but would not just  

[8:49] have that simple periodicity but could have um  a vast number of alternative arrangements and  

[8:55] permutations of its components. So he had this  idea of an a periodic crystal. didn't know at the  

[9:00] time what that molecule might be but it took  Crick and Watson's famous analysis of DNA to  

[9:08] declare that that was the life molecule and now we  would say it's contains the book of life it codes  

[9:14] the information uh that is necessary to build the  organism in that a periodic crystal called DNA  

[9:22] I think the concept of information is absolutely  critical to understanding the distinction between  

[9:27] uh life and non-life People use this term  information in a very informal way in daily  

[9:33] life. Uh and we have after all information  technology. Uh and so uh what is it and why  

[9:40] is it that this thing called information uh is  the key to life? A pretty good general definition  

[9:46] of information is reduction in uncertainty. Just  give you a simple example. You might flip a coin  

[9:53] and may come down heads, may come down tails.  You don't know which. But if you look and find  

[9:58] out that uncertainty 50/50 is reduced, you are  certain it's say heads and that means you've  

[10:05] acquired a bit of information. And I use that word  adverisedly because to the technical definition is  

[10:10] indeed one bit. It's a short for a binary digit.  And so the information from inspecting a flip coin  

[10:16] is one bit of reduction in your uncertainty.  And you can build upon that and that's a way  

[10:21] of quantifying information. And there's an entire  branch of science and engineering uh information  

[10:27] theory which is just based on that rather austere  definition. But when it comes to life it's very  

[10:34] clear that there's something else involved  because if we think for example of bacteria  

[10:39] you could take out its DNA. This is routinely  done. You can edit that DNA and put it back and  

[10:45] get the bacterium to do something a bit different.  But if you take out its DNA and just scramble it,  

[10:51] just shuffle the base pairs of that DNA and  put it back so that it's just gobbledygook,  

[10:56] then the bacterium is in effect dead. I've  got the same amount of information in the DNA,  

[11:02] but it's not going to do anything and it will  slowly just decompose. In other words, it's like a  

[11:07] book. If you take the words in that book and then  just shuffle them randomly and then you'd have  

[11:12] a book with the same information content, but it  wouldn't mean anything. And that's the point about  

[11:17] life. The information in the DNA, and I might say  it's only a small part of the total information  

[11:23] content of living organisms. There's a whole lot  of what we call epigenetic information outside  

[11:28] of DNA as well. But you take the whole thing. Uh  it is so effective because it means something. So  

[11:35] that's the software component that's been refined  over billions of years as an operating system.  

[11:42] And uh when a bacterium uh divides and makes  a new organism when it replicates it has to  

[11:49] uh upload that um that uh information that uh  program into the progeny for the whole thing to  

[11:57] function. So this is the way that life works.  Uh and without the instructions it it isn't  

[12:03] life. It's just complex chemistry. So how did  that come to exist in the first place? How did  

[12:09] that genetic code arise? It's, you know, it's a  pretty clever sophisticated sort of thing. Um,  

[12:15] what did it, was there a simpler precursor  code? If you go back four billion years,  

[12:20] were there organisms using a dick code instead of  a triplet code? Were there less amino acids? But  

[12:26] how did that notion of coded information uh come  about in the first place? I I think that is the  

[12:34] for me the point about the origin of life is how  did the molecules the complex molecules that make  

[12:41] up life write their own code their own computer  code cuz that's what it amounts to uh how did  

[12:47] how did that happen I think that's a deep mystery  I don't think uh we we've got anywhere close to  

[12:53] understanding uh that particular step but for me  if I think about you know what was the critical  

[12:59] point at which you say it's alive uh in in that  uh pathway from just complex chemistry to a truly  

[13:06] living thing. It's at the point that you get that  abstract mathematical code appearing uh we don't  

[13:13] know how that that happened but that would be the  point for me uh at which you would say it's the  

[13:18] origin of life. So if I stand back and look at  uh the the the magic of life, the way it is uh  

[13:27] performing its amazing feats, uh then it it just  seems to me that the correct words that come to my  

[13:34] mind are information management. It's the way that  the information is not just a headcount of bits,  

[13:40] not just the content, but the way that information  is managing or organizing or supervising what  

[13:48] life does. And so that information has to be  in a context. It's got to be embedded in a  

[13:56] bigger system. It has to have that uh biological  functionality on that larger scale. That's a very  

[14:03] hard thing for physicists to think about because  we're used to understanding what goes on in the  

[14:10] world in terms of forces and interactions and so  on by thinking locally. You know what is happening  

[14:15] at a particular point. Give you an example. You  might uh shoot um a a proton at a at a nucleus  

[14:24] and it shatters the nucleus. And then how do we  describe what goes on in that interaction? Well,  

[14:30] it's in terms of the forces concentrated uh in  that nuclear volume. Uh we wouldn't appeal to  

[14:36] the uh you know the entire lab uh when trying to  figure out what's going on. But when it comes to  

[14:42] biology, you have to look at the organism as a  whole. It's the collective organization of the  

[14:47] whole thing and that's the difficulty. It's trying  to understand how uh information uh embedded in  

[14:54] in the organism stored in the DNA and in other  features of the organism as well can be deployed  

[15:01] uh in a manner that um supervises that overall  organization. There are many many examples that  

[15:08] I could cite but that's the gist of it. It's um  what is that semantic or meaningful or contextual  

[15:16] information that is information plus it's not  just a matter of bits. So I've said several  

[15:21] times that the information content of life it  the book of instructions if you like and uh the  

[15:28] information management is in much more than the  DNA. And so we have this term genetics and the  

[15:35] gene is a particular sequence of letters in DNA  and we can think of that as genetic information.  

[15:42] But it's very clear that there is a lot of other  information which is called epigenetic. It just  

[15:46] means outside of the genome. The question is where  is this information stored? There's networks of  

[15:52] genes that switch each other on and off. And so  these networks are one place that information  

[15:57] can be stored. There's another way which is the  DNA just doesn't sort of sit there like you see  

[16:02] in the textbooks. It's all folded up in complex  patterns and those patterns themselves can store  

[16:08] information. But the question is really whether  information outside of the genome can survive  

[16:16] uh from one generation to the next. Can it be  inherited? Back in the 19th century when it  

[16:21] became clear that life has evolved over billions  of years there were rival theories about how this  

[16:28] might happen and one of these is of course well  known as Darwin's theory of random variation and  

[16:33] natural selection but the other was due to the  French biologist and Lamar and Lamar had the  

[16:39] idea that uh maybe characteristics that organisms  acquired during their uh lifetime could somehow  

[16:47] be passed on to their progeny and give you a  sort of trivial example. Giraffes long necks,  

[16:53] you know, they're stretching to get food  higher and higher. So maybe a giraffe that  

[16:57] had to stretch its neck even higher during its  lifetime and sort of acquired an elongated neck  

[17:05] as a result would then pass it on to its progeny.  So it's its babies would have longer necks than  

[17:12] average. In other words, the characteristics you  acquire during uh a lifetime would be passed on.  

[17:18] And that theory fell out of favor. Um it seems  very easy to find counter examples. Think for  

[17:24] example of a blacksmith um acquiring huge  muscles by sort of hammering away uh every  

[17:31] day. Does the blacksmith have babies with born  with big muscles? Um well the answer is no. Uh  

[17:38] it looks like uh the uh the the the genes in the  the blacksmith's genes if you like uh are sort of  

[17:46] fixed uh early on and passed on to the offspring  and have nothing to do with the activity that the  

[17:52] uh of the blacksmith in his lifetime. And this  is a rather controversial subject. It's called  

[17:59] epigenetic inheritance. Now it's it's very clear  it can work at the cellular level. um you know  

[18:06] skin cell can make a skin cell and a liver cell  can make a liver cell and so on. So it's identity  

[18:11] uh they have identical DNA but the identity the  gene expression is different in these different  

[18:16] cells uh and yet it can be passed on but can you  have intergenerational epigenetic inheritance?  

[18:24] What I mean by that that is it possible uh for an  organism uh to pass on some of the information not  

[18:32] in its genes but in the in the the body as a whole  pass that on to its progeny. Very controversial.  

[18:39] Clearly happens in plants. But what about people?  You know, is it the case uh that what you do in  

[18:46] your lifetime might affect your children uh  whether they be taller or shorter or thinner  

[18:52] or fatter or you know even their behavior. Is is  that possible? There's a little bit of evidence  

[19:00] that it might be uh but it's contentious as  you might imagine. Anything involving human  

[19:05] beings becomes a very contentious issue. And then  the the problem is the mechanism. How would that  

[19:10] be be passed on uh through the eggs and and the  sperm? Is it possible that they could carry with  

[19:16] them something other than the DNA some chemical  or structural information that would affect how  

[19:22] uh the children develop? Um and it it seems like  an open question. I can be uh convinced. I know  

[19:29] of some experiments with mice that show that it  is possible uh even through the uh the male line  

[19:35] the the sperm uh for the progeny to uh to be  influenced in some way by the experiences of  

[19:42] the fathers in that case. So um it it's easy to  think of ways in which this might happen. There's  

[19:49] some amazing experiments by Michael Levvin and  his colleagues at Tus University using pleneria.  

[19:56] They're very popular because it's got a head and  a tail. And if you chop a worm in two, the head  

[20:02] grows a tail and the tail grows a head. So you've  then got two worms for the price of one. And you  

[20:07] can go on doing that, sort of chopping them up.  In fact, you can chop a worm like that up into,  

[20:12] you know, 100 different sections. Uh, and somehow  these sections remember which was the front and  

[20:17] which was the back and they grow into 100 uh  different worms. And that's all very amazing. Now,  

[20:24] you can chemically manipulate them such that you  can make two-headed worms and two-tailed worms.  

[20:30] But now you ask the question, what happens if  you chop a two-headed worm in half? Does that  

[20:36] reconstitute the original worm? Two worms now  with a head and a sail. No. It turns out that  

[20:42] the two-headed worm makes two more two-headed  worms. In other words, it's like a new lineage.  

[20:48] And so in a lab across town, you can have a whole  population of two-tailed worms. And in your lab,  

[20:53] you've got a whole population of two-headed worms.  You might think these are different species,  

[20:58] but they have identical DNA. So, this shows that  the morphology, the actual the phenotype is the  

[21:04] technical term that biologists use uh for uh these  worms depends on much more than the DNA content.  

[21:12] It's that information is somehow stored, possibly  electrically, possibly chemically. it's not really  

[21:18] understood somehow stored and can reconstitute the  worms into that particular uh shape afterwards. So  

[21:26] that's a clue that in just focusing on genes  we're missing a big part of the picture.

[21:37] Chapter 2 life entropy and the laws were missing.  There was a famous scientist called Rav Lando who  

[21:46] is uttered the phrase information is physical  and it stuck in my mind in the minds of a lot  

[21:51] of other people. In as much as we can talk about  information in the abstract just as you you go and  

[21:58] uh to a computer sciences department, you talk  to a software engineer uh and they're writing  

[22:03] all this uh computer code and uh uh and they  talk about it as if it's um a separate thing.  

[22:10] But of course it always has to be instantiated in  material uh some sort of material substrate. And  

[22:17] so information isn't something that can just  sort of float around in the ether on its own  

[22:22] doing its own thing. It's got to be instantiated  in matter. Uh so then we come up against this very  

[22:28] interesting thing that matter does what matter has  to do. It's got laws of physics that describe how  

[22:34] it should behave. uh and we can't say oh just  because it's encoding information um you know  

[22:40] it's going to behave differently. These laws are  mathematical relationships and that's a really  

[22:46] important point to get across. So when physicists  talk about laws uh they don't just mean um ways  

[22:52] of thinking about the world. They mean organizing  principles which are mathematical relationships.  

[22:58] And give you a simple example. You might want  to play chess on your computer. the shapes on  

[23:04] the screen move around according to the laws of  chess. Well, does that mean that uh down among  

[23:09] the secretary you got the laws of physics sort  of squabbbling with the laws of chess? You know,  

[23:13] well, well, you know, who's going to win here?  Uh, of course, it's perfectly consistent. It's  

[23:18] just that the laws of physics, we come back to  this, that operate locally. The standard laws of  

[23:24] physics we understand are local effects. the laws  of chess have to do with the overall organization  

[23:30] of the shapes on the screen and the um the  rules of the game and so on. Uh and so we're  

[23:36] uh we're dealing here with trying to understand if  we want to reconcile if we're talking about life  

[23:41] or consciousness, we want to reconcile laws which  describe the global or the context or the overall  

[23:48] arrangement of things with the local laws at the  bottom. Some people think that the mystery of life  

[23:53] is all about the second law of thermodynamics that  it's going against the trend from order to chaos.  

[24:00] Here living organisms go the other way. They  create order out of order. And that has suggested  

[24:06] to some non-scientists that there's some sort of  mystical mysterious extra ingredient or a life  

[24:11] force or some something sort of spiritual or the  guiding hand of a a deity or something which is  

[24:18] uh uh bringing these effects uh about. Um and  that's a total misunderstanding of the laws of  

[24:25] thermodynamics. I must emphasize that living  organisms are open systems. The second law  

[24:32] strictly stated says that in a closed system the  entropy can never go down. But living organisms  

[24:39] are not closed systems. There's a throughput of  energy uh and material from their environment. Um  

[24:46] and uh if you like good way of putting it is that  they can export their entropy or their chaos into  

[24:52] the wider environment. So, uh, when we eat food,  um, this, uh, helps us maintain our own internal  

[24:59] order, but we're breaking the food down and,  uh, in acquiring the food in the first place,  

[25:04] we're creating a lot of sort of chaos and  disorder in the surrounding environment. I  

[25:10] I should say that this is not deeply mysterious.  My refrigerator can perform a similar feat because  

[25:17] one of the best expressions of the second law  of thermodynamics is that heat flows from hot  

[25:22] to cold spontaneously. Now my refrigerator of  course does exactly what I've said is against  

[25:30] the second law of thermodynamics. It takes heat  from inside the refrigerator and pumps it out  

[25:35] into the kitchen which is taking heat from cold  region and putting it out into the hot region.  

[25:40] going against the trend of the second law of  thermodynamics, but it can do that because I'm  

[25:45] paying the electricity bills for it to happen.  You see, it's not happening spontaneously. If  

[25:50] you take the system as a whole, that includes the  electricity supply and the generator across town,  

[25:55] all of that means that the entropy goes up, but  locally it can go down. We can think of living  

[26:01] organisms as just sort of little entropy wells  if you like that can achieve this going against  

[26:08] the second law but at the expense of the wider  environment. Another way of thinking about life  

[26:13] and the second law of thermodynamics says that  information is like negative entropy that if you  

[26:19] gain information about something you're reducing  the amount of chaos or disorder and one of the  

[26:25] founders of thermodynamics James Maxwell came up  with a curious idea in a letter to a friend in  

[26:33] which he imagined a box of gas with a membrane in  the middle and a little hole in that membrane and  

[26:40] then one of those molecules would go through  the hole and go to the other side of the box  

[26:44] and vice versa. And in equilibrium, there'd  be a traffic in both directions that would  

[26:49] balance out. But now imagine he said that you had  a little creature later came to be called a demon  

[26:55] who could operate a shutter mechanism and could  see the molecules coming along. And supposing the  

[27:02] demon saw a fastmoving molecule coming from one  side of the box and would think, "Yes, I'll open  

[27:08] the shutter and let that one go through. But the  slowmoving molecules will be rejected. Then over  

[27:15] time there'd be an accumulation of fastoving  molecules on the other side of the membrane  

[27:20] which in terms of temperature would mean a higher  temperature. The molecules jiggling faster means  

[27:26] it's hotter on that side. So the demon would be  able to create a temperature difference between  

[27:31] the two sides in complete violation of the second  law of thermodynamics that says heat goes from  

[27:37] hot to cold. This is an example of it being pushed  in the other direction. Not by paying electricity  

[27:44] bills for a refrigerator which does the same um  but by using the information about the molecular  

[27:51] motions. So what this suggests is that information  is a type of fuel. It's something uh which could  

[27:58] be used uh to in principle create a little engine.  you create a temperature difference and then you  

[28:05] could run a motor off that temperature difference  uh using entirely from the power of information  

[28:11] that information as a fuel. Now the interesting  thing is that nature discovered Maxwell demons  

[28:17] billions of years ago because our bodies are full  of them. They're sort of chanting away inside us.  

[28:23] um uh there are pumps and and levers  and all sorts of little mechanisms,  

[28:30] little engines and so on that are carrying out  uh these um these operations playing the margins  

[28:37] of the second law of thermodynamics. I must  emphasize they don't violate the second law  

[28:42] of thermodynamics but they come very close uh  to what we might regard as the uh perfection  

[28:49] uh very close to the theoretical limit permitted  by the second law of thermodynamics. So life has  

[28:55] refined this information processing or information  as fuel uh right down to the point of having lots  

[29:02] of legions of these little molecular machines uh  which are effectively Maxwell demons carrying out  

[29:08] the business of life and the universe as a whole  is un undoubtedly on a one-way slide to a higher  

[29:16] and higher entropy state less and less useful  sources of energy and that's a cosmological story.  

[29:22] So life is not going against the trend of the  second law of thermodynamics. It's simply playing  

[29:28] the margins of it. And if I might just back up  and say that we talked earlier about Schroinger.  

[29:34] Shreddinger wrote this remarkable book, what is  life? And in it he said we must be prepared to  

[29:40] find a new kind of physical law operating in it.  The operative word there is kind, not just a new  

[29:47] physical law. In other words, he he wasn't saying,  "Well, um there's all the laws of physics we know  

[29:52] and there'll be one that we haven't discovered yet  that will explain life." Uh it would be a new kind  

[29:57] of law. And I've taken that very seriously uh  during my career. And I think that the that it  

[30:03] does need a new kind of law. It doesn't just  need another force or something of that sort.  

[30:08] Uh what it needs is a a new way of a new concept  of law. uh and it's something which I've already  

[30:15] hinted at that the the the way information and  uh matter the hardware and the software the way  

[30:22] they interact in living organisms uh we don't have  any sort of lawike framework uh on a general basis  

[30:29] for describing that we do need something uh that  would uh that put that uh biological information  

[30:36] in context that is I've explained how a a gene is  a set of instructions For a particular molecular  

[30:44] system to do something like make a a protein, it  has biological functionality, we have to relate  

[30:50] the global context of the organism to the uh  local instruction set. If we talk about law  

[30:57] of gravitational or something, why does an object  fall? It's because the gravitational field at this  

[31:02] point is acting on it. It's a local thing. when  we're talking about uh living organisms uh somehow  

[31:08] we have to take into account the organization of  the entire system the context of the assemblage  

[31:15] uh and we've got to embed that in some sort of new  type of physical law I think we're not going to do  

[31:21] this just by inventing new local laws we've got  to have a new way of thinking about laws laws of  

[31:27] physics at the bottom level with some higher level  laws of organization at the top level and we've  

[31:33] got to mesh these two in some way that people have  tried. I mean, I'm not not saying this is a lost  

[31:38] cause. Been lots of attempts um to uh describe  what's often called top- down causation. Uh what's  

[31:46] happening at the global level, it's affecting  what's happening at the at the local level.  

[31:50] uh you can write down equations and things and  some some of these are moderately successful but  

[31:55] I don't think we've really understood at a truly  fundamental level how the uh higher levels of  

[32:02] organization and the lower levels of the laws of  physics really mesh together in a fundamental way  

[32:09] uh in a general sense there's some ideas  slushing around I won't get into them they're  

[32:14] a bit technical um this is all very tentative  uh but I think we're never going to fully  

[32:20] explain life without having that new kind of  physical law as Schroinger was asking for.

[32:30] Chapter 3, are we alone? The search for a second  genesis. Part of the problem about coming up with  

[32:38] a definition of life uh and the origin of life  uh is that uh we we're guided almost entirely  

[32:45] by life on Earth. And so we can look at what were  the conditions uh on the early earth and what are  

[32:51] the conditions necessary to sustain life on earth  today. Now we don't know that these were the same  

[32:57] things. It may be uh that the origin of life  requires one set of conditions but for it to  

[33:02] thrive it's a different set of conditions. We  know life can move around. You know maybe early  

[33:07] Mars was a better place for life to get going  but early Earth was a better place for it to  

[33:12] flourish. Uh but because life primitive microbial  life can go from Mars to Earth in impact ejector.  

[33:20] That's no problem. Starts on Mars, flourishes on  Earth. Uh we we don't really know. So when we're  

[33:27] going to look for life beyond Earth, um there's  a tendency to think, well, we should look for  

[33:32] Earthlike planets. When I was a student, I was  really interested in the idea of life beyond  

[33:38] Earth. But in those days, one might have professed  an interest in looking for fairies. was considered  

[33:44] uh self-evident that there couldn't be any life  beyond earth because life is so complex it would  

[33:49] have happened only once and Francis Crick for  example who discovered the structure of DNA  

[33:55] said life seems almost a miracle so many of the  conditions necessary for it to get going so the  

[34:01] prevailing view decades ago was that life is a a  bizarre freak accident a chemical fluke of such  

[34:08] improbability that you'd only get it once in  the whole universe universe and then over the  

[34:14] decades the pendulum sort of swung and so now very  distinguished scientists are prepared to say that  

[34:19] the universe is teeming with life. Um but uh I  often criticize that by saying well when I was a  

[34:26] student nobody took that seriously. Now you're all  saying it's teameming with life. What's changed?  

[34:32] And the answer that I often get is oh well we know  that life can now live under a much wider range of  

[34:38] circumstances than when I was a student. used to  be thought that uh even hardy microbes couldn't  

[34:46] survive temperatures above you know 50 or 60  degrees Celsius then it was found that there  

[34:52] are organisms living in hot springs of much higher  temperatures than that and same goes for uh other  

[34:58] physical conditions extremes of cold extremes of  chemical pollution extremes of salinity um and so  

[35:05] these collective noun for these organisms that  survive under these conditions is extreophiles  

[35:11] And so people point to that and they say, "Well,  now we know uh that life can survive under such a  

[35:16] wide range of conditions." That greatly increases  the amount of real estate out there that we might  

[35:22] search uh to uh to to find life. And it's true  that it may be by a factor of 10 or something  

[35:30] that there are more places that we could look. Uh  but if the odds against life forming from non-life  

[35:36] uh are one in a trillion trillion, you know, an  extra factor of 10 isn't going to help you very  

[35:42] much. Uh I would like a demonstration uh or of  the discovery, just one other sample of life. Uh  

[35:49] one one microbe here on Earth that is life, but  not as we know it would do it. Two two samples  

[35:55] of life on Earth surely means that there would  be life everywhere. Everyone has their favorite  

[36:00] place to look. I like to think of Mars as the best  possibility, but there's a lot of emphasis on the  

[36:06] frigid outer moons of the solar system, Europa and  Enceladus. That's a moon of Saturn. It's got a icy  

[36:12] crust and underneath it is a liquid ocean. The icy  crust has cracks in it and spewing out of these  

[36:19] cracks are gases and the Cassini mission flew  through this plume and detected organic molecules.  

[36:28] Now, organic doesn't necessarily mean living.  Organic molecules are complex carbon molecules.  

[36:33] They may be a product of living organisms or  they may just be a pro product of complex carbon  

[36:38] chemistry. How can you tell the difference?  How would we know whether there is anything  

[36:43] spewing out in this plume uh that was maybe once  living and got mashed up or is maybe still living?  

[36:51] What you'd like to do is have an instrument to put  on board uh a spacecraft that would fly through  

[36:57] that plume, collect uh the material spearing  out and would deliver a verdict uh on on the uh  

[37:06] whether it's living or not. Uh we don't know quite  what that instrument would be. what what would be  

[37:12] um a definitive sign of life uh or for that matter  what would distinguish between something that was  

[37:19] living and is now broken down into components. Uh  so that's death if you like. That would be a death  

[37:25] meter. Uh do we have a death meter? Something that  could say yes it's dead but it was living versus  

[37:31] no it isn't quite living yet. Uh you know versus  it is alive. And that immediately gets you into  

[37:39] uh some very interesting questions. We tend  to obviously dwell on death for human beings  

[37:44] and the loss of uh of consciousness and people  worry about you know well is there some sort  

[37:51] of existence after death and so on. But I' I'd  like to uh to be a bit more scientific uh boil  

[37:58] it down to something much simpler uh to think  about. uh if we take um say a bacterium if you  

[38:06] uh cool a bacteria a bacterium down to say liquid  nitrogen temperatures it become dormant. Uh there  

[38:13] are uh uh bacteria which have been trapped uh  trapped in ice uh for example uh and can be sort  

[38:21] of resuscitated after millions of years or trapped  in salt crystals uh or in in a fridge. They're not  

[38:28] dead but they're not living either. Uh, and I  think of it a little bit like a clock. Well,  

[38:34] is a stopped clock. Still a clock. It still has  the potential to tell the time if you get it  

[38:39] started again. But if it if it's a stopped clock,  it's not a dead clock. It's a dormant clock. Um,  

[38:47] and the same thing with bacteria. Uh, that they're  not dead when they're frozen. Uh, they're simply  

[38:54] dormant and they can uh come alive again uh  in the full expression. But now that raises a  

[39:00] further question because uh it's entirely possible  that life has uh uh traveled from Earth to Mars or  

[39:10] Mars to Earth inside impact ejector. We know Mars  and Earth are hit from time to time by comets and  

[39:16] asteroids that splatters rocks all around the  solar system and organisms can hitch a ride  

[39:21] uh in these rocks and travel from Mars to Earth or  Earth to Mars. Now uh obviously that is possible.  

[39:29] We don't know if it's happened but it seems  entirely likely that it would have done. Uh the  

[39:34] biggest hazard in interplanetary space is not the  cold because these microbes would become dormant.  

[39:41] Um it is in fact the radiation. So sitting inside  a rock uh in space um a dormant bacterium is going  

[39:50] to be bombarded by cosmic rays and some radiation  from the rock itself. And so it's going to sustain  

[39:56] damage during its journey. And supposeding it's a  million years before it finally hits the earth. Uh  

[40:03] will it come alive again? Uh how much damage can  it sustain before it's gone beyond the point of  

[40:10] no return? The point I'm trying to make is that  um is a bacterium alive or dead? You can cool it  

[40:16] down and stop it working. uh and it can sustain  a certain level of damage but at some particular  

[40:25] point it won't start up again and then you might  pronounce it to be dead. But now let's consider a  

[40:31] more complicated case like Titan moon of Saturn  and Titan's very cold. It would be unlikely to  

[40:37] have life as we know it but it's full of organic  molecules. It's like a prochemical smog in its  

[40:42] atmosphere. We can imagine that it's been carrying  out like a sort of uh cosmic milleri experiment.  

[40:50] It's been uh cooking up prebiotic chemistry for  4 billion years, 4 and a half billion years. Um  

[40:57] and so uh you know has it did it succeed in making  life even if it wouldn't be life quite as we know  

[41:02] it. Um and how would we know? Imagine you sent um  some sort of life meter to Titan and it went down  

[41:10] through the atmosphere and it then uh delivered  a verdict. It uh might say, "Well, uh we didn't  

[41:16] find any life on Titan, but it did get 93.4% of  the way to life." Um or it only got, you know,  

[41:25] 5% of the way to life. Uh you know, what would  you make of that? Well, what I just said seems  

[41:30] sort of ridiculous. Um we don't have it's hard  enough to come up with a definition of life. Um  

[41:36] we don't really have a definition of almost life.  We we couldn't tell by looking uh that it was  

[41:42] nearly there. You know, give it another billion  years and it might make life. We we don't even  

[41:46] know how to think about that. Um and that's very  good metaphor. Richard Dawkins, the biologist,  

[41:52] wrote a book called Climbing Mountain Probable.  And it addresses the question of life started out  

[41:58] very simple, just microbes, and today we have the  whole complex biosphere. And some people find that  

[42:03] miraculous. Uh, but the way he likes to describe  it is that um it's it's it's a like a climbing a  

[42:11] mountain and each step might be very improbable  that you get more complexity, more order, and so  

[42:17] on. Uh but that's what natural selection does. It  is acts like a ratchet locking in the um efficient  

[42:25] more complex uh order uh and killing off the ones  that uh doesn't work so well. And so laborously  

[42:32] you climb up this mountain probable step by  step by step. Well, of course it didn't start  

[42:38] uh with microbes. There's a mountain probable that  starts with chemistry. You've got to climb all the  

[42:44] way from simple chemistry to complex chemistry to  living chemistry. the chemistry of living matter.  

[42:49] Um how do you climb that mountain probable in  that prebiotic sense? Uh and is there any way of  

[42:55] measuring what would be the elevation up mountain  probable? Can we look at a particular complex  

[43:02] uh chemical mixture and give it a probability and  say how close it has come to to actually forming  

[43:10] life. Well, I don't think we can. You see, I think  we lack uh not only lack a definition of life,  

[43:16] we lack a definition of uh even how close you  might be getting to life. And what's the point? We  

[43:24] don't even know whether the pathway from non-life  to life was just some sort of seamless upward  

[43:31] march of complexity. starting out simple over  millions and millions of years getting more and  

[43:37] more complex more and more complex until suddenly  you would say well now I guess we would call this  

[43:43] really complex thing living or whether it's more  like a phase transition like um a gas bursting  

[43:48] into flame that you would uh go along this pathway  it would get more and more complex and suddenly  

[43:54] there'd be a jump uh and you would say it sprung  into life at that particular point and then if we  

[44:00] had a life meter that could uh say where you are  on that pathway has that jump happened uh then it  

[44:08] will be worth sending that meter out into the  universe to look for somewhere else where that  

[44:14] jump may have occurred but we haven't got to that  stage yet. We don't know how to build a life meter  

[44:19] because we don't really know how to understand  this pathway uh and the threshold of life and what  

[44:26] will constitute almost life. So astrobiologists  love looking for earthlike planets beyond the  

[44:34] solar system and that's very natural. Uh but the  most earthlike planet we know is earth itself. And  

[44:39] so that raises the question about whether if life  arises readily under earthlike conditions. Might  

[44:47] it have happened more than once right here on our  home planet? How do we know it didn't? Has anybody  

[44:53] actually looked? Uh and it turns out that nobody's  really taken very seriously the idea that life  

[44:59] could have arisen on Earth many times over. Now it  could be that life started 500 times on Earth and  

[45:07] only one form of life has survived to the present  day. But can we be absolutely sure that there is  

[45:13] no other sample of life on Earth hiding somewhere  in some uh little niche uh beyond the reach of of  

[45:20] known life? Could it be that descendants from a uh  another genesis 4 billion years ago uh are still  

[45:28] here in Earth's biosphere today? Uh this is um a  very speculative idea sometimes called the shadow  

[45:36] biosphere that alongside uh the uh biosphere  that we know and love uh in intermingled among  

[45:44] the organisms the microorganisms uh that are  all around us might be some microorganisms from  

[45:51] uh another genesis event. this this would be uh  not just a different branch on the known tree of  

[45:58] life but a different tree entirely. Uh how could  we tell how how would we know if such things are  

[46:05] out there? Uh would we have spotted them? And  it turns out the answer when you look at this  

[46:09] very carefully is no. We probably wouldn't have  noticed them. They could be there uh all around  

[46:14] us. So it could be that there's second sample of  life uh alien life if you like uh right under our  

[46:20] noses or even in our noses um and nobody has  really made an effort to look. Now there's a a  

[46:28] counterargument that people like to make which is  that once one form of life gets going it sort of  

[46:34] appropriates all the resources and changes the  condition conditions uh in order to uh sustain  

[46:40] its own existence. that this would act against  any the survival of any other type of organism.  

[46:47] The classic example is when photosynthesis was  discovered by life uh I don't know 2 and a half  

[46:54] 3 billion years ago um and then uh it led to the  buildup of oxygen in the atmosphere. We tend to  

[47:01] think of oxygen as a good thing and it is for you  and me. Um but it's a terrible corrosive poison.  

[47:07] Uh and when it first appeared uh it threatened  to wipe out life totally. It was a pollutant. Uh  

[47:14] and it was only that life was able to some life  was able to adapt and actually turn a sin into a  

[47:20] virtue and use that oxygen as an energy source uh  that we are where we are today with an oxygenrich  

[47:27] atmosphere. But the buildup of oxygen has uh uh  led to more than allowing life to become more  

[47:35] energy rich, more complex. Um it's also changed  the nature of rocks, for example. Contrast the  

[47:43] Earth with Mars. You look at Mars, it's noticeably  red because that red is really rust. And so Mars  

[47:49] doesn't have this recycling mechanism. It doesn't  have plate tectonics. It doesn't have plates that  

[47:55] move around. and uh volcanoes that change it has  volcanoes but it doesn't uh manage to to cycle all  

[48:04] of these elements and so on. So there's a feedback  loop between the life on earth and the cycles that  

[48:10] drive uh life on earth uh and and each affects the  other. Um it's very unclear uh how often you would  

[48:19] come across a a planet quite like the earth which  has these interlocking cycles the biological and  

[48:25] the geological and the atmospheric all working  together to to change each other and sustain  

[48:31] each other uh which is done not just uh for a  short duration but over literally over billions  

[48:37] of years. So this these cycles have co-evolved.  It may be a very special set of circumstances.  

[48:44] It may be that it is a rare earth to use uh a  a title of a famous book. It could be as a rare  

[48:50] earth. And I think most people have the idea of  searching for alien beings as f flesh and blood  

[48:58] uh organisms, you know, weird looking animals  that you might find on another planet. But it it's  

[49:04] very clear that if there are techn technological  civilizations out there uh that they would very  

[49:10] soon um if they got to our level of development  uh begin to outsource their intellectual heavy  

[49:17] lifting uh to uh I I prefer call them design  systems. It's not artificial is a bad term.  

[49:25] I I think of it as designed intelligence. We've  got Darwinian intelligence very slow. It's taken  

[49:30] billions of years to get to this point. And then  designed intelligence can be very rapid and once  

[49:35] you embed the design principles in the designed  intelligence once AI gets the uh design principles  

[49:42] for the next generation and so on uh it it very  rapidly uh takes off. I can imagine an AI system  

[49:50] in the not too distant future that would use uh  components from living organisms uh you know from  

[49:58] uh neural tissue uh being incorporated and people  are still doing this even now incorporating those  

[50:06] uh into some larger system and that we're  we're going to lose this distinction between  

[50:10] is it living is it non-living um uh and it  really just boils down to is it designed  

[50:17] and uh and is is it designing the next generation  and so on. So, we're if if we ever do contact ET,  

[50:25] and I'm pretty skeptical, but if we ever do it, uh  it's overwhelmingly likely not to be some sort of  

[50:31] uh you know, Hollywood style flesh and  blood being, but it's going to be some  

[50:36] uh something we might want to call AI, but we we  we lack a term for what this super intelligent  

[50:43] uh multi-generation designed uh system might  be. But it's clear that the just from the way  

[50:51] we're going, it's clear that this entity would  have godlike uh uh features that we would be  

[50:57] dealing with something which would uh be probably  well beyond our level of understanding. And if we  

[51:03] combine AI with quantum computing, so it's where  it gets really interesting and really profound. So  

[51:10] we got Q AI, quantum artificial intelligence  or quintelligence as Frank Wilchek calls it.  

[51:17] uh then all bets are off because now we're dealing  with an entity that can explore not only uh all of  

[51:25] the possibilities that we can explore in our own  minds um but all possible quantum alternatives  

[51:32] all possible worlds. So we're dealing with some  sort of uh entity that intelligent or conscious  

[51:39] or it might be an agent of some sort which has  an infinitely greater uh range of possibilities  

[51:47] and experiences and uh processes that can it can  operate than we do. And if we're dealing with the  

[51:53] ET that has civilization that's been going for 500  million years or something, it's overwhelmingly  

[52:01] likely it's going to be dominated by the these  godlike totally uh mysterious awesome entities.

[52:14] Chapter 4. The Goldilocks Enigma.  Is the universe fine-tuned for life?  

[52:20] So now putting on my uh physicist hat and looking  at the universe as a whole uh I'm struck by the  

[52:28] nature of physical laws uh the fact that the  universe is ordered in a very precise mathematical  

[52:35] manner uh and that these underlying laws are  not only beautiful and powerful and represent  

[52:42] uh uh mathematical relationships uh that um  uh enable the universe to run uh in such an  

[52:51] efficient way, but they're also consistent  with the existence of life. And so this is  

[52:56] uh a subject often goes under the name of the  anthropic principle. is a very bad name. But  

[53:01] what it basically means is is the following that  if you take uh the various laws of physics and the  

[53:07] initial conditions for the universe, the way the  big bang went bang uh and if you say well suppose  

[53:13] we change something a little bit uh say you you  wanted to make all electrons a little bit heavier  

[53:18] uh or the weak nuclear force a little bit weaker,  you know, can you could you muck around with those  

[53:24] things in such a way as to still have life? And  it turns out that the answer is no. That some of  

[53:30] the laws of physics are so exquisitly sensitive  that the tiniest change would wreck the prospects  

[53:38] of life. Those changes would be literally lethal.  Now, obviously, we can't do the real experiment,  

[53:43] but we can do the mathematical experiment. We can  figure out how would the world change gravity was  

[53:48] a bit stronger or if um the uh electrical forces  were a bit weaker or something. And and when you  

[53:54] do that, you find that some rather small changes  would wreck the chances of life. Uh for example,  

[54:01] it might prevent uh complex nuclei from forming.  You might end up with a universe that consists  

[54:07] entirely of neutrons or entirely of just hydrogen  with no carbon, the life-giving element. Uh so you  

[54:14] can look at all those things and conclude that  uh the the universe uh that the laws of nature  

[54:20] in the universe as a whole seem to be and this  is where it gets uh the terminology gets a bit  

[54:26] controversial seem to be fine-tuned for life.  People talk about the fine-tuning argument.  

[54:32] Now finetuning doesn't necessarily mean uh that  there was a designer who deliberately picked those  

[54:38] values in order that there should be life. Uh, but  what it does mean is that if those numbers were a  

[54:43] bit different, there wouldn't be any life and we  wouldn't be here having this conversation. So,  

[54:47] what are we to make of this? I call this the  Goldilocks enigma that the universe looks like  

[54:52] it's just right for life. So, we have really  three possible explanations for Goldilocks.  

[54:58] We've got it's just a fluke. It happened that way  and there's nothing special about life anyway.  

[55:03] There was a designer or god who sort of made  the universe, fine-tuned it in order that life  

[55:08] should arise. And the other response that you  can take to this is the multiverse explanation  

[55:13] that the universe is just right for life because  it isn't just one universe. There's an infinite  

[55:18] number of them and it starts out sort of random.  Uh that the big bangs, lots of bangs going off  

[55:24] scattered throughout space and time and each one  comes with its own set of laws. And so in some of  

[55:29] these universes, gravity will be a bit stronger.  In some the electrons will be a bit heavier and  

[55:35] so on. Um, and in the vast vast majority of those  universes, there won't be life. And so there's no  

[55:41] one around to bemen the fact that they're not  Goldilocks universes. But here and there, uh,  

[55:46] just by the laws of chance, you're going to find,  uh, that there will be a Goldilocks universe, and  

[55:51] in that universe, there will be living creatures  like ourselves who arise and reflect on what does  

[55:58] it all mean? And so those three ideas are out  there, and that discussion continues to take  

[56:03] place. And really it boils down to at this stage  a matter of personal choice. But there is actually  

[56:09] Davis's fourth way. I've been talking about the  laws of physics in the traditional way of sort of  

[56:14] fixed immutable uh mathematical relationships.  I said stamped on the origin of the universe,  

[56:22] you know, at the outset like the maker's mark. So  in other words, the laws are fix. But you know,  

[56:28] maybe that's a simplistic way of looking at it.  It's the way that physicists have looked at the  

[56:32] laws ever since Newton as uh im immutable eternal  universal mathematical relationships. But maybe  

[56:40] uh we should think in terms of flexi laws or  something that's a bit more malleable. Uh this  

[56:44] is where it does get rather subtle because um I  if it's uh is there any way in which the emergence  

[56:52] of life and mind can be connected in some way  some causal way with the nature of the laws that  

[57:00] gives rise to them? Is there like a feedback loop  between observers like ourselves and the laws that  

[57:09] uh enable the emergence of observers? You think  well if the laws are fix that's ridiculous. Um but  

[57:17] earlier we I a very rough analogy we were talking  about the earth the way that life on earth um uh  

[57:24] the feedback loops uh the the physical nature of  our planet of planet earth and the life upon it  

[57:33] uh are connected together. So the uh existence of  life affects the way the earth behaves and so on.  

[57:38] Is there some sort of cosmic feedback loop? So the  existence of life affects the laws that then give  

[57:45] rise to that life. And at first sight you would  think that that's completely impossible. But  

[57:51] actually there is a loophole. And that loophole  arises in in quantum mechanics, quantum physics.  

[57:56] Um and the reason is uh because I've been saying  well the laws are uh the traditional way is that  

[58:02] the laws are fixed at the beginning. Um but  actually because uh quantum mechanics is based  

[58:08] on the notion of uncertainty. People have heard  of Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and what  

[58:13] it means is even if you set up very precisely  a quantum system an atom in a certain state now  

[58:19] you can't be certain how it's going to be in 1  second time but that uncertainty goes back in  

[58:25] time as well it's a fallacy to suppose that  there is a fixed history connecting the big  

[58:29] bang origin of the universe with the world today  and about 30 years ago John Wheeler the physicist  

[58:37] discovered that you could do an experiment called  the delayed choice exper experiment in which you  

[58:41] decide now what it shall have been in the past.  So in quantum mechanics something like a photon  

[58:48] can be described as a particle or it could be  described as a wave depending on the circumstances  

[58:55] and you the experimentter can choose. I will do an  experiment that will disclose the wavelike nature  

[59:01] or I shall do an experiment that will disclose  the particle-like nature. But it turns out if  

[59:07] you ask the question, well, was it a particle or  a wave one nancond ago, even before your choice,  

[59:14] it would have been what you decided in the present  moment because quantum fuzziness engulfs the past.  

[59:22] Now, you're not sending information back in  time. You're not changing the past. The past is  

[59:27] ambiguous. So, we know some things about the past,  but not everything. So if something we do today  

[59:35] resolves an ambiguity in the past, then it's not  backward causation, but it is a way in which what  

[59:43] happens now uh is linked to what happens in the  past. No doubt that this is the case in quantum  

[59:48] physics. You you can decide now what reality shall  have been in the past. We extend that from was  

[59:56] it a wave, was it a particle to are the laws of  physics themselves part of this quantum landscape?  

[1:00:02] Uh was it this law of physics? Was it that law of  physics? Now we begin to see that there's a nexus,  

[1:00:08] a way in which the existence of life and mind  [snorts] can gain some sort of patches over  

[1:00:15] the nature of the laws that have emerged in the  universe by having flexibility in the laws and  

[1:00:23] having this sort of quantum retroaction effect  uh and uh in this very subtle way. So it's it's  

[1:00:31] very easy to misunderstand what I'm saying. I'm  not saying that we now have changed the past  

[1:00:36] to ensure our own existence. Um, but there is a  consistency. There's a feedback loop that operates  

[1:00:42] in in quantum physics. So that's number four. So  you've now got it's just an accident. God did it.  

[1:00:50] There's an infinite number of universes with life  very rare but popping up somewhere. Or there's a  

[1:00:56] way in which life and the universe form part of  a common existence loop. And that idea, I should  

[1:01:02] say, is not my idea. It's the one I favor. It was  the idea that John Wheeler, the physicist, uh,  

[1:01:08] favored uh, many years ago. Was a big influence  on me. And he was the one who came up with this  

[1:01:13] delay choice experiment. And it was sort of a  springboard for his idea that participants in the  

[1:01:20] universe that is beings who have minds and choices  and can do experiments and make measurements uh  

[1:01:27] in quantum physics could be part of the whole  existence story. And I find that very appealing.

[1:01:44] Four times a year, we print a magazine worth  putting your phone down for. Big Think's  

[1:01:48] premium print magazine is built with custom  artwork and expert insight from the world's  

[1:01:52] biggest thinkers. No AI slap, no rage bait,  just big ideas for curious people. Support  

[1:01:58] the media you want to see in the world. Go to  bigthink.com/join to become a member today.

Big Think

Big Think

Artist

Big Think is a digital media platform and educational content studio that produces expert-led video essays and interviews exploring science, philosophy, psychology, and culture. Founded in 2011, Big Think reaches millions of viewers monthly with long-form thought leadership from academics, entrepreneurs, and public intellectuals.

View profile
Explore Topics
Origin of lifeInformation theoryPhysicsAbiogenesisGenetics

You might also like

View All
Who You Are Changes Every Second: The Relational Self
Inspire

Who You Are Changes Every Second: The Relational Self

Psychologist Lisa Feldman Barrett argues that traits like introvert or rude aren't sealed inside us. They describe a relationship that shift…

8 min read
Why Narcissism Is Having Its Moment, and How to Spot It Early
Inspire

Why Narcissism Is Having Its Moment, and How to Spot It Early

Clinical psychologist Ramani Durvasula has studied narcissism since the early 2000s. Here's why the topic exploded, and why "just leave" isn…

9 min read
Sacred Feminine Power: Chanting Devi Beyond the Mat
Inspire

Sacred Feminine Power: Chanting Devi Beyond the Mat

An in-person gathering in Bengaluru merges ancient devotional chanting with modern psychotherapy to explore how the Goddess archetype illumi…

8 min read
Work Isn't Your Spiritual Problem—Attachment Is
Inspire

Work Isn't Your Spiritual Problem—Attachment Is

The Bhagavad Gita teaches that career and ambition aren't obstacles to spirituality—attachment, ego, and ownership are what bind us.…

2 min read
See allYou might also like→

Continue your journey

More wisdom and gatherings from across the BrightStar directory.

More Articles

Browse the full library of teachings, interviews, and guides.

Back to all articles →

Teachers & Artists

Explore the lineages, musicians, and guides of the conscious world.

Explore artists →

Find an Event

Kirtan, retreats, sound baths, breathwork, festivals — happening soon.

Browse events →