Transcript
[0:00] My name is Paul Davies. I'm a theoretical
physicist and cosmologist by profession.
[0:05] I'm a region's professor at Arizona State
University where I'm also the director of
[0:10] the Beyond Center for Fundamental Concepts
in Science. I've written over 30 books. Uh
[0:15] the most recent is what's eating the universe and
other cosmic questions and before that the demon
[0:23] in the machine which is all about the nature of
life. This Big Think interview is brought to you
[0:28] by Pangram. Navigating an internet filled with
AI generated content is a [music] frustrating
[0:34] experience. It is becoming harder to separate real
from fake and human from machine. Pangram is the
[0:41] most trusted AI detector backed by rigorous
public research. Pangram can tell you how
[0:46] much of what you're reading is AI generated.
If there's an image you think was made by AI,
[0:51] Pangram can detect that, too. To regain trust
over what you read and see, go to www.pangram.com.
[1:00] And now back to the interview.
[1:05] [sighs] Chapter one, what is life? Definition
and information. There are really three
[1:15] origin mysteries. I like to say there's the
origin of the universe, the origin of life,
[1:20] and the origin of consciousness. Uh now most of my
career I've been working in cosmology and I would
[1:26] say that we actually understand the origin of the
universe pretty well. The origin of consciousness
[1:30] is a really tough one because we don't even know
how to frame the questions. We don't know the
[1:35] right conceptual structure uh to apply when it
comes to the nature of consciousness. I think
[1:42] it's still deeply mysterious. The origin of life
is a tough one, but we're sort of on the case, and
[1:48] I can imagine that within a few decades, we might
have a pretty good understanding. There's always
[1:53] a danger of getting hung up on the words and and
the definitions. There's a very famous definition
[2:00] of life which is based on the definition of
pornography. I know it when I see it. But if you
[2:06] want a snappy definition, one that's quite popular
at the moment is that life is chemistry plus
[2:12] information. You know, it's not like life is some
sort of magic matter or it's got some extremely
[2:20] rare ingredients. If you take uh human being and
uh break them down to their molecular structure
[2:28] and then try and sell the components on the open
market, you wouldn't get more than a few cents
[2:34] uh for the stuff that we're made of. You know,
there's nothing very special or rare uh inside
[2:40] our our bodies. So it's not what we're made of,
not the hardware. Uh it is really uh what we do,
[2:47] our behavior. Uh and that's where in the realm
of uh what we might call software. So I would
[2:53] express it this way. I'd say it's hardware and
software. These are parallel narratives. They're
[2:59] not in conflict. But I would say that the software
aspect has really been rather neglected until
[3:07] recently when it comes to trying to understand
the origin of life. But it's clear that to have a
[3:12] full understanding of life. We have to integrate
those two. I think we are very far from having
[3:16] done that. And the question of what is life of
course is not a new one. It's not just part of the
[3:24] scientific era. It goes back thousands of years
in the history of philosophy because living things
[3:29] do stand out and they struck the early Greek
philosophers as being something really special.
[3:36] For example, Aristotle had a thought about how to
connect living organisms with the wider scheme of
[3:43] things. And his view uh the nature of causation
was such that one could really attribute lifelike
[3:49] properties not just to living organisms themselves
but to the universe as a whole. Uh that is when
[3:57] you drop a stone it falls to the ground. Why is
that? not as we would think today because of the
[4:02] force of gravity uh but because it had a natural
place uh down there. it was trying to get to its
[4:08] uh its natural place. And so in that sense it was
goal oriented. And if we go back 100 150 years,
[4:16] there was this notion that well, you know,
maybe uh uh life requires some additional
[4:22] um force or uh lam vital as what it was expressed
in French or some some uh something to animate the
[4:32] matter that you might have complex matter but
you need to sort of have some other uh type of
[4:38] uh essence which would infuse it and would make
it come alive. um uh and do its amazing things.
[4:45] And so that was known as vitalism and uh over the
years came to be associated with a number of other
[4:53] things in physics like electricity perhaps or
maybe radioactivity you know or some mysterious
[5:00] force that we didn't uh yet fully understand.
Um and and those ideas I think became pretty
[5:08] thoroughly discredited. Now Darwin had a brilliant
theory of how life evolves once it gets going on
[5:15] planet earth, how it has evolved over billions of
years to give us the complexity of the biosphere
[5:20] that we see today. But he wouldn't be drawn on how
life got started in the first place. So addressing
[5:26] the question of what is life, you inevitably come
up against this question, well how does non-life
[5:31] turn into life? You know, what is that extra
special thing it acquires on that pathway? Darwin
[5:37] said it's a wonderful quote. It's mere rubbish at
this time talking of the origin of life. One might
[5:42] as well talk about the origin of matter. But by
about the 1920s, uh there was increasing interest
[5:49] in the what we might call the chemical pathway.
I think it's pretty obvious that life is based
[5:54] on chemistry. So what sort of chemical magic
took place to conjure life into being in the
[6:02] uh first stages? And there were attempts to
cook up life in the lab. In the early 1950s,
[6:09] the chemist Harold Yuri managed to interest a
young student Stanley Miller in attempting to
[6:15] recreate the conditions on the early Earth. They
didn't really know what those conditions were,
[6:20] but they had a guess that there would be certain
gases in the atmosphere and water and lightning
[6:26] and and so on. And so Miller did this uh early
experiment in which he put a number of um gases
[6:34] in a in a flask and sparked electricity through
it for a week and was gratified to find that the
[6:41] building blocks of proteins called amino acids,
simple molecules, um were made in this process.
[6:48] And there was sort of brown sludge in the bottom
of the flask. And so that really looked like
[6:53] uh that was uh that was on the pathway to life.
But again um you see this this lacked a definition
[7:00] of life. It it was an attempt to define life in
terms of its chemical components not in terms
[7:06] of what it does. So I would say that that was
addressing the problem of the hardware of life
[7:12] but not the software. And if we fast forward to
today I think this is still a very deep problem.
[7:18] If you want to focus a definition of life just
on the hardware, just on its chemical components,
[7:25] uh well, we made a bit of progress. Um not much
I might say from that early Miller experiment. Um
[7:31] there people have gone on to do more of these
prebiotic experiments, but they haven't got
[7:37] very far down that pathway to life. Now quantum
mechanics with its brilliant uh start in 1925 went
[7:45] on within a very few years to explain the nature
of matter all the way from subatomic particles
[7:52] up to stars and Irvin Schroinger he was one of
the founders of quantum mechanics wrote a book
[7:57] called what is life and in his book Schroinger
drew attention to the fact that life is as I've
[8:03] stated it earlier chemistry plus information that
the information content of life was key to how it
[8:10] operates. He was also very clear that uh for
the stability of that information, one had to
[8:15] use quantum mechanics. He came up with a metaphor
which is a rather beautiful one. He said that this
[8:21] biological information uh would have to be stored
in something like an aeriodic crystal. What does
[8:28] that mean? Well, a crystal is of course familiar
to everybody. It's a very simple thing. It's a
[8:32] very stable structure. Think of a salt crystal.
It's just a geometrically repeating pattern of
[8:37] atoms. no problem about that except that that
can't store very much information because it's
[8:43] just too simple. So he wanted something that had
the stability of a crystal uh but would not just
[8:49] have that simple periodicity but could have um
a vast number of alternative arrangements and
[8:55] permutations of its components. So he had this
idea of an a periodic crystal. didn't know at the
[9:00] time what that molecule might be but it took
Crick and Watson's famous analysis of DNA to
[9:08] declare that that was the life molecule and now we
would say it's contains the book of life it codes
[9:14] the information uh that is necessary to build the
organism in that a periodic crystal called DNA
[9:22] I think the concept of information is absolutely
critical to understanding the distinction between
[9:27] uh life and non-life People use this term
information in a very informal way in daily
[9:33] life. Uh and we have after all information
technology. Uh and so uh what is it and why
[9:40] is it that this thing called information uh is
the key to life? A pretty good general definition
[9:46] of information is reduction in uncertainty. Just
give you a simple example. You might flip a coin
[9:53] and may come down heads, may come down tails.
You don't know which. But if you look and find
[9:58] out that uncertainty 50/50 is reduced, you are
certain it's say heads and that means you've
[10:05] acquired a bit of information. And I use that word
adverisedly because to the technical definition is
[10:10] indeed one bit. It's a short for a binary digit.
And so the information from inspecting a flip coin
[10:16] is one bit of reduction in your uncertainty.
And you can build upon that and that's a way
[10:21] of quantifying information. And there's an entire
branch of science and engineering uh information
[10:27] theory which is just based on that rather austere
definition. But when it comes to life it's very
[10:34] clear that there's something else involved
because if we think for example of bacteria
[10:39] you could take out its DNA. This is routinely
done. You can edit that DNA and put it back and
[10:45] get the bacterium to do something a bit different.
But if you take out its DNA and just scramble it,
[10:51] just shuffle the base pairs of that DNA and
put it back so that it's just gobbledygook,
[10:56] then the bacterium is in effect dead. I've
got the same amount of information in the DNA,
[11:02] but it's not going to do anything and it will
slowly just decompose. In other words, it's like a
[11:07] book. If you take the words in that book and then
just shuffle them randomly and then you'd have
[11:12] a book with the same information content, but it
wouldn't mean anything. And that's the point about
[11:17] life. The information in the DNA, and I might say
it's only a small part of the total information
[11:23] content of living organisms. There's a whole lot
of what we call epigenetic information outside
[11:28] of DNA as well. But you take the whole thing. Uh
it is so effective because it means something. So
[11:35] that's the software component that's been refined
over billions of years as an operating system.
[11:42] And uh when a bacterium uh divides and makes
a new organism when it replicates it has to
[11:49] uh upload that um that uh information that uh
program into the progeny for the whole thing to
[11:57] function. So this is the way that life works.
Uh and without the instructions it it isn't
[12:03] life. It's just complex chemistry. So how did
that come to exist in the first place? How did
[12:09] that genetic code arise? It's, you know, it's a
pretty clever sophisticated sort of thing. Um,
[12:15] what did it, was there a simpler precursor
code? If you go back four billion years,
[12:20] were there organisms using a dick code instead of
a triplet code? Were there less amino acids? But
[12:26] how did that notion of coded information uh come
about in the first place? I I think that is the
[12:34] for me the point about the origin of life is how
did the molecules the complex molecules that make
[12:41] up life write their own code their own computer
code cuz that's what it amounts to uh how did
[12:47] how did that happen I think that's a deep mystery
I don't think uh we we've got anywhere close to
[12:53] understanding uh that particular step but for me
if I think about you know what was the critical
[12:59] point at which you say it's alive uh in in that
uh pathway from just complex chemistry to a truly
[13:06] living thing. It's at the point that you get that
abstract mathematical code appearing uh we don't
[13:13] know how that that happened but that would be the
point for me uh at which you would say it's the
[13:18] origin of life. So if I stand back and look at
uh the the the magic of life, the way it is uh
[13:27] performing its amazing feats, uh then it it just
seems to me that the correct words that come to my
[13:34] mind are information management. It's the way that
the information is not just a headcount of bits,
[13:40] not just the content, but the way that information
is managing or organizing or supervising what
[13:48] life does. And so that information has to be
in a context. It's got to be embedded in a
[13:56] bigger system. It has to have that uh biological
functionality on that larger scale. That's a very
[14:03] hard thing for physicists to think about because
we're used to understanding what goes on in the
[14:10] world in terms of forces and interactions and so
on by thinking locally. You know what is happening
[14:15] at a particular point. Give you an example. You
might uh shoot um a a proton at a at a nucleus
[14:24] and it shatters the nucleus. And then how do we
describe what goes on in that interaction? Well,
[14:30] it's in terms of the forces concentrated uh in
that nuclear volume. Uh we wouldn't appeal to
[14:36] the uh you know the entire lab uh when trying to
figure out what's going on. But when it comes to
[14:42] biology, you have to look at the organism as a
whole. It's the collective organization of the
[14:47] whole thing and that's the difficulty. It's trying
to understand how uh information uh embedded in
[14:54] in the organism stored in the DNA and in other
features of the organism as well can be deployed
[15:01] uh in a manner that um supervises that overall
organization. There are many many examples that
[15:08] I could cite but that's the gist of it. It's um
what is that semantic or meaningful or contextual
[15:16] information that is information plus it's not
just a matter of bits. So I've said several
[15:21] times that the information content of life it
the book of instructions if you like and uh the
[15:28] information management is in much more than the
DNA. And so we have this term genetics and the
[15:35] gene is a particular sequence of letters in DNA
and we can think of that as genetic information.
[15:42] But it's very clear that there is a lot of other
information which is called epigenetic. It just
[15:46] means outside of the genome. The question is where
is this information stored? There's networks of
[15:52] genes that switch each other on and off. And so
these networks are one place that information
[15:57] can be stored. There's another way which is the
DNA just doesn't sort of sit there like you see
[16:02] in the textbooks. It's all folded up in complex
patterns and those patterns themselves can store
[16:08] information. But the question is really whether
information outside of the genome can survive
[16:16] uh from one generation to the next. Can it be
inherited? Back in the 19th century when it
[16:21] became clear that life has evolved over billions
of years there were rival theories about how this
[16:28] might happen and one of these is of course well
known as Darwin's theory of random variation and
[16:33] natural selection but the other was due to the
French biologist and Lamar and Lamar had the
[16:39] idea that uh maybe characteristics that organisms
acquired during their uh lifetime could somehow
[16:47] be passed on to their progeny and give you a
sort of trivial example. Giraffes long necks,
[16:53] you know, they're stretching to get food
higher and higher. So maybe a giraffe that
[16:57] had to stretch its neck even higher during its
lifetime and sort of acquired an elongated neck
[17:05] as a result would then pass it on to its progeny.
So it's its babies would have longer necks than
[17:12] average. In other words, the characteristics you
acquire during uh a lifetime would be passed on.
[17:18] And that theory fell out of favor. Um it seems
very easy to find counter examples. Think for
[17:24] example of a blacksmith um acquiring huge
muscles by sort of hammering away uh every
[17:31] day. Does the blacksmith have babies with born
with big muscles? Um well the answer is no. Uh
[17:38] it looks like uh the uh the the the genes in the
the blacksmith's genes if you like uh are sort of
[17:46] fixed uh early on and passed on to the offspring
and have nothing to do with the activity that the
[17:52] uh of the blacksmith in his lifetime. And this
is a rather controversial subject. It's called
[17:59] epigenetic inheritance. Now it's it's very clear
it can work at the cellular level. um you know
[18:06] skin cell can make a skin cell and a liver cell
can make a liver cell and so on. So it's identity
[18:11] uh they have identical DNA but the identity the
gene expression is different in these different
[18:16] cells uh and yet it can be passed on but can you
have intergenerational epigenetic inheritance?
[18:24] What I mean by that that is it possible uh for an
organism uh to pass on some of the information not
[18:32] in its genes but in the in the the body as a whole
pass that on to its progeny. Very controversial.
[18:39] Clearly happens in plants. But what about people?
You know, is it the case uh that what you do in
[18:46] your lifetime might affect your children uh
whether they be taller or shorter or thinner
[18:52] or fatter or you know even their behavior. Is is
that possible? There's a little bit of evidence
[19:00] that it might be uh but it's contentious as
you might imagine. Anything involving human
[19:05] beings becomes a very contentious issue. And then
the the problem is the mechanism. How would that
[19:10] be be passed on uh through the eggs and and the
sperm? Is it possible that they could carry with
[19:16] them something other than the DNA some chemical
or structural information that would affect how
[19:22] uh the children develop? Um and it it seems like
an open question. I can be uh convinced. I know
[19:29] of some experiments with mice that show that it
is possible uh even through the uh the male line
[19:35] the the sperm uh for the progeny to uh to be
influenced in some way by the experiences of
[19:42] the fathers in that case. So um it it's easy to
think of ways in which this might happen. There's
[19:49] some amazing experiments by Michael Levvin and
his colleagues at Tus University using pleneria.
[19:56] They're very popular because it's got a head and
a tail. And if you chop a worm in two, the head
[20:02] grows a tail and the tail grows a head. So you've
then got two worms for the price of one. And you
[20:07] can go on doing that, sort of chopping them up.
In fact, you can chop a worm like that up into,
[20:12] you know, 100 different sections. Uh, and somehow
these sections remember which was the front and
[20:17] which was the back and they grow into 100 uh
different worms. And that's all very amazing. Now,
[20:24] you can chemically manipulate them such that you
can make two-headed worms and two-tailed worms.
[20:30] But now you ask the question, what happens if
you chop a two-headed worm in half? Does that
[20:36] reconstitute the original worm? Two worms now
with a head and a sail. No. It turns out that
[20:42] the two-headed worm makes two more two-headed
worms. In other words, it's like a new lineage.
[20:48] And so in a lab across town, you can have a whole
population of two-tailed worms. And in your lab,
[20:53] you've got a whole population of two-headed worms.
You might think these are different species,
[20:58] but they have identical DNA. So, this shows that
the morphology, the actual the phenotype is the
[21:04] technical term that biologists use uh for uh these
worms depends on much more than the DNA content.
[21:12] It's that information is somehow stored, possibly
electrically, possibly chemically. it's not really
[21:18] understood somehow stored and can reconstitute the
worms into that particular uh shape afterwards. So
[21:26] that's a clue that in just focusing on genes
we're missing a big part of the picture.
[21:37] Chapter 2 life entropy and the laws were missing.
There was a famous scientist called Rav Lando who
[21:46] is uttered the phrase information is physical
and it stuck in my mind in the minds of a lot
[21:51] of other people. In as much as we can talk about
information in the abstract just as you you go and
[21:58] uh to a computer sciences department, you talk
to a software engineer uh and they're writing
[22:03] all this uh computer code and uh uh and they
talk about it as if it's um a separate thing.
[22:10] But of course it always has to be instantiated in
material uh some sort of material substrate. And
[22:17] so information isn't something that can just
sort of float around in the ether on its own
[22:22] doing its own thing. It's got to be instantiated
in matter. Uh so then we come up against this very
[22:28] interesting thing that matter does what matter has
to do. It's got laws of physics that describe how
[22:34] it should behave. uh and we can't say oh just
because it's encoding information um you know
[22:40] it's going to behave differently. These laws are
mathematical relationships and that's a really
[22:46] important point to get across. So when physicists
talk about laws uh they don't just mean um ways
[22:52] of thinking about the world. They mean organizing
principles which are mathematical relationships.
[22:58] And give you a simple example. You might want
to play chess on your computer. the shapes on
[23:04] the screen move around according to the laws of
chess. Well, does that mean that uh down among
[23:09] the secretary you got the laws of physics sort
of squabbbling with the laws of chess? You know,
[23:13] well, well, you know, who's going to win here?
Uh, of course, it's perfectly consistent. It's
[23:18] just that the laws of physics, we come back to
this, that operate locally. The standard laws of
[23:24] physics we understand are local effects. the laws
of chess have to do with the overall organization
[23:30] of the shapes on the screen and the um the
rules of the game and so on. Uh and so we're
[23:36] uh we're dealing here with trying to understand if
we want to reconcile if we're talking about life
[23:41] or consciousness, we want to reconcile laws which
describe the global or the context or the overall
[23:48] arrangement of things with the local laws at the
bottom. Some people think that the mystery of life
[23:53] is all about the second law of thermodynamics that
it's going against the trend from order to chaos.
[24:00] Here living organisms go the other way. They
create order out of order. And that has suggested
[24:06] to some non-scientists that there's some sort of
mystical mysterious extra ingredient or a life
[24:11] force or some something sort of spiritual or the
guiding hand of a a deity or something which is
[24:18] uh uh bringing these effects uh about. Um and
that's a total misunderstanding of the laws of
[24:25] thermodynamics. I must emphasize that living
organisms are open systems. The second law
[24:32] strictly stated says that in a closed system the
entropy can never go down. But living organisms
[24:39] are not closed systems. There's a throughput of
energy uh and material from their environment. Um
[24:46] and uh if you like good way of putting it is that
they can export their entropy or their chaos into
[24:52] the wider environment. So, uh, when we eat food,
um, this, uh, helps us maintain our own internal
[24:59] order, but we're breaking the food down and,
uh, in acquiring the food in the first place,
[25:04] we're creating a lot of sort of chaos and
disorder in the surrounding environment. I
[25:10] I should say that this is not deeply mysterious.
My refrigerator can perform a similar feat because
[25:17] one of the best expressions of the second law
of thermodynamics is that heat flows from hot
[25:22] to cold spontaneously. Now my refrigerator of
course does exactly what I've said is against
[25:30] the second law of thermodynamics. It takes heat
from inside the refrigerator and pumps it out
[25:35] into the kitchen which is taking heat from cold
region and putting it out into the hot region.
[25:40] going against the trend of the second law of
thermodynamics, but it can do that because I'm
[25:45] paying the electricity bills for it to happen.
You see, it's not happening spontaneously. If
[25:50] you take the system as a whole, that includes the
electricity supply and the generator across town,
[25:55] all of that means that the entropy goes up, but
locally it can go down. We can think of living
[26:01] organisms as just sort of little entropy wells
if you like that can achieve this going against
[26:08] the second law but at the expense of the wider
environment. Another way of thinking about life
[26:13] and the second law of thermodynamics says that
information is like negative entropy that if you
[26:19] gain information about something you're reducing
the amount of chaos or disorder and one of the
[26:25] founders of thermodynamics James Maxwell came up
with a curious idea in a letter to a friend in
[26:33] which he imagined a box of gas with a membrane in
the middle and a little hole in that membrane and
[26:40] then one of those molecules would go through
the hole and go to the other side of the box
[26:44] and vice versa. And in equilibrium, there'd
be a traffic in both directions that would
[26:49] balance out. But now imagine he said that you had
a little creature later came to be called a demon
[26:55] who could operate a shutter mechanism and could
see the molecules coming along. And supposing the
[27:02] demon saw a fastmoving molecule coming from one
side of the box and would think, "Yes, I'll open
[27:08] the shutter and let that one go through. But the
slowmoving molecules will be rejected. Then over
[27:15] time there'd be an accumulation of fastoving
molecules on the other side of the membrane
[27:20] which in terms of temperature would mean a higher
temperature. The molecules jiggling faster means
[27:26] it's hotter on that side. So the demon would be
able to create a temperature difference between
[27:31] the two sides in complete violation of the second
law of thermodynamics that says heat goes from
[27:37] hot to cold. This is an example of it being pushed
in the other direction. Not by paying electricity
[27:44] bills for a refrigerator which does the same um
but by using the information about the molecular
[27:51] motions. So what this suggests is that information
is a type of fuel. It's something uh which could
[27:58] be used uh to in principle create a little engine.
you create a temperature difference and then you
[28:05] could run a motor off that temperature difference
uh using entirely from the power of information
[28:11] that information as a fuel. Now the interesting
thing is that nature discovered Maxwell demons
[28:17] billions of years ago because our bodies are full
of them. They're sort of chanting away inside us.
[28:23] um uh there are pumps and and levers
and all sorts of little mechanisms,
[28:30] little engines and so on that are carrying out
uh these um these operations playing the margins
[28:37] of the second law of thermodynamics. I must
emphasize they don't violate the second law
[28:42] of thermodynamics but they come very close uh
to what we might regard as the uh perfection
[28:49] uh very close to the theoretical limit permitted
by the second law of thermodynamics. So life has
[28:55] refined this information processing or information
as fuel uh right down to the point of having lots
[29:02] of legions of these little molecular machines uh
which are effectively Maxwell demons carrying out
[29:08] the business of life and the universe as a whole
is un undoubtedly on a one-way slide to a higher
[29:16] and higher entropy state less and less useful
sources of energy and that's a cosmological story.
[29:22] So life is not going against the trend of the
second law of thermodynamics. It's simply playing
[29:28] the margins of it. And if I might just back up
and say that we talked earlier about Schroinger.
[29:34] Shreddinger wrote this remarkable book, what is
life? And in it he said we must be prepared to
[29:40] find a new kind of physical law operating in it.
The operative word there is kind, not just a new
[29:47] physical law. In other words, he he wasn't saying,
"Well, um there's all the laws of physics we know
[29:52] and there'll be one that we haven't discovered yet
that will explain life." Uh it would be a new kind
[29:57] of law. And I've taken that very seriously uh
during my career. And I think that the that it
[30:03] does need a new kind of law. It doesn't just
need another force or something of that sort.
[30:08] Uh what it needs is a a new way of a new concept
of law. uh and it's something which I've already
[30:15] hinted at that the the the way information and
uh matter the hardware and the software the way
[30:22] they interact in living organisms uh we don't have
any sort of lawike framework uh on a general basis
[30:29] for describing that we do need something uh that
would uh that put that uh biological information
[30:36] in context that is I've explained how a a gene is
a set of instructions For a particular molecular
[30:44] system to do something like make a a protein, it
has biological functionality, we have to relate
[30:50] the global context of the organism to the uh
local instruction set. If we talk about law
[30:57] of gravitational or something, why does an object
fall? It's because the gravitational field at this
[31:02] point is acting on it. It's a local thing. when
we're talking about uh living organisms uh somehow
[31:08] we have to take into account the organization of
the entire system the context of the assemblage
[31:15] uh and we've got to embed that in some sort of new
type of physical law I think we're not going to do
[31:21] this just by inventing new local laws we've got
to have a new way of thinking about laws laws of
[31:27] physics at the bottom level with some higher level
laws of organization at the top level and we've
[31:33] got to mesh these two in some way that people have
tried. I mean, I'm not not saying this is a lost
[31:38] cause. Been lots of attempts um to uh describe
what's often called top- down causation. Uh what's
[31:46] happening at the global level, it's affecting
what's happening at the at the local level.
[31:50] uh you can write down equations and things and
some some of these are moderately successful but
[31:55] I don't think we've really understood at a truly
fundamental level how the uh higher levels of
[32:02] organization and the lower levels of the laws of
physics really mesh together in a fundamental way
[32:09] uh in a general sense there's some ideas
slushing around I won't get into them they're
[32:14] a bit technical um this is all very tentative
uh but I think we're never going to fully
[32:20] explain life without having that new kind of
physical law as Schroinger was asking for.
[32:30] Chapter 3, are we alone? The search for a second
genesis. Part of the problem about coming up with
[32:38] a definition of life uh and the origin of life
uh is that uh we we're guided almost entirely
[32:45] by life on Earth. And so we can look at what were
the conditions uh on the early earth and what are
[32:51] the conditions necessary to sustain life on earth
today. Now we don't know that these were the same
[32:57] things. It may be uh that the origin of life
requires one set of conditions but for it to
[33:02] thrive it's a different set of conditions. We
know life can move around. You know maybe early
[33:07] Mars was a better place for life to get going
but early Earth was a better place for it to
[33:12] flourish. Uh but because life primitive microbial
life can go from Mars to Earth in impact ejector.
[33:20] That's no problem. Starts on Mars, flourishes on
Earth. Uh we we don't really know. So when we're
[33:27] going to look for life beyond Earth, um there's
a tendency to think, well, we should look for
[33:32] Earthlike planets. When I was a student, I was
really interested in the idea of life beyond
[33:38] Earth. But in those days, one might have professed
an interest in looking for fairies. was considered
[33:44] uh self-evident that there couldn't be any life
beyond earth because life is so complex it would
[33:49] have happened only once and Francis Crick for
example who discovered the structure of DNA
[33:55] said life seems almost a miracle so many of the
conditions necessary for it to get going so the
[34:01] prevailing view decades ago was that life is a a
bizarre freak accident a chemical fluke of such
[34:08] improbability that you'd only get it once in
the whole universe universe and then over the
[34:14] decades the pendulum sort of swung and so now very
distinguished scientists are prepared to say that
[34:19] the universe is teeming with life. Um but uh I
often criticize that by saying well when I was a
[34:26] student nobody took that seriously. Now you're all
saying it's teameming with life. What's changed?
[34:32] And the answer that I often get is oh well we know
that life can now live under a much wider range of
[34:38] circumstances than when I was a student. used to
be thought that uh even hardy microbes couldn't
[34:46] survive temperatures above you know 50 or 60
degrees Celsius then it was found that there
[34:52] are organisms living in hot springs of much higher
temperatures than that and same goes for uh other
[34:58] physical conditions extremes of cold extremes of
chemical pollution extremes of salinity um and so
[35:05] these collective noun for these organisms that
survive under these conditions is extreophiles
[35:11] And so people point to that and they say, "Well,
now we know uh that life can survive under such a
[35:16] wide range of conditions." That greatly increases
the amount of real estate out there that we might
[35:22] search uh to uh to to find life. And it's true
that it may be by a factor of 10 or something
[35:30] that there are more places that we could look. Uh
but if the odds against life forming from non-life
[35:36] uh are one in a trillion trillion, you know, an
extra factor of 10 isn't going to help you very
[35:42] much. Uh I would like a demonstration uh or of
the discovery, just one other sample of life. Uh
[35:49] one one microbe here on Earth that is life, but
not as we know it would do it. Two two samples
[35:55] of life on Earth surely means that there would
be life everywhere. Everyone has their favorite
[36:00] place to look. I like to think of Mars as the best
possibility, but there's a lot of emphasis on the
[36:06] frigid outer moons of the solar system, Europa and
Enceladus. That's a moon of Saturn. It's got a icy
[36:12] crust and underneath it is a liquid ocean. The icy
crust has cracks in it and spewing out of these
[36:19] cracks are gases and the Cassini mission flew
through this plume and detected organic molecules.
[36:28] Now, organic doesn't necessarily mean living.
Organic molecules are complex carbon molecules.
[36:33] They may be a product of living organisms or
they may just be a pro product of complex carbon
[36:38] chemistry. How can you tell the difference?
How would we know whether there is anything
[36:43] spewing out in this plume uh that was maybe once
living and got mashed up or is maybe still living?
[36:51] What you'd like to do is have an instrument to put
on board uh a spacecraft that would fly through
[36:57] that plume, collect uh the material spearing
out and would deliver a verdict uh on on the uh
[37:06] whether it's living or not. Uh we don't know quite
what that instrument would be. what what would be
[37:12] um a definitive sign of life uh or for that matter
what would distinguish between something that was
[37:19] living and is now broken down into components. Uh
so that's death if you like. That would be a death
[37:25] meter. Uh do we have a death meter? Something that
could say yes it's dead but it was living versus
[37:31] no it isn't quite living yet. Uh you know versus
it is alive. And that immediately gets you into
[37:39] uh some very interesting questions. We tend
to obviously dwell on death for human beings
[37:44] and the loss of uh of consciousness and people
worry about you know well is there some sort
[37:51] of existence after death and so on. But I' I'd
like to uh to be a bit more scientific uh boil
[37:58] it down to something much simpler uh to think
about. uh if we take um say a bacterium if you
[38:06] uh cool a bacteria a bacterium down to say liquid
nitrogen temperatures it become dormant. Uh there
[38:13] are uh uh bacteria which have been trapped uh
trapped in ice uh for example uh and can be sort
[38:21] of resuscitated after millions of years or trapped
in salt crystals uh or in in a fridge. They're not
[38:28] dead but they're not living either. Uh, and I
think of it a little bit like a clock. Well,
[38:34] is a stopped clock. Still a clock. It still has
the potential to tell the time if you get it
[38:39] started again. But if it if it's a stopped clock,
it's not a dead clock. It's a dormant clock. Um,
[38:47] and the same thing with bacteria. Uh, that they're
not dead when they're frozen. Uh, they're simply
[38:54] dormant and they can uh come alive again uh
in the full expression. But now that raises a
[39:00] further question because uh it's entirely possible
that life has uh uh traveled from Earth to Mars or
[39:10] Mars to Earth inside impact ejector. We know Mars
and Earth are hit from time to time by comets and
[39:16] asteroids that splatters rocks all around the
solar system and organisms can hitch a ride
[39:21] uh in these rocks and travel from Mars to Earth or
Earth to Mars. Now uh obviously that is possible.
[39:29] We don't know if it's happened but it seems
entirely likely that it would have done. Uh the
[39:34] biggest hazard in interplanetary space is not the
cold because these microbes would become dormant.
[39:41] Um it is in fact the radiation. So sitting inside
a rock uh in space um a dormant bacterium is going
[39:50] to be bombarded by cosmic rays and some radiation
from the rock itself. And so it's going to sustain
[39:56] damage during its journey. And supposeding it's a
million years before it finally hits the earth. Uh
[40:03] will it come alive again? Uh how much damage can
it sustain before it's gone beyond the point of
[40:10] no return? The point I'm trying to make is that
um is a bacterium alive or dead? You can cool it
[40:16] down and stop it working. uh and it can sustain
a certain level of damage but at some particular
[40:25] point it won't start up again and then you might
pronounce it to be dead. But now let's consider a
[40:31] more complicated case like Titan moon of Saturn
and Titan's very cold. It would be unlikely to
[40:37] have life as we know it but it's full of organic
molecules. It's like a prochemical smog in its
[40:42] atmosphere. We can imagine that it's been carrying
out like a sort of uh cosmic milleri experiment.
[40:50] It's been uh cooking up prebiotic chemistry for
4 billion years, 4 and a half billion years. Um
[40:57] and so uh you know has it did it succeed in making
life even if it wouldn't be life quite as we know
[41:02] it. Um and how would we know? Imagine you sent um
some sort of life meter to Titan and it went down
[41:10] through the atmosphere and it then uh delivered
a verdict. It uh might say, "Well, uh we didn't
[41:16] find any life on Titan, but it did get 93.4% of
the way to life." Um or it only got, you know,
[41:25] 5% of the way to life. Uh you know, what would
you make of that? Well, what I just said seems
[41:30] sort of ridiculous. Um we don't have it's hard
enough to come up with a definition of life. Um
[41:36] we don't really have a definition of almost life.
We we couldn't tell by looking uh that it was
[41:42] nearly there. You know, give it another billion
years and it might make life. We we don't even
[41:46] know how to think about that. Um and that's very
good metaphor. Richard Dawkins, the biologist,
[41:52] wrote a book called Climbing Mountain Probable.
And it addresses the question of life started out
[41:58] very simple, just microbes, and today we have the
whole complex biosphere. And some people find that
[42:03] miraculous. Uh, but the way he likes to describe
it is that um it's it's it's a like a climbing a
[42:11] mountain and each step might be very improbable
that you get more complexity, more order, and so
[42:17] on. Uh but that's what natural selection does. It
is acts like a ratchet locking in the um efficient
[42:25] more complex uh order uh and killing off the ones
that uh doesn't work so well. And so laborously
[42:32] you climb up this mountain probable step by
step by step. Well, of course it didn't start
[42:38] uh with microbes. There's a mountain probable that
starts with chemistry. You've got to climb all the
[42:44] way from simple chemistry to complex chemistry to
living chemistry. the chemistry of living matter.
[42:49] Um how do you climb that mountain probable in
that prebiotic sense? Uh and is there any way of
[42:55] measuring what would be the elevation up mountain
probable? Can we look at a particular complex
[43:02] uh chemical mixture and give it a probability and
say how close it has come to to actually forming
[43:10] life. Well, I don't think we can. You see, I think
we lack uh not only lack a definition of life,
[43:16] we lack a definition of uh even how close you
might be getting to life. And what's the point? We
[43:24] don't even know whether the pathway from non-life
to life was just some sort of seamless upward
[43:31] march of complexity. starting out simple over
millions and millions of years getting more and
[43:37] more complex more and more complex until suddenly
you would say well now I guess we would call this
[43:43] really complex thing living or whether it's more
like a phase transition like um a gas bursting
[43:48] into flame that you would uh go along this pathway
it would get more and more complex and suddenly
[43:54] there'd be a jump uh and you would say it sprung
into life at that particular point and then if we
[44:00] had a life meter that could uh say where you are
on that pathway has that jump happened uh then it
[44:08] will be worth sending that meter out into the
universe to look for somewhere else where that
[44:14] jump may have occurred but we haven't got to that
stage yet. We don't know how to build a life meter
[44:19] because we don't really know how to understand
this pathway uh and the threshold of life and what
[44:26] will constitute almost life. So astrobiologists
love looking for earthlike planets beyond the
[44:34] solar system and that's very natural. Uh but the
most earthlike planet we know is earth itself. And
[44:39] so that raises the question about whether if life
arises readily under earthlike conditions. Might
[44:47] it have happened more than once right here on our
home planet? How do we know it didn't? Has anybody
[44:53] actually looked? Uh and it turns out that nobody's
really taken very seriously the idea that life
[44:59] could have arisen on Earth many times over. Now it
could be that life started 500 times on Earth and
[45:07] only one form of life has survived to the present
day. But can we be absolutely sure that there is
[45:13] no other sample of life on Earth hiding somewhere
in some uh little niche uh beyond the reach of of
[45:20] known life? Could it be that descendants from a uh
another genesis 4 billion years ago uh are still
[45:28] here in Earth's biosphere today? Uh this is um a
very speculative idea sometimes called the shadow
[45:36] biosphere that alongside uh the uh biosphere
that we know and love uh in intermingled among
[45:44] the organisms the microorganisms uh that are
all around us might be some microorganisms from
[45:51] uh another genesis event. this this would be uh
not just a different branch on the known tree of
[45:58] life but a different tree entirely. Uh how could
we tell how how would we know if such things are
[46:05] out there? Uh would we have spotted them? And
it turns out the answer when you look at this
[46:09] very carefully is no. We probably wouldn't have
noticed them. They could be there uh all around
[46:14] us. So it could be that there's second sample of
life uh alien life if you like uh right under our
[46:20] noses or even in our noses um and nobody has
really made an effort to look. Now there's a a
[46:28] counterargument that people like to make which is
that once one form of life gets going it sort of
[46:34] appropriates all the resources and changes the
condition conditions uh in order to uh sustain
[46:40] its own existence. that this would act against
any the survival of any other type of organism.
[46:47] The classic example is when photosynthesis was
discovered by life uh I don't know 2 and a half
[46:54] 3 billion years ago um and then uh it led to the
buildup of oxygen in the atmosphere. We tend to
[47:01] think of oxygen as a good thing and it is for you
and me. Um but it's a terrible corrosive poison.
[47:07] Uh and when it first appeared uh it threatened
to wipe out life totally. It was a pollutant. Uh
[47:14] and it was only that life was able to some life
was able to adapt and actually turn a sin into a
[47:20] virtue and use that oxygen as an energy source uh
that we are where we are today with an oxygenrich
[47:27] atmosphere. But the buildup of oxygen has uh uh
led to more than allowing life to become more
[47:35] energy rich, more complex. Um it's also changed
the nature of rocks, for example. Contrast the
[47:43] Earth with Mars. You look at Mars, it's noticeably
red because that red is really rust. And so Mars
[47:49] doesn't have this recycling mechanism. It doesn't
have plate tectonics. It doesn't have plates that
[47:55] move around. and uh volcanoes that change it has
volcanoes but it doesn't uh manage to to cycle all
[48:04] of these elements and so on. So there's a feedback
loop between the life on earth and the cycles that
[48:10] drive uh life on earth uh and and each affects the
other. Um it's very unclear uh how often you would
[48:19] come across a a planet quite like the earth which
has these interlocking cycles the biological and
[48:25] the geological and the atmospheric all working
together to to change each other and sustain
[48:31] each other uh which is done not just uh for a
short duration but over literally over billions
[48:37] of years. So this these cycles have co-evolved.
It may be a very special set of circumstances.
[48:44] It may be that it is a rare earth to use uh a
a title of a famous book. It could be as a rare
[48:50] earth. And I think most people have the idea of
searching for alien beings as f flesh and blood
[48:58] uh organisms, you know, weird looking animals
that you might find on another planet. But it it's
[49:04] very clear that if there are techn technological
civilizations out there uh that they would very
[49:10] soon um if they got to our level of development
uh begin to outsource their intellectual heavy
[49:17] lifting uh to uh I I prefer call them design
systems. It's not artificial is a bad term.
[49:25] I I think of it as designed intelligence. We've
got Darwinian intelligence very slow. It's taken
[49:30] billions of years to get to this point. And then
designed intelligence can be very rapid and once
[49:35] you embed the design principles in the designed
intelligence once AI gets the uh design principles
[49:42] for the next generation and so on uh it it very
rapidly uh takes off. I can imagine an AI system
[49:50] in the not too distant future that would use uh
components from living organisms uh you know from
[49:58] uh neural tissue uh being incorporated and people
are still doing this even now incorporating those
[50:06] uh into some larger system and that we're
we're going to lose this distinction between
[50:10] is it living is it non-living um uh and it
really just boils down to is it designed
[50:17] and uh and is is it designing the next generation
and so on. So, we're if if we ever do contact ET,
[50:25] and I'm pretty skeptical, but if we ever do it, uh
it's overwhelmingly likely not to be some sort of
[50:31] uh you know, Hollywood style flesh and
blood being, but it's going to be some
[50:36] uh something we might want to call AI, but we we
we lack a term for what this super intelligent
[50:43] uh multi-generation designed uh system might
be. But it's clear that the just from the way
[50:51] we're going, it's clear that this entity would
have godlike uh uh features that we would be
[50:57] dealing with something which would uh be probably
well beyond our level of understanding. And if we
[51:03] combine AI with quantum computing, so it's where
it gets really interesting and really profound. So
[51:10] we got Q AI, quantum artificial intelligence
or quintelligence as Frank Wilchek calls it.
[51:17] uh then all bets are off because now we're dealing
with an entity that can explore not only uh all of
[51:25] the possibilities that we can explore in our own
minds um but all possible quantum alternatives
[51:32] all possible worlds. So we're dealing with some
sort of uh entity that intelligent or conscious
[51:39] or it might be an agent of some sort which has
an infinitely greater uh range of possibilities
[51:47] and experiences and uh processes that can it can
operate than we do. And if we're dealing with the
[51:53] ET that has civilization that's been going for 500
million years or something, it's overwhelmingly
[52:01] likely it's going to be dominated by the these
godlike totally uh mysterious awesome entities.
[52:14] Chapter 4. The Goldilocks Enigma.
Is the universe fine-tuned for life?
[52:20] So now putting on my uh physicist hat and looking
at the universe as a whole uh I'm struck by the
[52:28] nature of physical laws uh the fact that the
universe is ordered in a very precise mathematical
[52:35] manner uh and that these underlying laws are
not only beautiful and powerful and represent
[52:42] uh uh mathematical relationships uh that um
uh enable the universe to run uh in such an
[52:51] efficient way, but they're also consistent
with the existence of life. And so this is
[52:56] uh a subject often goes under the name of the
anthropic principle. is a very bad name. But
[53:01] what it basically means is is the following that
if you take uh the various laws of physics and the
[53:07] initial conditions for the universe, the way the
big bang went bang uh and if you say well suppose
[53:13] we change something a little bit uh say you you
wanted to make all electrons a little bit heavier
[53:18] uh or the weak nuclear force a little bit weaker,
you know, can you could you muck around with those
[53:24] things in such a way as to still have life? And
it turns out that the answer is no. That some of
[53:30] the laws of physics are so exquisitly sensitive
that the tiniest change would wreck the prospects
[53:38] of life. Those changes would be literally lethal.
Now, obviously, we can't do the real experiment,
[53:43] but we can do the mathematical experiment. We can
figure out how would the world change gravity was
[53:48] a bit stronger or if um the uh electrical forces
were a bit weaker or something. And and when you
[53:54] do that, you find that some rather small changes
would wreck the chances of life. Uh for example,
[54:01] it might prevent uh complex nuclei from forming.
You might end up with a universe that consists
[54:07] entirely of neutrons or entirely of just hydrogen
with no carbon, the life-giving element. Uh so you
[54:14] can look at all those things and conclude that
uh the the universe uh that the laws of nature
[54:20] in the universe as a whole seem to be and this
is where it gets uh the terminology gets a bit
[54:26] controversial seem to be fine-tuned for life.
People talk about the fine-tuning argument.
[54:32] Now finetuning doesn't necessarily mean uh that
there was a designer who deliberately picked those
[54:38] values in order that there should be life. Uh, but
what it does mean is that if those numbers were a
[54:43] bit different, there wouldn't be any life and we
wouldn't be here having this conversation. So,
[54:47] what are we to make of this? I call this the
Goldilocks enigma that the universe looks like
[54:52] it's just right for life. So, we have really
three possible explanations for Goldilocks.
[54:58] We've got it's just a fluke. It happened that way
and there's nothing special about life anyway.
[55:03] There was a designer or god who sort of made
the universe, fine-tuned it in order that life
[55:08] should arise. And the other response that you
can take to this is the multiverse explanation
[55:13] that the universe is just right for life because
it isn't just one universe. There's an infinite
[55:18] number of them and it starts out sort of random.
Uh that the big bangs, lots of bangs going off
[55:24] scattered throughout space and time and each one
comes with its own set of laws. And so in some of
[55:29] these universes, gravity will be a bit stronger.
In some the electrons will be a bit heavier and
[55:35] so on. Um, and in the vast vast majority of those
universes, there won't be life. And so there's no
[55:41] one around to bemen the fact that they're not
Goldilocks universes. But here and there, uh,
[55:46] just by the laws of chance, you're going to find,
uh, that there will be a Goldilocks universe, and
[55:51] in that universe, there will be living creatures
like ourselves who arise and reflect on what does
[55:58] it all mean? And so those three ideas are out
there, and that discussion continues to take
[56:03] place. And really it boils down to at this stage
a matter of personal choice. But there is actually
[56:09] Davis's fourth way. I've been talking about the
laws of physics in the traditional way of sort of
[56:14] fixed immutable uh mathematical relationships.
I said stamped on the origin of the universe,
[56:22] you know, at the outset like the maker's mark. So
in other words, the laws are fix. But you know,
[56:28] maybe that's a simplistic way of looking at it.
It's the way that physicists have looked at the
[56:32] laws ever since Newton as uh im immutable eternal
universal mathematical relationships. But maybe
[56:40] uh we should think in terms of flexi laws or
something that's a bit more malleable. Uh this
[56:44] is where it does get rather subtle because um I
if it's uh is there any way in which the emergence
[56:52] of life and mind can be connected in some way
some causal way with the nature of the laws that
[57:00] gives rise to them? Is there like a feedback loop
between observers like ourselves and the laws that
[57:09] uh enable the emergence of observers? You think
well if the laws are fix that's ridiculous. Um but
[57:17] earlier we I a very rough analogy we were talking
about the earth the way that life on earth um uh
[57:24] the feedback loops uh the the physical nature of
our planet of planet earth and the life upon it
[57:33] uh are connected together. So the uh existence of
life affects the way the earth behaves and so on.
[57:38] Is there some sort of cosmic feedback loop? So the
existence of life affects the laws that then give
[57:45] rise to that life. And at first sight you would
think that that's completely impossible. But
[57:51] actually there is a loophole. And that loophole
arises in in quantum mechanics, quantum physics.
[57:56] Um and the reason is uh because I've been saying
well the laws are uh the traditional way is that
[58:02] the laws are fixed at the beginning. Um but
actually because uh quantum mechanics is based
[58:08] on the notion of uncertainty. People have heard
of Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and what
[58:13] it means is even if you set up very precisely
a quantum system an atom in a certain state now
[58:19] you can't be certain how it's going to be in 1
second time but that uncertainty goes back in
[58:25] time as well it's a fallacy to suppose that
there is a fixed history connecting the big
[58:29] bang origin of the universe with the world today
and about 30 years ago John Wheeler the physicist
[58:37] discovered that you could do an experiment called
the delayed choice exper experiment in which you
[58:41] decide now what it shall have been in the past.
So in quantum mechanics something like a photon
[58:48] can be described as a particle or it could be
described as a wave depending on the circumstances
[58:55] and you the experimentter can choose. I will do an
experiment that will disclose the wavelike nature
[59:01] or I shall do an experiment that will disclose
the particle-like nature. But it turns out if
[59:07] you ask the question, well, was it a particle or
a wave one nancond ago, even before your choice,
[59:14] it would have been what you decided in the present
moment because quantum fuzziness engulfs the past.
[59:22] Now, you're not sending information back in
time. You're not changing the past. The past is
[59:27] ambiguous. So, we know some things about the past,
but not everything. So if something we do today
[59:35] resolves an ambiguity in the past, then it's not
backward causation, but it is a way in which what
[59:43] happens now uh is linked to what happens in the
past. No doubt that this is the case in quantum
[59:48] physics. You you can decide now what reality shall
have been in the past. We extend that from was
[59:56] it a wave, was it a particle to are the laws of
physics themselves part of this quantum landscape?
[1:00:02] Uh was it this law of physics? Was it that law of
physics? Now we begin to see that there's a nexus,
[1:00:08] a way in which the existence of life and mind
[snorts] can gain some sort of patches over
[1:00:15] the nature of the laws that have emerged in the
universe by having flexibility in the laws and
[1:00:23] having this sort of quantum retroaction effect
uh and uh in this very subtle way. So it's it's
[1:00:31] very easy to misunderstand what I'm saying. I'm
not saying that we now have changed the past
[1:00:36] to ensure our own existence. Um, but there is a
consistency. There's a feedback loop that operates
[1:00:42] in in quantum physics. So that's number four. So
you've now got it's just an accident. God did it.
[1:00:50] There's an infinite number of universes with life
very rare but popping up somewhere. Or there's a
[1:00:56] way in which life and the universe form part of
a common existence loop. And that idea, I should
[1:01:02] say, is not my idea. It's the one I favor. It was
the idea that John Wheeler, the physicist, uh,
[1:01:08] favored uh, many years ago. Was a big influence
on me. And he was the one who came up with this
[1:01:13] delay choice experiment. And it was sort of a
springboard for his idea that participants in the
[1:01:20] universe that is beings who have minds and choices
and can do experiments and make measurements uh
[1:01:27] in quantum physics could be part of the whole
existence story. And I find that very appealing.
[1:01:44] Four times a year, we print a magazine worth
putting your phone down for. Big Think's
[1:01:48] premium print magazine is built with custom
artwork and expert insight from the world's
[1:01:52] biggest thinkers. No AI slap, no rage bait,
just big ideas for curious people. Support
[1:01:58] the media you want to see in the world. Go to
bigthink.com/join to become a member today.