BrightStar
BlogMy Tickets
BlogMy Tickets
Saved events
Help & contactSign UpLog in
Events
  • Browse All Events
  • For Seekers
  • Yoga
  • Meditation
  • Breathwork
  • Qigong
  • Sacred Music
  • World Music
  • Medicine Music
  • Sound Healing
  • Ecstatic Dance
  • Ceremony
  • Plant Medicine
  • Energy Healing
  • Satsang & Wisdom
  • Tantra
  • Retreats
  • All Categories →
Destinations
  • Bali
  • Sedona
  • Los Angeles
  • Costa Rica
  • Tulum
  • Byron Bay
  • San Francisco
  • Austin
  • New York
  • San Diego
  • Seattle
  • Portland
  • Miami
  • London
  • Maui
  • Boulder
  • Oakland
  • All Cities →
Platform
  • List Your Event Free
  • Autopilot
  • Join the Movement
  • Sell Globally
  • For Creators
  • For Teams
  • For Writers
  • For Teachers
  • For Kirtan Artists
  • For Studios
  • For Festivals
  • For Retreat Centers
  • For Nonprofits
  • Brand Ambassador
  • Free Ticketing
  • Elevate
  • Amplify
  • The Ecosystem
Features

Ticketing and checkout

  • Ticket categories
  • Assigned seating
  • Custom questions
  • Coupon codes
  • Smart pricing
  • Ticket sharing
  • Waitlist
  • Flexible refunds
  • Digital waivers
  • Tip jar
  • Donations and sliding scale
  • Embed widget
  • Mindful checkout
  • Recurring events
  • Private sessions
  • Online courses
  • Summits
  • Rooms and stays
  • Ticket scanner

Marketing and growth

  • Abandoned cart recovery
  • Visitor recovery
  • Upsells and add-ons
  • Affiliate engine
  • Upsell affiliate network
  • Brand ambassador
  • Meta retargeting
  • Verified buyer network
  • Outbound email marketing
  • Email sequences
  • SMS and WhatsApp
  • Event upsell network
  • Direct mail campaigns
  • SEO engine
  • Syndication
  • Event sharing
  • Custom event pages
  • Artist profiles
  • Link in bio
  • Event blog
  • Blog newsletter

Payments

  • Payments, powered by Stripe
  • Buy now, pay later
  • Apple Wallet
  • Multi currency

Data and operations

  • Team access
  • Message center
  • Reports
  • Analytics reporting
  • Performance reporting
  • Customer data
  • Integrations
  • Switch from another platform

AI

  • Maestro
  • AI FAQ assistant
  • All Features →
Company
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Glossary
  • Inspiration
  • Help Center
  • API Docs
  • Brand Assets
  • Press
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy

Events

  • Browse All Events
  • For Seekers
  • Yoga
  • Meditation
  • Breathwork
  • Qigong
  • Sacred Music
  • World Music

Destinations

  • Bali
  • Sedona
  • Los Angeles
  • Costa Rica
  • Tulum
  • Byron Bay
  • San Francisco
  • Austin

Platform

  • List Your Event Free
  • Autopilot
  • Join the Movement
  • Sell Globally
  • For Creators
  • For Teams
  • For Writers
  • For Teachers

Features

  • Community Network
  • Abandoned Cart Recovery
  • Ticket Categories
  • Recurring Events
  • Assigned Seating
  • Affiliate Engine
  • Waitlist / Notify
  • All Features →

Company

  • About
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Glossary
  • Inspiration
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
Read more

Events

  • Medicine Music
  • Sound Healing
  • Ecstatic Dance
  • Ceremony
  • Plant Medicine
  • Energy Healing
  • Satsang & Wisdom
  • Tantra
  • Retreats
  • All Categories →

Destinations

  • New York
  • San Diego
  • Seattle
  • Portland
  • Miami
  • London
  • Maui
  • Boulder
  • Oakland
  • All Cities →

Platform

  • For Kirtan Artists
  • For Studios
  • For Festivals
  • For Retreat Centers
  • For Nonprofits
  • Brand Ambassador
  • Free Ticketing
  • Elevate
  • Amplify
  • The Ecosystem

Company

  • Help Center
  • API Docs
  • Brand Assets
  • Press

Ticketing and checkout

  • Ticket categories
  • Assigned seating
  • Custom questions
  • Coupon codes
  • Smart pricing
  • Ticket sharing
  • Waitlist
  • Flexible refunds
  • Digital waivers
  • Tip jar
  • Donations and sliding scale
  • Embed widget
  • Mindful checkout
  • Recurring events
  • Private sessions
  • Online courses
  • Summits
  • Rooms and stays
  • Ticket scanner

Marketing and growth

  • Abandoned cart recovery
  • Visitor recovery
  • Upsells and add-ons
  • Affiliate engine
  • Upsell affiliate network
  • Brand ambassador
  • Meta retargeting
  • Verified buyer network
  • Outbound email marketing
  • Email sequences
  • SMS and WhatsApp
  • Event upsell network
  • Direct mail campaigns
  • SEO engine
  • Syndication
  • Event sharing
  • Custom event pages
  • Artist profiles
  • Link in bio
  • Event blog
  • Blog newsletter

Payments

  • Payments, powered by Stripe
  • Buy now, pay later
  • Apple Wallet
  • Multi currency

Data and operations

  • Team access
  • Message center
  • Reports
  • Analytics reporting
  • Performance reporting
  • Customer data
  • Integrations
  • Switch from another platform

AI

  • Maestro
  • AI FAQ assistant
Get the app
Download on theApp StoreGet it onGoogle Play
© 2026 BrightStar. All rights reserved. Photo credits ·
Inspiration

Why Do People Have Different Karma? Understanding Cause, Effect, and Interbeing

Thich Nhat Hanh
Thich Nhat Hanh
Jan 17, 2015
8 min read

From Plum Village

Watch · 9

Thich Nhat Hanh addresses the question of why people have different karma by reframing karma as action—not reward or punishment—and demonstrating how cause and effect form a continuous, inseparable whole. Rather than seeing karma as strictly individual, he reveals the deep interbeing between individual and collective karma. He uses the metaphor of a corn kernel and plant to show that opposites like cause/effect and individual/collective are not truly separate but are continuations of each other in time and space. Understanding this non-dualistic view of karma leads to ethical action based on insight into our interconnection with all beings, ancestors, and the world.

Read · 8 sections

What Does Karma Actually Mean?

The opening question—"Why do people have different karma?"—prompts Thich Nhat Hanh to step back and examine the assumption embedded in the question itself. He asks the questioner: "Are you sure every human being has a different karma?" This gentle interrogation is characteristic of his teaching method: before answering, he invites reflection on what we think we know.

Thich Nhat Hanh defines karma plainly: karma is action. The word itself, he explains, means action. He shares a personal note—his name, Nhat Hanh, carries this meaning. "Nhat means one, Hanh means action," he says, adding with characteristic humility, "and I don't know what action it is" (101s). This is not mystical language. Karma is not a cosmic accounting system that rewards and punishes. It is the concrete reality of action and its consequences.

How Are Cause and Effect Actually Related?

To deepen understanding, Thich Nhat Hanh distinguishes between two forms of karma: karma hetu (action as cause) and karma phal kaala (karma as fruit, or effect) (126s). But here is where his teaching diverges from simplistic interpretations. He states with precision: "You cannot remove the cause from the effect...and you cannot remove the effect from the cause" (152-155s).

He illustrates this with the image of a corn kernel and a corn stalk:

"It's like the corn kernel is the cause and the corn stalk is the effect but they are not two separate entities...you cannot remove the corn kernel from the plant of corn and you cannot remove the corn plant out from the corn kernel" (160-175s).

This is profound. The kernel and the stalk appear to be distinct—one comes first, one comes after. Yet they are not truly separate. Cause and effect are not two different entities; one is the continuation of the other (185s). The plant of corn is a continuation of the kernel in the direction of the future. The kernel continues the plant in the direction of the past. "Thanks to the corn kernel the plant of corn has access to the ancestors and thanks to the plant of corn the ancestors have access to the future" (209s). This is not poetic language alone—it describes a real interdependence: "It's a wonderful collaboration on the base of no-self. There is only a continuation" (227s).

This teaching dissolves the illusion that past and future are truly separate. Karma is a continuous process, not a chain of isolated links.

What Is the Relationship Between Individual and Collective Karma?

The question shifts from time to space. Just as cause and effect are inseparable, so too are individual and collective karma (243s). Thich Nhat Hanh notes that "if you reflect on the notion of individual and collective you already make a big step" (263s), because "the notions of individual and collective are also a pair of opposites to be transcended" (278s).

He illustrates this through the example of a young person claiming autonomy: "This is my body, this is my life, I have the freedom, I have the right to do anything with my body my life" (291-312s). Such a view rests on the illusion that "I am not you"—that the young person is entirely separate from their parents and ancestors. But this is false. The young person is "a continuation of their father, their mother" (325s). This insight has ethical implications: "They cannot harm, they do not have the right to harm the father....to commit suicide is an offence: you are killing your father you are killing your mother, your ancestors when you commit suicide" (334-347s).

Why? Because "this body is not yours. This body is a property of your father, of your ancestors" (347s). This is not poetic exaggeration. It is a statement about the actual dependence of the body on ancestral lineage, genetics, culture, and resources.

How Does the Body Dissolve the Boundary Between Individual and Collective?

Thich Nhat Hanh uses a striking example to show how the individual/collective boundary collapses: your optic nerves (427-489s). At first glance, your optic nerves seem strictly individual—"something absolutely individual. People don't see it, they are not concerned by it, it concerns only you" (456s). The distinction seems clear.

But imagine you are a bus driver. "Our lives depend on your optic nerves so your optic nerves are not individual any more, they belong to us because our lives depend on your optic nerves" (475-489s). Your individual organs become collective when their function affects others. The boundary is not fixed—it shifts based on relationship and dependence.

The broader principle: "Your body is a collective product of your nation, of your people, of your culture of your ancestors, so you are not strictly individual, you are partly collective" (394-407s). This is not a metaphor. Every cell, every nutrient, every learned skill comes from the collective.

What Happens When Many People Act Together as a Collective?

Thich Nhat Hanh then illustrates these principles in action. When 600 people gather on retreat, "they read something together as collective action. They do sitting, walking, breathing, smiling, sharing, and this is a collective action and we profit from that" (506-533s).

This collective action stands in contrast to how others spend their time in the world—"they drink and....., go dancing and they spend their time in a very different way" (548s). The 600 people have set aside three weeks to share "a collective action here that we believe to be a good action because every day we water the seeds of mindfulness, understanding, compassion in us and the collective" (569-588s).

Yet even within this collective, individual differences persist: "There are those that do better than some others, there are those of us who can find it possible to transform, to leave behind the burden of worries in the first five days there are those who also need more than that, probably on the third week that they can release, put down their worries" (602-622s).

The point is not that individuals vanish into the collective, but that "in the collective there is the individual and in the individual there is the collective there is no absolute individuality, there is no absolute collectivity, that is the truth" (640s).

How Do We Act Rightly When Karma Affects Everyone?

This understanding transforms ethics. "Any karma whether it is individual or collective affects the whole" (506s). Whatever good actions we undertake ripple outward: "whatever good we are doing here is helping the world, so we have to be confident that the karma is not lost" (660s).

Moreover, "any thought of compassion and forgiveness that we produce not only can help us heal but can help the world" (681s). This is not wishful thinking. If we are truly interconnected—if the individual and collective are inseparable—then our inner work is simultaneously action in the world. "During the 21 days we have in producing thoughts of loving kindness, that is our best contribution to the world" (697s).

What Is "Right View" of Karma?

Thich Nhat Hanh concludes with a statement about right view: "Our action of karma is neither different nor the same because sameness and otherness is also a pair of opposites so right view lies in the fact that you are able to remove all these pairs of opposites" (697-720s).

This is the culmination of his teaching on the original question. Why do people have different karma? The question contains a hidden duality—the assumption that some people are fundamentally separate from others, with separate karmas. But right view transcends this. Karma is neither utterly individual nor utterly collective, neither fixed in the past nor determined in the future, neither cause nor effect but their continuous collaboration.

To practice this view is to meditate: "To meditate is to see the nature of interbeing, non self, which allow you to act properly and not to cause suffering that is karma" (360-375s). This is not abstract philosophy. It is practical insight that grounds ethical conduct in reality rather than in rules or fear of cosmic punishment.

Where to Go From Here

Explore Thich Nhat Hanh's teachings on interbeing (the concept that all phenomena exist in mutual dependence) as the foundation for understanding karma in a non-dualistic way. Study his work on mindfulness practice, which trains the mind to perceive these interconnections directly rather than merely intellectually. Investigate how this view of karma differs from both fatalistic and mechanical interpretations—it offers a middle way that acknowledges causation while dissolving the illusion of a separate self making choices in isolation. Consider how this framework applies to collective action and social change: if individual and collective karma are inseparable, what does ethical action look like in community?

Comments

Loading the conversation…

Transcript

[0:33] My question is: Why human beings have different karma?

[0:42] Thank you.

[0:45] Our friend is asking why each human being has a different karma

[0:57] Are you sure?

[1:02] Are you sure every human being has a different karma?

[1:15] I was quite sure but now....

[1:33] Karma is action, the word karma means action

[1:41] My name Nhat Hanh means one action only , Nhat means one, Hanh means action , and I don't know what action it is

[2:06] Karma may be cause or may be effect. Karma hetu is action as a cause and karma phal kaala is karma as a fruit and cause and effect they are together,

[2:32] ...you cannot remove the cause from the effect...

[2:35] ...and you cannot remove the effect from the cause

[2:40] it'a like the corn kernel is the cause and the corn stalk is the effect but they are not two separate entities...

[2:55] you cannot remove the corn kernel from the plant of corn and you cannot remove the corn plant out from the corn kernel

[3:05] so cause and effect are not two different entities and one is the continuation of the other

[3:18] the plant of corn is a continuation of the seed of corn in the direction of the future and the kernel of corn continues the plant of corn in the direction of the past

[3:29] thanks to the corn kernel the plant of corn has access to the ancestors and thanks to the plant of corn the ancestors have access to the future

[3:47] it's a wonderful collaboration on the base of no-self. There is only a continuation and that is from the point of view of time

[4:03] From the point of view of space it's the same: there is what we call collective karma and individual karma and you are talking about individual karma

[4:23] and it's different from other karma, but if you reflect on the notion of individual and collective you already make a big step

[4:38] because the notions of individual and collective are also a pair of opposites to be transcended

[4:51] When a young person tells his father that : 'This is my body, this is my life, I have the freedom, I have the right to do anything with my body

[5:12] my life' that is a view that I am not you- 'I have my own body, my own feeling, my own life, I have the right to dispose my life the way I want'

[5:25] and our young people say like that, they don't know that they are a continuation of their father, their mother

[5:34] and in fact they cannot harm, they do not have the right to harm the father, .... to commit suicide is an offence: you are killing your father

[5:47] you are killing your mother, your ancestors when you commit suicide..this body is not yours.This body is a property of your father, of your ancestors

[6:00] and with that kind of insight you cannot behave like the way many people behave, based on wrong view. So to meditate is to see the nature of interbeing,

[6:15] non self, which allow you to act properly and not to cause suffering that is karma. And your body is not your individual property

[6:34] it is also collective at the same time. Your body is a collective product of your nation, of your people, of your culture

[6:47] of your ancestors, so you are not strictly individual, you are partly collective, and it depends on a way of looking that you are more or less collective

[7:07] Suppose you say that you have your nerves, your optic nerves behind your eyes, your optic nerves look like something strictly individual, it only concerns you, your optic nerves

[7:36] that is something absolutely individual. People don't see it, they are not concerned by it, it concerns only you. That is a notion of individual and collectiveness.

[7:55] But if you are a bus driver, our lives depend on your optic nerves so your optic nerves are not individual any more, they belong to us because our lives depend on your optic nerves

[8:09] So your optic nerve is something you describe as individual but infact they are collective. So we have the notion of collective karma and individual karma.

[8:26] And any karma whether it is individual or collective affects the whole and the karma, the action may be better or worse. When 600 people come on a retreat they read something together as collective action

[8:53] They do sitting, walking, breathing, smiling, sharing, and this is a collective action and we profit from that.

[9:08] There are those in the world at this time they don't practice like us and they drink and ....., go dancing and they spend their time in a very different way

[9:29] and we have been able to set aside three weeks to come together and we are sharing a collective action here that we believe to be a good action

[9:48] because every day we water the seeds of mindfulness, understanding, compassion in us and the collective. But in the collective you can see the individuals-

[10:02] there are those that do better than some others, there are those of us who can find it possible to transform, to leave behind the burden of worries in the first five days

[10:22] there are those who also need more than that, probably on the third week that they can release, put down their worries. So in the collective there is the individual and in the individual there is the collective

[10:40] there is no absolute individuality, there is no absolute collectivity, that is the truth and that is why it is another pair of opposites and if you practice looking deeply you can remove them

[11:00] and you see that any karma affects all of us, whatever good we are doing here is helping the world, so we have to be confident that the karma is not lost

[11:21] any thought of compassion and forgiveveness that we produce not only can help us heal but can help the world, so during the 21 days we have in producing thoughts of compassion,

[11:37] of loving kindness, that is our best contribution to the world. And that is why our action of karma is neither different nor the same

[12:00] because sameness and otherness is also a pair of opposites so right view lies in the fact that you are able to remove all these pairs of opposites

[12:49] Subtitles by the Amara.org community

The Artist in This Story

Thich Nhat Hanh

Thich Nhat Hanh

Mindfulness Teacher

Thich Nhat Hanh (1926–2022) was a Vietnamese Zen master, author and peace activist who founded the Plum Village Tradition and taught mindfulness as a path to understanding, compassion and engaged action.

View profile
Explore Topics
Karma actionInterbeingCollective karmaCause effectNon self
Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

No. Karma simply means action. It is not a cosmic accounting system. Rather, karma describes how cause and effect are inseparably linked—action and its consequences form a continuous process, not a transaction where the universe 'punishes' or 'rewards' you.

Not in the absolute sense. While individuals may have different circumstances and experiences, individual karma and collective karma are not truly separate. Your actions arise from and affect a web of relationships, ancestors, culture, and community. The distinction between individual and collective is itself a 'pair of opposites' that points to a deeper unity.

The opposite. Understanding that you are a continuation of your ancestors and parents, and that your body is shaped by collective forces, deepens your responsibility. You cannot harm others without harming yourself and your lineage. This insight leads to more ethical action, not less.

Because individual and collective are inseparable. A thought of compassion or forgiveness cultivated in your mind is not isolated; it ripples through the collective consciousness and affects how you interact with others. Inner work is simultaneously outer work when understood through interbeing.

Buddhism identifies many pairs of opposites that create confusion and suffering: individual/collective, cause/effect, self/other, sameness/difference. Right view lies in seeing that these opposites are interdependent and inseparable, like the corn kernel and the corn plant. Transcending them does not mean denying the distinctions; it means seeing through the illusion that they are absolutely separate.

Cause and effect exist in a continuous relationship through time. The corn kernel continues into the plant in the direction of the future; the plant continues the kernel in the direction of the past. They are not two separate moments but one unbroken process, a 'wonderful collaboration on the base of no-self.'

The optic nerve appears to be strictly individual—something that concerns only you. But if you are a bus driver, passengers' lives depend on your optic nerves, making them collective. This shows that the boundary between individual and collective is not fixed but depends on relationship and interdependence. It dissolves the illusion of absolute individuality.

Meditation is not separate from karma practice. To meditate is to see directly the nature of interbeing and non-self, which allows you to act properly and not cause suffering. This insight—not rules or fear of punishment—is what leads to ethical action.

You might also like

View All
Liberation Through Grief and Self-Worth in Buddhist Practice
Inspire

Liberation Through Grief and Self-Worth in Buddhist Practice

Br. Phap Huu explores how recognizing our inherent goodness and learning to grieve openly within community liberates us from suffering and s…

11 min read
Living Gems Archive: Preserving Thích Nhất Hạnh's Dharma for the World
Inspire

Living Gems Archive: Preserving Thích Nhất Hạnh's Dharma for the World

Living Gems is a searchable digital archive of Thích Nhất Hạnh's teachings, built by Plum Village to preserve and share the dharma globally …

10 min read
Medicine Buddha Practice: Healing Through Darkness and Grace
Inspire

Medicine Buddha Practice: Healing Through Darkness and Grace

Lama Rod Owens guides practitioners into seasonal darkness work and the felt sense of awakened beings through Medicine Buddha practice roote…

7 min read
Love Beyond Habit: Breaking Free From Patterns of Separation
Inspire

Love Beyond Habit: Breaking Free From Patterns of Separation

When judgment, fear, and wanting filter how we see others, we lose touch with their humanity. Through mindful presence and loving-kindness, …

7 min read
See allYou might also like→

Continue your journey

More wisdom and gatherings from across the BrightStar directory.

More Articles

Browse the full library of teachings, interviews, and guides.

Back to all articles →

Teachers & Artists

Explore the lineages, musicians, and guides of the conscious world.

Explore artists →

Find an Event

Kirtan, retreats, sound baths, breathwork, festivals — happening soon.

Browse events →