St. Francis of Assisi's assertion, "Whoever does not know how to ask this is not yet a disciple," invites us to reflect on the profound nature of inquiry within the spiritual journey. To ask is not merely to seek information; it is to engage in a deeper relationship with the divine and with ourselves. This quote underscores the essential role that asking plays in the life of a disciple, suggesting that true discipleship begins with a willingness to question and to seek understanding. The stakes are high: without this capacity for inquiry, we risk remaining stagnant in our spiritual growth.
Moreover, the act of asking is inherently relational. It implies a recognition of our limitations and a desire to transcend them. In a world that often values certainty and self-sufficiency, St. Francis reminds us that the path of a disciple is one marked by humility and openness. This humility is not a weakness but a strength, allowing us to embrace the unknown and to cultivate a deeper connection with the sacred. Thus, the quote serves as both a challenge and an invitation, urging us to explore the depths of our own questions as we embark on our spiritual journeys.
The image / the metaphor
At its core, St. Francis's quote evokes a vivid image of the seeker, standing at the threshold of understanding, grappling with the art of asking. The verb "ask" carries with it a sense of urgency and necessity; it is an action that requires both courage and vulnerability. To ask is to acknowledge that we do not possess all the answers, that we are in a state of learning. The imagery here is not one of passive waiting but of active engagement, where the disciple steps forward, ready to confront the mysteries of existence.
Diving deeper into the metaphor, we can see that asking is not merely about verbal inquiries; it encompasses a broader spectrum of seeking—through prayer, contemplation, and the lived experience. It suggests a posture of openness, where the disciple is not only asking questions but is also receptive to the answers that may come in unexpected forms. This dynamic interplay between asking and receiving is central to the spiritual path, as it fosters a relationship with the divine that is both intimate and transformative.
In the speaker's tradition
St. Francis of Assisi's teachings are deeply rooted in the Franciscan tradition, which emphasizes humility, simplicity, and a profound connection to creation. The concept of "kenosis," or self-emptying, resonates here, as it invites the disciple to let go of preconceived notions and to approach the divine with an open heart. In this light, asking becomes an act of surrender, a willingness to relinquish control and to trust in a greater wisdom. This aligns with the idea of "bhakti," or devotion, where the act of asking is infused with love and longing for a deeper relationship with the divine.
In the "Earlier Rule," St. Francis articulates the importance of living in accordance with the Gospel, which includes a call to seek understanding through humility and inquiry. This echoes the teachings found in other spiritual traditions, such as the Buddhist concept of "prajna," or wisdom, which emphasizes the importance of questioning as a means to enlightenment. Both traditions recognize that the journey toward understanding is paved with questions, and that discipleship is marked by a continuous quest for deeper truths.
Living the teaching
Consider a modern scenario where this teaching resonates: a person grappling with a significant life decision, such as a career change or a relationship challenge. In this moment, the ability to ask the right questions becomes crucial. Instead of seeking immediate answers or solutions, the individual might benefit from sitting with their uncertainty, asking themselves what truly matters, what fears are at play, and what their heart desires. This process of inquiry can lead to greater clarity and a more authentic path forward, illustrating how asking is integral to discernment.
In a different context, imagine a relationship that has become strained. Here, the act of asking can serve as a bridge to healing. Rather than making assumptions or harboring unspoken grievances, one partner might approach the other with genuine questions: "How are you feeling about us?" or "What do you need from me right now?" This willingness to ask and to listen fosters a deeper understanding and connection, transforming the relationship into a space of mutual growth and support. In both scenarios, the essence of St. Francis's teaching shines through: asking is not just a means to an end but a vital practice that nurtures our spiritual and relational lives.
A reflection
As we contemplate St. Francis's words, we are invited to consider our own relationship with asking. What questions linger in your heart that remain unspoken? How might embracing the art of inquiry deepen your spiritual journey and enhance your connections with others? Reflecting on these questions can illuminate the path toward becoming a more engaged disciple, one who is not afraid to seek, to wonder, and to grow.


