Transcript
[0:00] I offer these every week along with a
[0:02] guided meditation. Just click the uh
[0:05] subscribe link below to be notified
[0:07] through YouTube when I post the latest
[0:09] recording. Or if you'd like to join us
[0:11] live, which would be great, uh just go
[0:13] into the description section below and
[0:15] follow the link along to be able to sign
[0:17] up for free.
[0:20] So, I would like to talk with you about
[0:23] the two keys to transformation.
[0:28] These are also the two keys to having a
[0:32] happy marriage
[0:33] or long-term relationship of any kind.
[0:36] These are the two keys to worldly
[0:39] success.
[0:40] These are the two keys to enlightenment.
[0:44] What are they?
[0:46] These are described in various ways and
[0:49] in the Buddhist lineage, they are
[0:51] referred to as sudden awakening and
[0:55] gradual cultivation.
[0:58] Now, that sounds sort of fancy and I'm
[1:00] going to explore this and kind of three
[1:03] levels because I grew up around swimming
[1:05] pools in Los Angeles, I think of the
[1:07] shallow end of the pool,
[1:09] the medium area of the pool,
[1:13] and the deep end of the pool.
[1:14] So, we're going to start at the shallow
[1:16] end where a lot of good action can
[1:18] occur. A lot of good fun there in the
[1:20] shallow end as we move further and
[1:22] further into the deep end of the pool.
[1:25] So,
[1:26] what are some basic examples? Sudden
[1:29] awakening
[1:31] begins with just a moment of
[1:34] understanding,
[1:35] insight.
[1:36] Like, "Oh, it really is possible as
[1:40] someone who grew up with forks and
[1:41] knives to eat your food with
[1:43] chopsticks."
[1:45] Wonderful, or vice versa, right?
[1:48] Or the realization that
[1:51] when you're learning to drive a car with
[1:53] a stick shift, that
[1:56] you need to keep the clutch in
[1:59] before you engage the gears and let it
[2:01] out kind of slowly. You understand
[2:03] something.
[2:04] Maybe in your relationship,
[2:07] you
[2:09] track the expression over someone's face
[2:12] when you interrupt them.
[2:15] Aha. And you realize that with that
[2:18] particular person, about that particular
[2:20] topic, and that particular kind of
[2:22] situation,
[2:23] don't interrupt them. You know,
[2:25] [laughter] more skillful the next time.
[2:27] You realize something. Right? You
[2:28] realize something. Light bulb. Thought
[2:31] balloon. You realize something. Sudden
[2:33] awakening. Maybe you read something and
[2:37] you're reading a book of fiction or
[2:39] non-fiction and a character says
[2:40] something or does something and oh, that
[2:43] would be that would be helpful. Oh,
[2:46] okay.
[2:47] You know, I made some
[2:50] baked bread the other day with brown
[2:52] rice flour and realized that next time
[2:55] the recipe could use a little more salt.
[2:57] These holistic people are kind of low on
[2:59] salt. Anyway. So, this is the beginning.
[3:03] And it's useful to appreciate that the
[3:05] range of sudden awakening comes from
[3:08] just a kind of simple ordinary idea,
[3:10] even maybe just 1% of you is whispering,
[3:13] the better angel of your nature in in
[3:15] the background, "Sweetie, next time
[3:19] don't drink so much." Or, "Oh, sweetie,
[3:21] you know, it's time to stop smoking."
[3:23] Or, "Oh, sweetie, next time leave for
[3:27] the appointment 10 minutes early so you
[3:29] don't have to drive like a maniac to get
[3:31] there on time." Oh, and then gradually
[3:34] you start listening to that part of you.
[3:36] Or all the way to
[3:39] poof
[3:41] really intense moments.
[3:43] I remember a moment with our daughter
[3:45] when she was maybe three or four and
[3:49] strike doing being, you know, like
[3:52] wanting it her way, you know, about
[3:54] something, putting on some sweatshirt.
[3:56] And I just got irritated and I was just
[3:59] sort of for me on the zero to 10 adult
[4:01] scale of irritation was I don't know,
[4:03] maybe a three given how I grew up where,
[4:06] you know, people could get pretty angry
[4:08] with each other. And I just looked at
[4:10] the stricken shocked expression on her
[4:12] face and I just got, "No, can't do
[4:15] that." It's like, "Whoa, you know,
[4:17] people sometimes wake up or, you know,
[4:20] in their own
[4:22] pool of vomit, whatever, and they
[4:23] realize
[4:25] hitting bottom.
[4:26] Hitting bottom.
[4:27] And no more. So, there's a range of the
[4:30] sudden awakening aspect.
[4:33] And then there's the question of how to
[4:36] implement that sudden awakening in
[4:40] gradual cultivation that makes a
[4:42] difference over time. And here I'd like
[4:44] to name three evidence-based practices
[4:48] that really lead to stabilizing
[4:52] good change that lasts.
[4:54] All right?
[4:55] The first of these from a lot of
[4:56] research on habit formation is to help
[5:00] yourself and kind of stack the odds in
[5:02] your favor by arranging your environment
[5:06] in ways that would support the
[5:09] stabilization and the enactment of the
[5:12] new way of being.
[5:14] A little things like if you're trying to
[5:16] eat a little differently, don't buy
[5:18] those foods or don't have them in your
[5:20] cupboards. Don't make it easy to don't
[5:23] keep a lot of beer in the refrigerator.
[5:25] Set your alarm clock 5 minutes earlier
[5:28] to get up a little earlier so you can
[5:30] have 10 minutes of meditation in the
[5:31] morning. Set out your clothes the night
[5:33] before, whatever. Make a make
[5:35] arrangements of different kinds. Start
[5:37] spending more time with some people,
[5:39] maybe less time with some other people.
[5:42] Just help yourself. Externals. There's a
[5:44] place for adjusting the externals to
[5:47] create more simple grooves in your life
[5:50] that draw you in the direction of your
[5:52] sudden awakening, quote unquote. As Fran
[5:55] puts it, set yourself up to succeed.
[5:58] Tons of evidence, tons of research on
[6:01] this. Geeking out a little bit here, I
[6:03] it's okay. And complex systems theory
[6:06] talks about dynamic systems continually
[6:09] changing. So, what sort of states are we
[6:12] attracted to, are we drawn into? Let's
[6:15] suppose that we've been caught up in a
[6:17] certain kind of old habit, and we're
[6:19] trying to help ourselves with our sudden
[6:20] awakening to shift into a better habit,
[6:23] a new habit. These states of being are
[6:25] described as strange attractors or
[6:29] basins of attraction. And I kind of
[6:31] visualize them or this visualization is
[6:33] offered. Imagine a rubber sheet laid out
[6:36] as flexible that contains all the
[6:39] possible states of being you could have.
[6:41] And some of them are represented as very
[6:44] kind of small, shallow divots, right?
[6:48] Others are broad but shallow, some are
[6:50] narrow or small and deep, some are broad
[6:53] and deep. And the more the broader it
[6:56] is, the more we tend to get sucked into
[6:58] it or attracted into it. And the deeper
[7:00] it is, the more we tend to stay there
[7:02] and takes a lot of energy to get us out.
[7:04] This is a very interesting way to
[7:06] visualize what we end up doing. Well,
[7:09] we're trying to help ourselves be less
[7:12] caught in the problematic basin of
[7:16] attraction. So, we don't want it to be
[7:17] so deep and so broad. And in particular,
[7:20] we're trying to deepen and broaden other
[7:23] basins of attraction, other strange
[7:25] attractors. So, our environment
[7:27] naturally inclines us in a certain
[7:28] direction.
[7:29] That's one of the first of three major,
[7:32] major ways to engage gradual cultivation
[7:36] in ordinary life.
[7:38] It's great. Help yourself.
[7:40] Second, this is an area that I've
[7:42] really, really developed. If you're
[7:44] seeking to produce gradual cultivation,
[7:48] good change that lasts inside yourself,
[7:52] that's durable and you take with you,
[7:54] and is not dependent on external
[7:57] supports, even if those supports, even
[8:00] if that scaffolding is withdrawn, shoo,
[8:04] you are still rested in the way of being
[8:08] that you are seeking to develop and
[8:10] cultivate. And to do that, it's
[8:13] extremely useful
[8:16] to deliberately internalize experiences
[8:20] of what you're encouraging.
[8:22] Experiences
[8:24] of greater commitment to exercise or not
[8:27] interrupting your partner, experiences
[8:29] of your own worth, experiences of an
[8:32] underlying resilience, experiences of
[8:35] skillfulness with other people, whatever
[8:38] it is you want to develop, you start
[8:40] with an experience of it and then using
[8:42] the evidence-based practices of positive
[8:45] neuroplasticity,
[8:47] you can increase the registration of
[8:50] that experience as a lasting change in
[8:53] your physical structures of your body,
[8:55] especially your nervous system,
[8:57] in by the ways you relate to the
[8:59] experience you're having or engage it.
[9:02] In particular, keep the experience
[9:04] going.
[9:05] Keep the neurons firing together so they
[9:08] can wire together. Keep the experience
[9:10] going for a breath or longer. Feel it in
[9:13] your body, this new way of being. What's
[9:16] it feel like in your body? Sink into it
[9:18] in your body as it sinks into your body.
[9:22] And be aware of what feels good about
[9:24] it, what's rewarding about it or
[9:26] meaningful about it. Tracking the reward
[9:28] value of what you wish to grow inside
[9:31] will increase its consolidation
[9:34] in the neural nets of memory,
[9:35] particularly emotional memory, somatic
[9:38] memory, motivational memory.
[9:42] One breath at a time,
[9:44] many synapses at a time, through
[9:47] deliberately taking in the good as I've
[9:49] taught about a lot and you can find
[9:52] everywhere or a lot of places, uh you
[9:55] really can grow the good that lasts
[9:56] inside.
[9:57] Deliberate internalization, not just
[10:01] having an experience that then washes
[10:03] through you and where to go, but
[10:05] actually marinating in it so it becomes
[10:07] a part of you. That's the second major
[10:09] way to engage or practice gradual
[10:12] cultivation in ordinary life.
[10:14] And then the third major way to promote
[10:17] gradual cultivation in ordinary life
[10:20] is through tracking. People don't like
[10:22] to track.
[10:23] What you track
[10:25] tends to get better.
[10:26] So, whether it's formally or informally
[10:30] find some way as best you can to track
[10:33] what you're seeking to develop. A simple
[10:35] way to do that is at the end of the day
[10:37] as you're preparing for bed bed, look
[10:39] back on the day and identify at least
[10:42] one moment or one way in which you were
[10:46] developing what you wish to strengthen.
[10:50] And increasingly establishing yourself
[10:53] and in your life. That's tracking,
[10:55] pretty informal. You could also have a
[10:57] daily checklist. You could even break it
[10:59] out morning, afternoon, and evening. And
[11:02] for example, if you're trying to track,
[11:04] you know, letting go of self-criticism
[11:07] or distancing from, separating from the
[11:10] inner critic
[11:12] and leaning more into the good news
[11:14] about yourself that's also true.
[11:17] Maybe you want to make a little check
[11:18] mark in the morning, the afternoon, and
[11:20] the evening each time you do that. Uh
[11:23] maybe after 3 days of that or 1
[11:26] >> [laughter]
[11:27] >> you'll get bored, but at least doing
[11:28] that in the beginning will move you in
[11:30] the right direction. Minutes of
[11:32] meditation. How many minutes a day are
[11:34] you in contemplative practice? That's
[11:36] kind of eye-opening. How many minutes a
[11:38] day are you doing exercise? How many
[11:40] minutes a day
[11:43] are you [clears throat] interacting with
[11:44] your child following their interest
[11:47] instead of your own agenda?
[11:49] Whoa. You know, how many minutes in a
[11:52] row are you listening to your partner
[11:55] without switching the topic to something
[11:57] that, you know, is your topic?
[12:00] Tracking. Tracking huge.
[12:03] Maybe you just happen to know that you
[12:05] create a schedule in which you're doing
[12:07] something you really want to promote,
[12:09] you want to cultivate. And so that's an
[12:10] informal kind of tracking like you know,
[12:13] you block out a certain amount of time
[12:14] and you know you're doing it. Whatever
[12:16] it might be and whatever system works
[12:18] for you, tracking's very powerful. I'll
[12:20] say that observing couples that are
[12:24] having conflicts about, for example, how
[12:28] much time they're how often they're
[12:30] making love or how much time really
[12:32] there's, you know, some kind of physical
[12:35] touch that's not a claim or a pull
[12:39] towards something else.
[12:41] Or how much time they're actually
[12:42] spending in housework or childcare.
[12:45] There's some a lot of disputes about
[12:47] that. One way to resolve those disputes
[12:49] is to really track your time for a week,
[12:52] both of people, fairly, and then compare
[12:54] notes at the end of the week. I find
[12:56] that that's very eye-opening often for
[12:59] people.
[13:00] Uh including realizing that they're
[13:01] spending a certain amount of time each
[13:02] day just doing stuff that's kind of dumb
[13:05] and they don't really want to keep doing
[13:07] cuz there's no value in it. Okay. So,
[13:09] those are three ways to engage
[13:12] cultivation in kind of ordinary life.
[13:15] Great.
[13:16] Now, we're moving into the middle area
[13:19] of the pool. And now I want to talk
[13:21] about certain Buddhist virtues or
[13:24] factors or insights. And to name these
[13:28] as opportunities for sudden awakening
[13:31] and gradual cultivation.
[13:33] Let's see here. So, let's start with the
[13:36] sudden awakening.
[13:40] There are many teachings in the Buddhist
[13:42] tradition
[13:44] and of course there are many other
[13:46] teachings and sometimes similar
[13:47] teachings in other contemplative
[13:49] traditions and wisdom traditions,
[13:51] including those of First Nations
[13:53] indigenous people around the world. A
[13:56] lot of wisdom out there.
[13:58] And a lot of that wisdom comes down to
[14:02] recognizing what's true.
[14:07] Like the recognition that things are
[14:09] continually changing.
[14:11] Or the recognition that when you try to
[14:14] hold on to an experience, it
[14:17] has when you try to hold on to a good
[14:18] experience
[14:20] and holding on to it and possessing it
[14:22] actually ruins it.
[14:24] Oh, you're recognizing what's true
[14:26] there. Recognizing the inevitability, if
[14:29] you, you know, of aging continuously.
[14:32] What did Bob Dylan sing? The one who is
[14:35] not busy being born is busy dying.
[14:38] Right? We are aging. We are prone to
[14:41] illness. Things happen. All uh entities
[14:44] disperse eventually. I had a surgeon as
[14:47] a client in therapy for a while and he
[14:49] said that in the ER, Rick, we have a
[14:51] saying, "All bleeding stops eventually."
[14:55] one way or another.
[14:57] Mhm. It's life.
[14:59] It's life. These are true recognitions.
[15:01] One of the fundamental recognitions
[15:03] that's given in the first two of the
[15:05] ennobling truths is that we create
[15:09] suffering through clinging and craving.
[15:13] We can observe directly that when we get
[15:16] caught up in a kind of contracted,
[15:19] pressured,
[15:20] self-referential,
[15:23] frustrated drivenness,
[15:26] even in fairly mild ways, like wanting
[15:28] to make our point in an
[15:31] in a conversation with someone or to
[15:33] protect our status by impressing others,
[15:37] we start suffering.
[15:39] As soon as craving begins, suffering
[15:41] follows.
[15:43] Now, suffering also
[15:46] can generate craving cuz we want the
[15:48] pain to stop, but that approach to
[15:51] ending the pain that is contracted and
[15:54] pressured and saturated with the sense
[15:56] of self
[15:57] creates other kinds of suffering, even
[15:59] if it ends this kind of suffering.
[16:01] And over time we gradually realize that
[16:04] there's a different way.
[16:06] We may realize as I've really emphasized
[16:10] in my own work and you can see for
[16:11] yourself that craving arises
[16:16] in animals, including big monkeys like
[16:19] us, craving arises in response to the
[16:24] perception or experience of an unmet
[16:28] need.
[16:29] Craving is a drive state.
[16:32] Biologically, it's based in a sense of
[16:35] deficit or disturbance in the meeting of
[16:39] an important need.
[16:41] That's what drives squirrels, mice,
[16:44] lizards,
[16:48] crabs,
[16:51] >> [clears throat]
[16:51] >> to pursue their goals.
[16:53] Therefore, we can observe over time that
[16:56] if we cultivate various strengths, we
[17:00] can meet our needs effectively
[17:03] without getting all contracted and
[17:06] pressured and angry and scared and
[17:10] cranky about it.
[17:13] Wow.
[17:15] It's when we don't have resources inside
[17:17] ourselves that of course we feel
[17:19] desperate or overwhelmed
[17:22] when things are challenging.
[17:24] But as we grow various psychological
[17:26] qualities inside like determination or
[17:28] resilience or confidence or positive
[17:31] emotions or happiness or compassion for
[17:34] our self
[17:36] or mindfulness,
[17:38] as we grow those strengths inside,
[17:41] we don't feel so upset
[17:43] when our needs are challenged. Uh it's a
[17:46] little bit like putting things into your
[17:48] backpack in the long road of life. And
[17:52] when the storms come, instead of getting
[17:54] all upset about it, you reach into your
[17:56] backpack and you pull out a rain shell
[18:00] and a map which then maybe will guide
[18:03] you to shelter.
[18:05] You're coping
[18:06] without suffering.
[18:08] You might be kind of cold, your feet
[18:10] might be
[18:11] tired in your tight boots,
[18:13] speaking from experience, but you're not
[18:15] really suffering.
[18:17] You're just dealing with things that are
[18:18] challenging.
[18:20] Right? Growing strengths inside.
[18:23] Number one way to manage challenges
[18:27] without tipping into craving.
[18:30] Number two way to
[18:33] deal with challenges in this life
[18:34] without tipping into craving is to
[18:36] repeatedly internalize the felt sense of
[18:39] needs met enough in the moment.
[18:41] So that you gradually build up an
[18:44] underlying residues of lived experience
[18:47] in
[18:48] implicit memory, somatic memory, limbic
[18:51] system memory. You gradually build up an
[18:54] underlying sense of feeling already
[18:57] peaceful and content and rested in love
[19:01] even when challenges arise to safety,
[19:04] satisfaction, and connection.
[19:08] This is a basic model I've taught many
[19:10] times. It's fundamental in biology.
[19:12] Animals need to be safe in various ways.
[19:15] They need to be satisfied in various
[19:17] ways. They need to be connected in
[19:19] various ways.
[19:20] They manage their needs for these three
[19:23] by avoiding harms for safety,
[19:27] approaching rewards for satisfaction,
[19:30] and attaching to others for connection.
[19:35] Avoiding, approaching, and attaching
[19:37] three great systems.
[19:39] Those systems fundamentally can operate
[19:41] under two conditions.
[19:43] One is the red zone, I call it, in which
[19:47] there's a sense of not enoughness and
[19:51] you know, an invasive sense of a need
[19:54] that triggers craving.
[19:56] Craving is in the red zone. Alternately,
[19:59] animals like us can meet distri-
[20:01] challenges can
[20:03] to our needs by feeling resourced enough
[20:05] already and resting in a fundamental
[20:09] underlying core of resilient well-being.
[20:12] If understandably around the edges is
[20:15] some anxiety, some anger, some
[20:17] frustration, some disappointment, some
[20:20] envy, some feelings of hurt and
[20:23] insecurity, but they do not, as the
[20:25] Buddha described in his own run-up to
[20:27] awakening,
[20:28] these
[20:32] feelings around the edges do not invade
[20:35] the mind and remain.
[20:38] And then third way to deal with
[20:42] life's challenges without dropping into
[20:43] craving is very embedded in the
[20:46] teachings around insight
[20:49] in which we develop increasing insight
[20:51] into our own mind
[20:53] that enables us to stand step back from
[20:57] our reactive patterns
[20:59] and to recognize that they're not
[21:04] inherently compelling.
[21:06] They're occurring,
[21:08] but we don't need to identify with them.
[21:10] They're passing,
[21:12] they're changing,
[21:14] and we don't need to get hijacked by
[21:16] them.
[21:18] These three great ways
[21:20] to cultivate the awakenings that can
[21:23] occur in with regard to fundamental
[21:26] Buddhist teachings.
[21:28] Building up strengths inside,
[21:30] building up a durable core emotionally,
[21:33] a resilient well-being,
[21:35] and cultivating insight.
[21:40] Okay?
[21:42] That's the shallow That's the medium end
[21:44] of the pool.
[21:46] And it's already pretty deep, isn't it?
[21:49] And then there is insight
[21:52] and awakening into our true nature. I
[21:55] just want to speak to a question that
[21:57] very understandably came in. So, what is
[22:00] the difference between savoring or
[22:03] taking in the good of an experience com-
[22:07] What is the difference between that and
[22:09] clinging to it?
[22:11] Very important question. First of all, a
[22:13] broad point. We tend to savor those
[22:15] experiences that feel good. The point
[22:18] I'm making about deliberate
[22:19] internalization, deliberate cultivation
[22:22] applies to the
[22:24] all possible beneficial experiences,
[22:27] many of which we would not really savor,
[22:29] per se, like the like uh
[22:32] understanding how to be more skillful in
[22:34] some ways, or recognizing an idea that
[22:37] everything changes, or sometimes one of
[22:40] the healthy things to grow inside is
[22:43] remorse about certain kinds of conduct.
[22:47] We don't really savor remorse, and yet
[22:49] there's a place for internalizing it. Uh
[22:51] disenchantment is another somewhat
[22:54] unpleasant but important beneficial
[22:56] experience in which we realize that uh
[22:59] we've been overestimating the rewards of
[23:01] certain
[23:02] paths of behavior in life, or we've been
[23:04] real like we realize, "Darn, I'm never
[23:07] going to get promoted in this job, or
[23:09] this person is never going to be the
[23:11] mate I really want in this life." And we
[23:13] kind of wake up from the spell,
[23:15] disenchantment. So, I want to I use the
[23:17] word deliberate internalism or word
[23:19] internalization rather than savoring
[23:21] just as a technical broad point. So,
[23:23] what's the difference between that and
[23:26] craving clinging? You can immediately
[23:28] feel the difference.
[23:29] When you're craving clinging, you're
[23:31] contracted, you're pressured, there's a
[23:34] presumption in some ways that the
[23:35] experience is solid, you're going to
[23:38] possess it, you're going to keep it.
[23:41] In what I'm talking about, it's more
[23:43] like you keep the river flowing.
[23:46] There's a stream of a particular sort
[23:48] moving through you. You're experiencing,
[23:51] let's say, your own worth in some way.
[23:54] Or you're experiencing someone caring
[23:56] about you, or you feel cared about,
[23:58] right? Or you feel strong and
[24:00] determined.
[24:01] Or you're rested in the knowing that
[24:04] there's short-term gain from banging
[24:07] down three glasses of wine, but there's
[24:10] going to be some long-term pain.
[24:12] So, you're resting in that experience.
[24:14] You're receiving it,
[24:16] you're regulating attention slightly so
[24:19] it doesn't wander off or get distracted,
[24:21] you're staying with it, and then you're
[24:23] engaging other factors, such as opening
[24:26] to it in your body, recognizing what's
[24:29] novel or fresh about it, recognizing
[24:31] what's personally relevant, feeling
[24:34] what's rewarding about it. You're doing
[24:35] these various things that are skillful
[24:37] means in terms of evidence-based
[24:39] positive neuroplasticity. It feels very
[24:42] different. And you know, play with that,
[24:44] I would say. Play with that. It's sort
[24:46] of like resting at the front edge of now
[24:49] while receiving what's beneficial into
[24:51] you with a real receptivity to it.
[24:55] A real absorption of it rather than the
[24:58] usual
[25:00] nice and moving on to the next thing.
[25:02] Okay? So, now I want to go back to the
[25:05] quotation and you can deliberately
[25:08] internalize not just for a few breaths,
[25:10] you can marinate in something for a long
[25:13] periods of time. You're simply
[25:16] helping yourself be changed
[25:18] bit by bit, synapse by synapse, for the
[25:21] better from the experiences you're
[25:22] having.
[25:23] That's the deliberate internalization I
[25:25] was speaking to. And you can see much
[25:27] more about it in many things I've done
[25:29] about it, including a formal
[25:31] paper published in a peer-reviewed
[25:33] journal, uh learning to learn from
[25:35] positive experiences. You can see more
[25:37] about it there. Okay? So, now let's go
[25:40] to this quotation in the deep end of the
[25:42] pool.
[25:43] All right?
[25:44] Having to do with your own true nature.
[25:47] This is
[25:48] your truly
[25:50] true nature.
[25:51] Really.
[25:53] Mine, too, happily.
[25:55] >> [snorts]
[25:55] >> So,
[25:58] consider the twofold approach of sudden
[26:00] awakening followed by gradual
[26:02] cultivation.
[26:04] The ordinary person does not know that
[26:07] their own numinous awareness, their
[26:10] sentience, is the true Buddha.
[26:14] If in one moment of thought
[26:16] they then follow back the light of their
[26:18] mind to its source and see their own
[26:21] original nature,
[26:23] they will discover that the ground of
[26:24] this nature is innately free of
[26:27] afflictions
[26:28] and that they themselves are originally
[26:31] endowed with the nature of wisdom
[26:34] that is free from the contaminants
[26:37] which is not a hair's breadth different
[26:39] from that of all the Buddhas.
[26:42] Hence, it is called sudden awakening.
[26:46] Although they have awakened
[26:49] the beginningless proclivities of habit
[26:52] are extremely difficult to remove
[26:54] suddenly.
[26:55] For this reason, they must continue to
[26:58] cultivate while relying on this
[27:00] awakening.
[27:02] Through this gradual process of
[27:04] suffusion
[27:05] their practice will be perfected.
[27:08] Uh this comes from Jinul
[27:10] arguably the leading teacher in Korean
[27:13] Zen translated by Robert Buswell.
[27:16] And I've modernized and degendered uh
[27:19] the language there.
[27:20] So, we could read this again and again
[27:22] and again and it would I think add value
[27:25] to do so. Another quotation, a similar
[27:29] one that's much shorter
[27:33] is this one.
[27:36] This one comes from Robert Buswell. The
[27:39] self-nature, in other words, the
[27:41] inherent nature of suchness
[27:44] which gives rise to thoughts yet remains
[27:48] untainted by the things that arise.
[27:53] So, awareness, the depths of awareness
[27:57] gives rise to thoughts and is untainted
[28:01] by thoughts
[28:03] and other contents of consciousness.
[28:06] So, now we are speaking to
[28:09] the intersection
[28:11] of
[28:13] gradual development
[28:15] and true nature already.
[28:18] These are said to be the two wheels of
[28:22] the great wagon of awakening the great
[28:25] wagon of practice.
[28:26] Uh gradual development and true nature
[28:29] already.
[28:31] So, the question is, what is our true
[28:34] nature?
[28:35] Already.
[28:38] This is where we start moving well
[28:40] beyond ordinary clinical psychology
[28:44] and ordinary conventional views.
[28:47] We're moving into the territory that
[28:50] religion in general has occupied.
[28:53] And sometimes people who reflexively
[28:56] resist
[28:57] the occupations
[28:59] and occupations of religion walk.
[29:03] And I just suggest that
[29:05] you be aware of that if that's happening
[29:06] for you and you just kind of set it
[29:08] aside and consider this exploration in
[29:12] terms of several kinds of levels.
[29:15] And see for yourself what is true and
[29:18] see if there's an opening for you around
[29:21] not so sure, maybe so.
[29:24] Let's see.
[29:26] In keeping with the spirit of science as
[29:29] well as the spirit of contemplative
[29:31] inquiry.
[29:34] So,
[29:35] I want to move through this recognition
[29:38] of true nature in sort of three levels.
[29:41] One level described in Buddhism is the
[29:45] level of anatta or interdependence.
[29:50] In which we recognize logically
[29:53] conceptually
[29:55] which then becomes more and more us and
[29:58] embodied experience, we recognize that
[30:01] we are being lived by and made by
[30:06] the
[30:07] physical
[30:09] universe altogether locally here on
[30:12] planet Earth. We We realize that my body
[30:15] is an expression of physical reality.
[30:18] You know, the I've had to consume all
[30:20] kinds of molecules and atoms to make
[30:23] this body. I release many of them. This
[30:26] body is a kind of standing wave of slow
[30:30] motion standing wave yet with a lot of
[30:32] throughput. I recognize that the foods I
[30:35] eat at bottom are sourced through
[30:38] sunlight,
[30:40] light and heat
[30:42] energy traveling from this big ball of
[30:44] gas takes 8 and 1/2 or so minutes to get
[30:47] here.
[30:49] I'm What I eat is congealed sunlight
[30:52] making my body. Yes, I live dependently.
[30:56] That's logical. And you realize as well
[30:57] that your own mindstream, the languaging
[31:00] in it,
[31:01] the underlying memories, the
[31:03] orientations you have are also
[31:05] interdependent with human culture
[31:08] broadly.
[31:09] Information flowing into you and through
[31:12] you from other people.
[31:14] All that together. And you realize, oh,
[31:17] as Buckminster Fuller put it, I seem to
[31:19] be a verb.
[31:21] So, the sense of identity
[31:24] is increasingly recognized as
[31:26] interdependent.
[31:28] And a wonderful metaphor that others use
[31:31] is to
[31:34] realize that, of course, each person is
[31:37] a wave, like a wave in the ocean. Each
[31:39] person is like a wave in the ocean. Each
[31:41] wave is real. There is the identity of
[31:44] this particular wave.
[31:46] Uh there is the identity or the of a
[31:48] particular body-mind
[31:50] process, body-matter, mind-mind,
[31:54] tangible-intangible,
[31:56] both real in different ways,
[31:59] co-occurring, co-creating each other.
[32:01] Yes.
[32:03] Yes.
[32:05] And each wave is being made by the ocean
[32:08] all together.
[32:10] Buckminster Fuller said, I seem to be a
[32:13] verb, I believe.
[32:14] And so, and there can also be the
[32:17] recognition that, wow,
[32:20] each wave is both distinct and
[32:24] interdependent,
[32:26] and the nature of all waves is water.
[32:30] So, this is
[32:33] an entry level
[32:35] >> [laughter]
[32:35] >> into the deep end of the pool. The
[32:37] recognition of interdependence, Thich
[32:39] Nhat Hanh called it interbeing. And it's
[32:42] a beautiful thing. Increasingly, the
[32:44] sense of boundaries start to blur.
[32:47] There's a softening. Distinctions
[32:49] between self and world soften. And
[32:51] paradoxically,
[32:53] taking good care of your particular
[32:55] wave, the particular wave that you are,
[32:58] actually helps us be more open
[33:01] to the waves, the other waves around us.
[33:04] It's okay to take care of persons. It's
[33:07] when persons are inadequately take cared
[33:11] for that the rigidities and contractions
[33:14] and possessiveness of selfing tend to
[33:17] really arise.
[33:22] Okay?
[33:23] And you can explore the cultivation of
[33:26] certainly this sense of inner being.
[33:29] Next level has to do with insight into
[33:34] the empty nature
[33:36] of all phenomena, mental and physical.
[33:40] The empty nature means that they are
[33:44] empty of absolute self-existence.
[33:48] Like a living room that could be empty
[33:49] of furniture is empty of the furniture.
[33:51] It's empty of sofas and couches and
[33:54] lamps. It's empty. Doesn't have them.
[33:57] In other words, all experiences and all
[34:00] material phenomena are made of parts
[34:03] that are connected and changing.
[34:05] Parts that are connected and changing.
[34:08] This is one of the primary teachings of
[34:10] the Buddha. It may seem like, "No, I
[34:12] don't want to really think about this."
[34:14] Okay, and it's what our coach, our
[34:16] doctor, our teacher, Shakyamuni
[34:19] Siddhartha long time ago really taught.
[34:22] That everything is of the nature.
[34:25] Everything that arises is subject to
[34:27] impermanence. Everything that arises is
[34:30] made of parts. Everything arises
[34:32] dependently upon its preceding causes.
[34:35] And when you start recognizing that your
[34:37] thoughts
[34:39] have the nature of emptiness,
[34:41] that
[34:42] your life has the nature of emptiness,
[34:45] that the lives of those who annoy you
[34:47] has the nature have the nature of
[34:48] emptiness,
[34:50] then they're not so fraught.
[34:52] They're not so upsetting.
[34:53] They're more like foam
[34:55] or clouds than bricks.
[35:00] You start realizing that the
[35:01] conventional self that you took to be
[35:04] unified, enduring, and independent
[35:07] is made of parts
[35:09] that are changing
[35:11] and arise dependently.
[35:14] Wow.
[35:16] You recognize that the self
[35:18] you took to be so solid is actually
[35:20] empty of that kind of solidity.
[35:24] Whoa. Now, don't go down that road if
[35:26] you're prone to psychosis or
[35:29] depersonalization
[35:31] or a fragment ted sense of self. Be
[35:34] careful here. Protect yourself. Shore up
[35:37] your sense of person. A psychologist
[35:39] psychologist,
[35:41] psychiatrist 30, 40 years ago wrote Jack
[35:44] Epstein, Engler, anyway. You have to be
[35:47] somebody
[35:48] before you can become nobody.
[35:51] That's very important. But still,
[35:53] emptiness.
[35:54] And then, even more deeply
[35:57] and this starts getting
[35:59] again layered.
[36:01] You start to recognize that the
[36:04] that there is a field in which
[36:06] experiences are occurring.
[36:10] A field that itself is undisturbed by
[36:14] the experiences moving through it.
[36:17] Now, you could take that in a very
[36:18] conventional way.
[36:21] You could also take it one layer more
[36:23] deeply by recognizing that in your being
[36:29] seems to be a core
[36:31] or a layer inherent in a human body
[36:35] mind.
[36:36] I don't know about cats and dolphins and
[36:38] lizards and monkeys. Maybe, but
[36:40] certainly or octopi, including
[36:42] octopuses, octopi. There is a layer of
[36:45] core in you that you can recognize
[36:48] that has qualities of stillness and
[36:52] wakefulness and inner peace and wisdom.
[36:56] It seems to be inherent.
[36:58] It's not disturbed by what passes
[37:00] through. It's not touched by them in
[37:03] some way. It's not affected by them.
[37:08] You can locate inside yourself a
[37:11] fundamental undisturbable
[37:14] level in your own being.
[37:19] Words like numinous or radiant
[37:23] are ascribed to it. Spacious. It any It
[37:27] can hold any experience.
[37:32] It's not restricted.
[37:36] We're still inside
[37:39] ordinary reality here.
[37:45] And then most deeply this is where I do
[37:48] think this Korean Zen teacher is
[37:50] speaking. This
[37:52] depth in ourselves can open into that
[37:54] which is
[37:55] unconditioned as the Buddha pointed to,
[37:58] transcendentally distinct from the
[38:00] conditioned Big Bang universe. Some
[38:03] people use the term absolute underlying
[38:06] radiant perfection.
[38:11] Jinul is pointing to that.
[38:16] Now, we could intuit this.
[38:18] Now, we might say, "Nope, I'm just going
[38:20] to stop at the waterline.
[38:22] I've had it. This is all sounding too
[38:24] religious here. Okay?"
[38:26] Or
[38:28] you might already have an intuition of
[38:31] this or you might even be interested in
[38:34] cultivating a sudden awakening that can
[38:36] occur.
[38:38] How do we cultivate the sudden awakening
[38:40] that Jinul is talking about?
[38:43] All right.
[38:44] And I want to go back to some of the
[38:46] words
[38:47] he's using. He talks about the ground of
[38:50] your nature is innately free of
[38:53] afflictions.
[38:56] And you are innately endowed with a
[38:58] wisdom that is free of contaminants.
[39:02] You are endowed with Buddha nature.
[39:05] Okay.
[39:07] So,
[39:13] there are three fundamental attributes
[39:16] of the underlying ground.
[39:19] One is stillness
[39:23] because it's not subject to arising and
[39:25] passing away.
[39:28] And the sense of stillness is a way in
[39:32] through gradual cultivation
[39:36] to the depth of your own being. So,
[39:38] exploring stillness and tranquility
[39:43] is a close cousin. It's the portal into
[39:47] an intuition and felt sense increasingly
[39:49] of stillness.
[39:52] Vastness, boundlessness
[39:56] is another attribute of the absolute. It
[40:00] It's without limit. It's without bound.
[40:05] And a sense of spaciousness, the
[40:08] spaciousness of the field of awareness,
[40:11] and then the spaciousness,
[40:13] you know, of you of the imagination of
[40:15] the universe is like
[40:18] It's not the same as, but it's like the
[40:20] inherent unboundedness, the inherent
[40:24] vastness of this ultimate ground. So,
[40:27] cultivating a sense of stillness and
[40:30] cultivating a sense of vastness are
[40:34] close cousins. They are portals into
[40:39] They are like the nature of the
[40:41] ultimate.
[40:42] That's part of gradual cultivation.
[40:49] And
[40:51] so in addition to those two practices of
[40:54] cultivation
[40:56] cultivating a recognition of stillness
[40:59] cultivating a recognition of vastness in
[41:02] your own ordinary life.
[41:06] In addition to that, there can be a
[41:08] process of allowing identity
[41:11] to start tipping
[41:13] into
[41:17] a sense of being vastness
[41:20] being stillness
[41:22] being the meeting of the absolute and
[41:24] the relative
[41:26] being the meeting of timelessness and
[41:30] time being the meeting in your own case,
[41:34] in your own wave unfolding being the
[41:37] meeting of unconditioned and conditioned
[41:41] continuously.
[41:43] And initially, there can be kind of a
[41:46] sense of that as if you're over here
[41:49] recognizing like, "Oh wow, that might be
[41:51] possible." And tuning into people who
[41:53] are much more rested in that.
[41:55] And speaking from that meeting and as
[41:57] their identity, as who they are most
[41:59] fundamentally.
[42:02] As they live into their personality
[42:05] interacting with others. And then over
[42:07] time, there can be a gradual sense more
[42:09] and more like, "Wow, that really is
[42:11] true." And with it is an incredible
[42:13] relief.
[42:15] Wow, all these horrible things I thought
[42:17] about myself
[42:18] they're all about the surface. They're
[42:20] all about the froth on the surface of
[42:21] the wave of my own person process. All
[42:25] along
[42:26] I've been water
[42:28] and water is innately pure.
[42:31] I've all along, wow. This really is my
[42:34] nature. It's the nature of everything.
[42:36] This meeting of absolute and relative,
[42:38] unconditioned and conditioned,
[42:40] timelessness and time.
[42:42] Wow.
[42:45] And we can increasingly help ourselves
[42:47] in the suffusion. Rest in that.
[42:51] In a fact, we can live in the both end.
[42:56] Modeling
[42:57] very, very awakened beings who are very,
[43:00] very far along, who both
[43:03] see and honor the relative.
[43:06] You know, they tie their shoelaces.
[43:08] They, you know, put the toilet seat down
[43:10] when they're done. They smile and talk
[43:13] and help the world be better. They see
[43:16] the relative, the conditioned
[43:19] time-bound processes unfolding.
[43:23] They do the best they can with their
[43:24] offerings to influence them in good
[43:26] directions. They do.
[43:28] While also
[43:30] abiding in
[43:32] and knowing
[43:34] the underlying true nature of all
[43:37] as their true home.
[43:42] As their resting place
[43:44] from which they live
[43:46] continuously into the next moment
[43:48] arising.
[43:50] And that's our opportunity.
[43:52] That's our opportunity. We might have a
[43:54] simple moment of, "Wow, this has the
[43:57] ring of truth."
[43:59] Or there could be a longing
[44:01] that somehow would not long for this
[44:04] uh if it did not know that there was
[44:05] truth to it.
[44:07] Maybe it's just that, that little bit.
[44:10] And yet on the basis of that little bit,
[44:12] that tiny little seed
[44:16] something grows inside. Some gradual
[44:18] inclination, some gradual leaning
[44:21] and development and cultivation of the
[44:24] fullness
[44:26] of that bit of awakening.
[44:29] That's a beautiful possible path for all
[44:32] of us.
[44:33] And
[44:37] that's what we're doing here.
[44:40] On a path that is, as the Buddha put it,
[44:42] is good in the beginning,
[44:44] good in the middle, and good in the end.
[44:47] Wherever you are on that path, or as
[44:49] Milarepa said, "In the beginning nothing
[44:52] came.
[44:53] >> [snorts]
[44:53] >> In the middle nothing stayed. In the
[44:55] end, nothing left.
[44:57] Yeah.
[44:59] It's a noble journey.
[45:02] One
[45:04] to which you are drawn by the nobility
[45:06] inherent within you,
[45:08] and a journey which ennobles you along
[45:11] the way.
[45:14] That's the truth.
[45:20] Thank you for your kind attention.
[45:22] Thank you for being with me in this
[45:24] journey.
[45:26] And
[45:28] sadhu.
[45:34] So, let's just take a breath or three
[45:37] to kind of rest in this and let it rest
[45:40] in ourselves.
[45:49] This is all about who you really are.
[45:54] Both how to realize it
[45:56] and to
[45:59] increasingly
[46:01] reveal and live in who you really are.