Teaching on discernment
“Your aspirations are mean, and your possessions are miseries!”
St. John of the Cross
St. John of the Cross

St. John of the Cross’s poignant declaration, "Your aspirations are mean, and your possessions are miseries!" invites us to confront the often unexamined nature of our desires and attachments. In a world that equates success with accumulation and ambition, this quote serves as a profound reminder of the spiritual poverty that can accompany such pursuits. It challenges us to reassess what we truly value and to recognize that our aspirations, when rooted in the material, may lead us away from genuine fulfillment.

In a culture that glorifies ambition and material wealth, St. John’s words resonate with a counterintuitive wisdom. He compels us to reflect on the deeper implications of our desires and the burdens they can impose. The notion that our possessions can become sources of misery suggests a profound disconnection between our inner lives and the external world. This disconnection is a theme that runs deep in the spiritual journey, urging us to seek a more authentic existence beyond the superficial allure of worldly aspirations.

The image / the metaphor

At first glance, St. John’s statement presents a stark dichotomy between aspirations and possessions. The term "mean" evokes a sense of pettiness or insignificance, suggesting that our desires are often trivial and unworthy of our attention. Meanwhile, "miseries" conveys a heavy emotional weight, indicating that what we own can become a source of suffering rather than joy. This imagery paints a vivid picture of the spiritual landscape, where the pursuit of worldly goals leads to a cycle of disappointment and disillusionment.

Diving deeper into the metaphor, we can see that St. John is not merely critiquing materialism; he is illuminating the spiritual path that lies beyond it. The "mean" aspirations represent a narrow vision of life, one that is confined to immediate gratification and societal approval. In contrast, the "miseries" of possessions symbolize the burdens we carry when we cling to transient things. This juxtaposition invites us to transcend these limitations and seek a higher, more profound understanding of fulfillment that is rooted in spiritual richness rather than material wealth.

In the speaker's tradition

St. John of the Cross is a luminary in the Christian mystical tradition, where the journey toward divine union often involves a process of purification and detachment. His insights resonate with concepts such as kenosis, the self-emptying of one’s will to make space for divine presence. This idea parallels notions found in other spiritual traditions, such as dharma in Buddhism, which emphasizes the importance of aligning one’s life with a higher purpose rather than personal desire. Both paths encourage a relinquishing of the ego's grip on aspirations and possessions.

In his seminal work, "The Spiritual Canticle," St. John explores the soul's longing for God, framing it as a journey that requires letting go of worldly attachments. This text serves as a guide for those seeking to navigate the complexities of desire and fulfillment. The imagery of the soul as a bride yearning for her divine lover encapsulates the transformative power of love that transcends material concerns. By embracing this longing, one can begin to understand the deeper truths of existence that St. John so eloquently articulates.

Living the teaching

Consider a modern scenario where an individual is caught in the relentless pursuit of career advancement. Each promotion and material acquisition brings a fleeting sense of satisfaction, yet it is quickly replaced by the anxiety of maintaining status and the fear of losing what has been gained. In this context, St. John’s teaching serves as a wake-up call, prompting the individual to question whether their aspirations are truly aligned with their deeper values or merely reflections of societal expectations. This realization can lead to a profound shift in focus, from external validation to inner peace.

In relationships, the impact of St. John’s wisdom can be equally transformative. Imagine a partnership where one person is constantly seeking validation through material gifts or social status, while the other yearns for genuine connection and emotional intimacy. Here, the "miseries" of possessions can create barriers to authentic love and understanding. By recognizing the superficiality of such aspirations, both partners can begin to cultivate a deeper bond rooted in shared values and spiritual growth, ultimately leading to a more fulfilling relationship.

A reflection

As we contemplate St. John of the Cross’s profound assertion, we are invited to engage in a reflective inquiry: What aspirations and possessions in my life are leading me away from true fulfillment? This question encourages us to examine the motivations behind our desires and the impact they have on our spiritual journey. By embracing this inquiry, we can begin to discern the path that leads not to misery, but to a deeper understanding of ourselves and our connection to the divine.

St. John of the Cross
ArtistSt. John of the Cross

Spanish mystic, Carmelite friar, and poet. His Dark Night of the Soul maps the spiritual journey through suffering to divine union.

Got Questions?

St. John of the Cross suggests that our desires often lack depth and significance, leading us to pursue superficial goals that ultimately result in suffering. He emphasizes the importance of seeking fulfillment beyond material possessions, which can become burdensome rather than sources of joy.
You can apply this teaching by reflecting on your own desires and possessions, asking yourself if they align with your deeper values. Consider simplifying your life by letting go of unnecessary attachments and focusing on what truly brings you joy and fulfillment.
Yes, similar themes can be found in the writings of other Christian mystics, such as Teresa of Avila and Meister Eckhart, who also emphasize the importance of detachment from worldly desires in favor of a deeper spiritual connection.
Kenosis refers specifically to the self-emptying of one's will to allow for divine presence, while letting go in this context encompasses a broader range of attachments, including material possessions and superficial aspirations.
Practices such as mindfulness meditation, journaling, or contemplative prayer can help you become more aware of your desires and attachments, allowing you to discern what truly matters in your life.
You can recognize if your aspirations are 'mean' by reflecting on whether they bring you lasting joy or merely temporary satisfaction. Consider if they align with your core values and contribute to your spiritual growth.

Continue Reading

View All