Teaching on discipline
“He can hardly catch it again.”
St. John of the Cross
St. John of the Cross

St. John of the Cross poignantly observes, "He can hardly catch it again," a reflection on the fleeting nature of spiritual insight and the discipline required to nurture it. This statement encapsulates the struggle many face in their spiritual journeys, where moments of clarity and connection can slip away just as quickly as they arrive. Understanding this quote invites us to consider the importance of practice and discipline in our spiritual lives, as well as the profound sense of loss that can accompany the absence of these insights.

In a world that often prioritizes immediate gratification, St. John’s words serve as a reminder of the deeper, more enduring truths that require patience and dedication. The spiritual path is not merely about the attainment of knowledge or experiences; it is about cultivating a relationship with the divine that demands our attention and commitment. The recognition that insights can be ephemeral urges us to engage more fully with our practices, lest we find ourselves unprepared when the moment of grace arrives.

The image / the metaphor

The imagery in St. John’s quote evokes a sense of urgency and fragility. The phrase "catch it again" suggests that spiritual insights are akin to delicate butterflies, beautiful yet elusive, requiring both skill and timing to grasp. The use of "hardly" emphasizes the difficulty inherent in this endeavor, hinting at the challenges one faces in trying to recapture a moment of divine clarity once it has passed. This metaphor resonates deeply with anyone who has experienced the fleeting nature of inspiration or insight, highlighting the need for vigilance and readiness in our spiritual pursuits.

Diving deeper into the metaphor, we can see that the act of "catching" implies an active engagement with the spiritual life. It is not enough to passively wait for insights to arrive; one must cultivate the conditions that allow for such moments to flourish. This requires a disciplined approach to practice, whether through prayer, meditation, or other forms of contemplation. The metaphor invites us to reflect on our own readiness to embrace these insights when they come, and to consider what practices we might need to refine in order to better "catch" the divine when it graces us with its presence.

In the speaker's tradition

St. John of the Cross, a key figure in the Christian mystical tradition, emphasizes the importance of discipline and practice in the pursuit of spiritual union with God. His teachings resonate with concepts found in other spiritual traditions, such as dharma in Buddhism, which underscores the necessity of right action and ethical living as a means to enlightenment. Similarly, the idea of kenosis, or self-emptying, aligns with St. John’s notion that one must let go of attachments and distractions to fully embrace the divine presence. This interplay of discipline and surrender is central to the mystical journey, inviting practitioners to navigate the delicate balance between effort and grace.

In his seminal work, "The Dark Night of the Soul," St. John explores the transformative process of spiritual purification, which often involves periods of desolation and longing. This text serves as a poignant reminder that the path to spiritual insight is rarely linear; it is fraught with challenges that can lead to profound growth. The experience of loss, as articulated in his quote, becomes a catalyst for deeper understanding and connection, urging us to remain steadfast in our practices even when the fruits of our labor seem distant.

Living the teaching

Consider a modern scenario where an individual embarks on a new spiritual practice, such as meditation. Initially, they may experience moments of clarity and peace, but as time passes, these moments become less frequent, leading to frustration and doubt. St. John’s insight resonates here, as the practitioner realizes that the initial spark of inspiration is not enough; it requires ongoing commitment and discipline to sustain the practice. This situation illustrates the importance of perseverance in the face of spiritual challenges, reminding us that insights may come and go, but our dedication to the path must remain steadfast.

In the context of relationships, St. John’s teaching can also be applied to the dynamics of connection and communication. When misunderstandings arise, the initial feelings of love and understanding may seem to dissipate, leaving individuals feeling lost and disconnected. The challenge then becomes one of discipline—how can we cultivate the practices of empathy and active listening that allow us to reconnect? By recognizing that moments of clarity in relationships are precious and require nurturing, we can learn to approach our interactions with greater intention and care, ultimately fostering deeper connections.

A reflection

As we contemplate St. John of the Cross’s poignant observation, we might ask ourselves: What practices am I engaging in that allow me to catch the fleeting moments of spiritual insight? This question invites us to reflect on our own spiritual journeys, encouraging us to examine the disciplines we uphold and the ways we prepare ourselves to receive the divine. In recognizing the transitory nature of these insights, we are called to cultivate a deeper commitment to our practices, ensuring that we remain open and receptive to the grace that life offers.

St. John of the Cross
ArtistSt. John of the Cross

Spanish mystic, Carmelite friar, and poet. His Dark Night of the Soul maps the spiritual journey through suffering to divine union.

Got Questions?

St. John of the Cross suggests that spiritual insights are fleeting and require discipline to nurture. Once a moment of clarity or connection passes, it can be difficult to recapture, emphasizing the need for ongoing commitment to spiritual practices.
You can apply this teaching by establishing a consistent spiritual practice, such as meditation or prayer, that allows you to cultivate awareness and readiness for moments of insight. By dedicating time to these practices, you create the conditions necessary to catch those fleeting moments of clarity.
Yes, the theme of the elusive nature of spiritual insight is prevalent in other Christian mystical writings, such as those by Teresa of Avila and Meister Eckhart, who also emphasize the importance of discipline and the challenges of maintaining spiritual awareness.
Discipline involves the consistent practice and effort required to cultivate spiritual insight, while surrender refers to the willingness to let go of control and allow grace to unfold. Both are essential in the spiritual journey, as they complement each other in the pursuit of deeper connection.
Engaging in contemplative practices such as mindfulness meditation, journaling, or spiritual reading can support living this teaching. These practices help cultivate awareness and readiness for moments of insight, allowing you to catch them when they arise.

Continue Reading

View All