BrightStar

Browse All Events

Discover conscious gatherings

events

Yoga
Meditation
Breathwork
Qigong
Tai Chi
Sacred Music
World Music
Medicine Music
Sound Healing
Ecstatic Dance
Popular Destinations
BaliSedonaLos AngelesCosta RicaNew YorkSan FranciscoAustinMiamiJoshua TreeTulum
View All CategoriesView All Destinations

Explore All Features

Powerful tools to grow your events

Platform Features

Smart Dynamic Pricing
Ticket Categories
Assigned Seating
Abandoned Cart Recovery
Visitor Recovery
Donations & Sliding Scale
Affiliate Engine
Ticket Scanner
Coupon Codes
Custom Questions
Ticket Sharing
Upsells & Add-ons
Analytics & Reporting
Email Sequences
Waitlist / Notify / Remind
People & Places
Artists & TeachersEvent OrganizersVenues & StudiosKnowledge BaseGlossaryInspiration
View All FeaturesAbout Us
PricingBlog
Language
Saved events
Browse All Events

events

YogaMeditationBreathworkQigongTai ChiSacred MusicWorld MusicMedicine Music

Popular Destinations

BaliSedonaLos AngelesCosta RicaNew YorkSan Francisco

People & Places

Artists & TeachersEvent OrganizersVenues & StudiosKnowledge BaseGlossaryInspiration

Platform Features

Smart Dynamic PricingTicket CategoriesAssigned SeatingAbandoned Cart RecoveryVisitor RecoveryDonations & Sliding ScaleAffiliate EngineTicket ScannerCoupon CodesCustom QuestionsTicket SharingUpsells & Add-onsAnalytics & ReportingEmail SequencesWaitlist / Notify / Remind
View All FeaturesAbout Us
PricingBlog
Log inFind EventsHost Events
  • Browse All Events
  • For Seekers
  • Yoga
  • Meditation
  • Breathwork
  • Qigong
  • Tai Chi
  • Sacred Music
  • World Music
  • Medicine Music
  • Sound Healing
  • Ecstatic Dance
  • Retreats
  • Workshops
  • All Categories →
  • Bali
  • Sedona
  • Los Angeles
  • Costa Rica
  • Tulum
  • Byron Bay
  • San Francisco
  • Austin
  • New York
  • San Diego
  • Denver
  • Seattle
  • Portland
  • Miami
  • All Cities →
  • Join the Movement
  • Why we list
  • Sell Globally
  • For Creators
  • For Teams
  • For Writers
  • For Teachers
  • For Kirtan Artists
  • For Studios
  • For Festivals
  • For Retreat Centers
  • For Nonprofits
  • Brand Ambassador
  • Free Ticketing
  • Elevate
  • Amplify
  • 500K+ Buyer Network
  • Abandoned Cart Recovery
  • Smart Dynamic Pricing
  • Ticket Categories
  • Recurring Events
  • Assigned Seating
  • Affiliate Engine
  • Waitlist / Notify
  • Ticket Scanner
  • Embed Widget
  • Event Syndication
  • Message Center
  • Integrations
  • Reports
  • All Features →
  • About
  • The Ecosystem
  • Blog
  • Glossary
  • Inspiration
  • Help Center
  • Contact
  • API Docs
  • Brand Assets
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy

Events

  • Browse All Events
  • For Seekers
  • Yoga
  • Meditation
  • Breathwork
  • Qigong
  • Tai Chi
  • Sacred Music
  • World Music
  • Medicine Music
  • Sound Healing
  • Ecstatic Dance
  • Retreats
  • Workshops
  • All Categories →

Destinations

  • Bali
  • Sedona
  • Los Angeles
  • Costa Rica
  • Tulum
  • Byron Bay
  • San Francisco
  • Austin
  • New York
  • San Diego
  • Denver
  • Seattle
  • Portland
  • Miami
  • All Cities →

For Creators

  • Join the Movement
  • Why we list
  • Sell Globally
  • For Creators
  • For Teams
  • For Writers
  • For Teachers
  • For Kirtan Artists
  • For Studios
  • For Festivals
  • For Retreat Centers
  • For Nonprofits
  • Brand Ambassador
  • Free Ticketing
  • Elevate
  • Amplify

Features

  • 500K+ Buyer Network
  • Abandoned Cart Recovery
  • Smart Dynamic Pricing
  • Ticket Categories
  • Recurring Events
  • Assigned Seating
  • Affiliate Engine
  • Waitlist / Notify
  • Ticket Scanner
  • Embed Widget
  • Event Syndication
  • Message Center
  • Integrations
  • Reports
  • All Features →

Company

  • About
  • The Ecosystem
  • Blog
  • Glossary
  • Inspiration
  • Help Center
  • Contact
  • API Docs
  • Brand Assets
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
BrightStar
Get the app
Download on theApp StoreGet it onGoogle Play
© 2026 BrightStar. All rights reserved.
Inspiration

How to Savor Life: Three Ways to Beat Negativity Bias

Arthur Brooks
Arthur Brooks
May 4, 2026
9 min read
Watch · 7

Savoring, as Arthur Brooks presents it in his Office Hours episode "How to Enjoy Your Life," is the deliberate act of noticing, lingering over and amplifying the good things in an ordinary day. He argues that most of us are simply not present for our own happiness, because the brain is built to register threats more readily than pleasures. His route into the idea runs through a painting studio in Seattle, a lesson about looking before making a mark, and a body of behavioral science about why positive experiences pass by unnoticed. He closes with three practical moves: savor across past, present and future; widen the set of techniques you use; and deliberately look forward to things. What follows works through his argument and why it holds up as more than a self-help slogan.

Read · 9 sections

What did a childhood painting lesson teach Arthur Brooks about attention?

Brooks begins with a scene from his teenage years. Coming home from school, he would practice his French horn, then paint alongside his mother. "It was just bliss," he says, though he was clear that she was the better artist, not only because she was older but because she had more ability. Around the age of 13 or 14, he asked her how he could improve. Her answer is the spine of the whole episode:

"Look deeply at the thing you're trying to draw, that you want to draw. Think about it and look at it again. Stare at it. Look at the nuances. Then try."

That advice is about attention before action. The instruction is not to draw faster or harder but to stay with the subject until its details reveal themselves. Brooks recognized that his mother was describing a skill that applies well beyond sketching. Her mixed-media work, he notes, was known in the Pacific Northwest, and she was also an amateur violinist and pianist. He describes her as someone who was often in great pain, living with serious mental health problems and illness for most of her life, and he says every day could be a chore. Yet her routine had a clear turning point. She would come down, have a cup of decaf (she could not have caffeine because of her medication), eat a little breakfast, and head up to her studio. "Life started at that moment," he recalls. "She was a different person."

The detail matters because it reframes savoring. It was not a luxury she reached for once her life was in order. It was the practice that made the rest of her life bearable, and Brooks saw it up close.

What does it actually mean to savor an experience?

Brooks opens the episode with a line that sets the stakes: "One of the biggest ways that we miss our happiness is that we're not here, we're not fully alive." The problem he is naming is not a shortage of good things. It is inattention. A pleasant meal, a walk, a conversation with someone you love can pass through us without leaving much behind, because we are thinking about the next task, the last mistake, or the worry we have been carrying.

Savoring is the corrective. Brooks is clear that it applies not only to good experiences but to neutral and even bad ones. The episode has a segment on what savoring really is (around 9:52), and a later one on how it affects the brain and body (around 10:39). He also argues that savoring shapes memory, which is part of why it matters for how we later remember our lives (around 14:54). The through-line is that attention is not passive. When you deliberately take in an experience, you change what you retain from it, and you change how it feels while it is happening.

This is where the studio lesson pays off. Brooks's mother did not paint to escape her life. She painted by giving her full attention to the subject in front of her. Savoring, in his telling, is the same discipline applied to a sunset, a cup of coffee or an afternoon at work.

Why do good moments slip past us so easily?

The episode's central scientific claim is that we have a built-in negativity bias. Brooks ties this directly to the difficulty of savoring: because the mind is wired to notice what could go wrong, we tend to overlook positive experiences unless we make an effort to notice them. The bias is not a character flaw. It is an inheritance from a brain that had to prioritize danger, and it still does, long after most of us have left conditions where that priority was useful. The segment on negativity bias begins around 17:16, and it is the logical hinge of the episode. If the default setting filters out the good, then savoring is not an optional enhancement. It is a counterweight that has to be applied on purpose.

This framing is useful because it turns an apparently vague goal, "be happier," into a concrete problem with a concrete fix. You are not failing to feel joy because something is wrong with you. You are being pulled toward threat, and you can train against that pull.

How do you savor across past, present and future?

Brooks's first technique is to savor in all three time zones (the segment begins around 20:18). The idea is that happiness is available in memory, in the moment, and in anticipation, and most people use only one of these channels.

  • The past: revisit good memories on purpose. Brooks mentions looking at old videos and recalling places he used to go, such as the Oregon coast, as an example of returning to experiences that once gave pleasure.
  • The present: give full attention to what is happening now, including ordinary tasks. Brooks makes the point with a mundane example. Savoring is not reserved for grand occasions; it can apply even to washing the dishes.
  • The future: look forward to what is coming. This is the third technique and gets its own treatment later in the episode.

The strength of this approach is that it does not require a dramatic change in circumstances. Most people already have memories they could revisit, a present they are already in, and a calendar with at least one thing on it. Savoring across all three simply asks you to notice which channels you have been ignoring.

What are the other ways to widen your savoring practice?

The second technique, which Brooks frames as expanding your savoring techniques (around 24:34), is about variety. If you only savor in one way, the practice can become stale or lose its effect. Brooks encourages listeners to build a wider repertoire. Within this section he offers small, almost physical cues. "Smile even if you don't feel it," he says at one point, pointing to how outward gestures can open a door to the experience itself. The point is not that a smile solves anything. It is that the body can participate in savoring, and the more ways you have to draw attention into a moment, the more likely you are to catch it.

Why does looking forward to something make you happier?

The third technique is to look forward to things, and Brooks describes it as a practice he uses himself (around 27:21). The question he poses to the audience is simple: what are you looking forward to? Anticipation is a form of savoring because it lets you enjoy an experience before it arrives. It also gives the present a direction. In the segment around 23:52, he makes the link between looking forward and the future more explicitly, noting that dread can dominate our thinking about what is ahead and that deliberately shifting toward anticipation counters it.

Brooks's own version is a small, repeatable habit. Rather than treating the future as a source of anxiety to be managed, he treats a coming event as something to taste ahead of time. The effect is modest on any single day and cumulative over weeks.

Can you savor a hard experience?

This is the most demanding part of the episode, and Brooks handles it carefully. He argues that savoring is not limited to pleasant events. In the segment on savoring difficult experiences to support growth (around 29:12), he suggests that the same attention you bring to good moments can help you find meaning in pain, and that doing so can support growth. He is not asking anyone to pretend that suffering is good. He is asking whether a hard experience can be met with the same deliberate attention that his mother gave to a blank canvas, so that it teaches rather than simply wears you down.

Brooks's personal history gives this claim weight. The illness that shaped his mother's life was not a metaphor for him. It was the reality he watched every morning, and the studio was where he saw her find something real within it.

What does this look like in a demanding season of life?

The episode closes with a listener question (around 31:19) about making space for relationships during a demanding period of work. Savoring is directly relevant here. When a schedule is full, relationships are often the first thing to lose their attention, not because they matter less but because they are the easiest to postpone. A savoring practice does not fix an overloaded calendar, but it changes what you notice inside it, including the people who are already present in your days.

Where to go from here

The most useful next step is to try the three-time-zone practice for a single day. Pick one memory to revisit, one ordinary task to do with full attention, and one upcoming event to look forward to. Notice what changes in how the day feels, and what you retain from it.

  • Watch the full episode, "How to Enjoy Your Life," on Arthur Brooks's YouTube channel, paying close attention to the negativity bias section (around 17:16).
  • Explore his newsletter at arthurbrooks.com/newsletter for further writing on happiness and meaning.
  • If you want to take the work into a structured setting, Brooks describes a series of science-backed retreats in Santa Fe, with details at retreats.arthurbrooks.com.
  • To send a question for the show, write to officehours@arthurbrooks.com.

Brooks's central instruction, borrowed from a painter who taught him to stare before trying, is simple. Attention is the first form of care. Give your life the look your mother gave her canvas, and it may start to reveal what was there all along.

Comments

Loading the conversation…

Transcript

[0:00] As a kid, I would come home from school

[0:02] and I would practice my French horn and

[0:04] then I would paint with my mother and it

[0:05] was just bliss. But my mom was better

[0:07] than me, not just because she was older,

[0:09] but because she had more ability. I

[0:10] remember asking her, I was probably 13

[0:12] or 14 years [music] old, how I could

[0:14] improve as an artist. She said, "Look

[0:17] deeply at the thing you're trying to

[0:19] [music] draw, that you want to draw.

[0:21] Think about it and look at it again.

[0:23] Stare at it. Look at the nuances.

[0:25] Then try." Savouring experiences [music]

[0:28] in life, neutral experiences, good

[0:30] experiences, even bad experiences, can

[0:33] be fundamentally game-changing in your

[0:35] [music] well-being. One of the biggest

[0:36] ways that we miss our happiness

[0:39] is that we're not here, we're not fully

[0:41] alive. And I promise you that if you

[0:44] learn to savor your life,

[0:45] your life's going to change.

[0:53] Hi friends, welcome to Office [music]

[0:55] Hours. I'm Arthur Brooks. This is a show

[0:56] about how you can lift people up and

[0:58] bring them together in bonds of

[0:59] happiness [music] and love using actual

[1:02] science and ideas. This is a show that

[1:04] actually shows you how research can be

[1:06] in the public interest and indeed your

[1:08] interest. If you want to lift people up,

[1:10] if you want to help people to become

[1:12] their best selves, this show's for you.

[1:14] That's why I do it. I want to be

[1:15] happier, I want you to be happier, and I

[1:17] want you to help other people to be

[1:18] happier. And furthermore, this is not

[1:21] just a self-improvement idea. This is

[1:23] one that's actually based in data and

[1:24] that's what we'll be talking about. This

[1:25] is an evidence-based program about how

[1:28] to live your best life. Hope you've

[1:30] enjoyed it so far. If you do, please

[1:32] recommend this show to other people. Uh

[1:33] hit like and subscribe wherever you're

[1:36] uh listening or watching this show. That

[1:37] actually helps the algorithms find other

[1:39] people, as a matter of fact, and and I

[1:41] appreciate you doing that an awful lot.

[1:43] If you have questions or criticisms or

[1:45] comments, we want to hear it. Leave it

[1:46] in the notes, um leave it in the comment

[1:48] sections, wherever you're consuming this

[1:50] content, or send me a note at

[1:52] officehours@arthurbrooks.com.

[1:54] Uh don't forget to leave a review. We

[1:56] want to know what you think and once

[1:57] again, that's really helpful to the show

[1:59] so that we can continue to spread as we

[2:00] are. Bigger audiences almost every week.

[2:03] So, thanks to you for that. Hey friends,

[2:05] a lot of you know that I keep a very

[2:06] high protein diet. That's important for

[2:08] me in my 60s cuz I want to maintain a

[2:10] good level of muscle protein synthesis

[2:12] [music] and I don't always have time to

[2:14] eat as much protein as I want from whole

[2:16] foods. That's the ideal, but it's just

[2:18] not manageable all the time. For that

[2:20] reason, I'm always looking for

[2:21] supplements that can actually get me

[2:22] where I need to go with respect to my

[2:24] macronutrient profile. A bunch of my

[2:26] friends were telling me that David

[2:28] Protein is a really good source. The

[2:30] reason is because protein bars in

[2:32] general, they're handy, they're

[2:34] convenient, but they can be very high in

[2:35] calories and they can actually be really

[2:37] high in carbohydrate, especially in the

[2:39] form of sugar. David Protein, I heard,

[2:42] was better and sure enough, it's got a

[2:43] great profile. It has 40% [music] more

[2:46] protein and 57% fewer calories than most

[2:49] of the protein bars you find out there.

[2:51] 28 g [music] of protein, 150 calories, 0

[2:54] g of sugar. That's actually quite a feat

[2:57] to put that together. And by the way,

[2:58] they taste great. [music] David Protein

[3:00] has a new bronze line with 20 g of

[3:02] protein, 150 [music] calories, and 0 g

[3:05] of sugar. That comes to 53% calories

[3:08] from protein, another industry-leading

[3:10] protein-to-calorie ratio, [music]

[3:12] as most leading protein bars on the

[3:14] market average 40% or lower. Each

[3:17] [music] bronze bar features a smooth,

[3:19] decadent marshmallow base with a

[3:20] flavor-filled layering, airy [music]

[3:22] crisp, and a chocolate-flavored coating,

[3:24] providing a different taste and texture

[3:26] profile compared [music] to our hero

[3:27] gold line. I started buying David

[3:30] Protein bars and now I'm pleased that

[3:31] they're sponsoring [music]

[3:32] this show as well. So, whether you're on

[3:35] the go or hitting the gym, if you're

[3:36] trying to meet your protein targets,

[3:37] [music] David Protein is a good way for

[3:39] you to do it. That's why I'm doing it

[3:41] and it's what I'm carrying when I'm on

[3:43] the road. So, head over to

[3:44] davidprotein.com/arthur.

[3:46] They got a special offer for you. If you

[3:48] buy four cartons, they'll give you the

[3:49] fifth carton for free. You're going to

[3:51] love that. And you can also find David

[3:53] Protein in [music] stores by looking for

[3:55] the store locator. So, enjoy.

[3:59] You're not broken.

[4:01] You're meaning starved.

[4:03] I talk to people all the time who are by

[4:05] any external measure successful. They

[4:08] build careers. They have families.

[4:10] They've checked the boxes. And yet,

[4:12] something feels off. Life feels thin.

[4:16] Like you're going through the motions.

[4:18] Like you're watching yourself [music]

[4:19] from the outside.

[4:21] And here's what I want you to know. That

[4:22] feeling is not a personal failing. It's

[4:25] not ingratitude. [music] It's not

[4:27] something wrong with you.

[4:29] It's a meaning problem.

[4:31] And it's an epidemic.

[4:33] The modern world [music] is

[4:34] extraordinary at giving us comfort,

[4:36] achievement, and distraction. It's

[4:38] terrible at giving us meaning.

[4:40] And no amount of success will fix that.

[4:43] I've seen it in my research, and I've

[4:45] seen it in [music] my own life.

[4:47] That's exactly what we work on at MEA,

[4:49] the Modern Elder Academy, in a program

[4:52] I've developed called The Meaning of

[4:54] Your Life.

[4:55] It's not a lecture. It's not a quick

[4:57] fix. It's several days of real work

[4:59] [music] in a small group on the

[5:01] questions that actually matter.

[5:04] If what I'm describing sounds familiar,

[5:06] I hope you'll come take a look.

[5:11] I'm recording this

[5:13] uh a little bit before Mother's Day

[5:16] 2026. It's going to play pretty close to

[5:18] Mother's Day as a matter of fact, and so

[5:20] you're probably thinking about Mom,

[5:21] whether Mom is still alive or not, and I

[5:23] hope you had a good experience growing

[5:25] up with your mom. I hope you love your

[5:26] mom. Everybody deserves to, for sure.

[5:28] Not everybody does.

[5:30] Um I want to tell you a little story

[5:31] about mine. Not because this is a show

[5:33] about Mother's Day, but because

[5:35] this is going to help me explain a very

[5:37] important phenomenon for your happiness.

[5:41] My mother was my late mother. She died

[5:44] relatively young, 73. She suffered a lot

[5:46] because she was very ill for most of her

[5:48] life as a matter of fact. She was

[5:50] however

[5:52] a terrific artist. She was an artist of

[5:53] some renown in the Pacific Northwest. I

[5:55] grew up in Seattle, Washington. And she

[5:57] was a terrific mixed media artist. Many

[6:00] people in the Pacific Northwest own her

[6:02] paintings.

[6:03] She did this

[6:05] to the exclusion of most other things

[6:06] over the course of her life. She was

[6:07] also an amateur violinist and pianist.

[6:09] So she was really into the arts and a

[6:11] creative soul to be sure. One of the

[6:13] reasons that she was

[6:14] so dedicated to her art, if you've been

[6:16] a

[6:17] a listener of this program over the last

[6:19] few weeks, you'll recognize this

[6:21] argument. It is that when you

[6:24] participate in the production of beauty,

[6:26] you illuminate the right hemisphere of

[6:27] your brain and you find the meaning of

[6:28] your life.

[6:30] When my mother would wake up in the

[6:31] morning, she was she was really in a lot

[6:33] of uh really in a lot of agony. She

[6:35] suffered from tremendous mental health

[6:37] problems and

[6:39] I mean every day was a chore. It just

[6:42] was.

[6:43] And then she would come down and have a

[6:45] cup of decaf and

[6:47] cuz because of her medication she

[6:48] couldn't take caffeine and and she would

[6:50] have a little breakfast and then she

[6:51] would head up to her studio.

[6:54] And and life started at that moment. She

[6:56] was a different person. It was

[6:57] extraordinary as a matter of fact how I

[6:59] saw that.

[7:00] And she was a great artist. She was

[7:03] fantastic. She had excellent technique.

[7:05] If she decided to paint a naked guy

[7:07] holding a guitar

[7:09] um much to my mortification as a

[7:11] teenager it actually looked like that.

[7:13] And it was beautiful to boot I guess

[7:15] although once again as a teenager I

[7:16] wouldn't have been able to discern that.

[7:18] Now growing up um I was very interested

[7:20] in the arts myself. I was more of a

[7:22] musician as a matter of fact I made my

[7:24] living as a classical musician for many

[7:25] years until I was 31 years old. But I

[7:28] was interested in all different kinds of

[7:29] creativity. I wrote stories and poetry

[7:32] and I painted with my mother.

[7:34] As a kid I would come home from school

[7:35] and I would practice my French horn and

[7:37] then I would paint with my mother and it

[7:39] was just bliss. You know and I just I I

[7:41] loved it too.

[7:42] Not knowing of course that my little

[7:44] right hemisphere was fully illuminated

[7:46] and I was experiencing the the meaning

[7:47] of my life.

[7:49] But my mom was better than me, not just

[7:50] because she was older, but because she

[7:51] had more ability. I remember asking her,

[7:53] I was probably 13 or 14 years old, how I

[7:56] could improve as an artist and I

[7:57] expected her to say,

[7:59] do a lot. Get the reps, which certainly

[8:02] is true. That's not what she told me.

[8:03] She said,

[8:05] "Here's the reason that people can't

[8:06] draw. Here's the reason. Because they

[8:08] actually never look at the thing they're

[8:10] trying to draw."

[8:12] She said, "Look deeply at the thing

[8:15] you're trying to draw, that you want to

[8:17] draw. Think about it and look at it

[8:19] again. Stare at it. Look at the nuances.

[8:22] Then try."

[8:24] So, I was actually

[8:26] trying to draw a tree. Simple thing,

[8:28] right? And I would look at it and go and

[8:29] try to draw the tree. Didn't look like a

[8:30] tree. Didn't look very good at all.

[8:32] Then I really stared at it. I really

[8:35] took in uh

[8:36] the details of what I was looking at. I

[8:38] was

[8:39] I wasn't relying on my brain to fill in

[8:41] the details. I was actually observing

[8:43] the details, the contours, the colors,

[8:45] the shadows.

[8:46] And I drew a pretty good tree. Now,

[8:48] here's the point of that.

[8:50] I was also happy.

[8:52] When I was I remember being really

[8:53] happy, not because the tree looked good,

[8:55] but because the whole experience was

[8:56] rich. What was that?

[8:59] It turns out that that was an experience

[9:01] of what we call savoring.

[9:03] Savoring experiences in life, neutral

[9:06] experiences, good experiences,

[9:09] even bad experiences, can be

[9:10] fundamentally game-changing in your

[9:12] well-being. And that's what I want to

[9:14] talk about today.

[9:15] In our hustle and grind culture, where

[9:17] everything is fast, where we're

[9:20] distracted constantly, one of the

[9:22] biggest sources, one of the biggest ways

[9:25] that we miss our happiness,

[9:27] is we're not here. We're not fully

[9:29] alive. Now, this is not just a call for

[9:32] some sort of mindfulness meditation

[9:34] technique.

[9:35] This means simply savoring life as it's

[9:39] happening right now. I want to tell you

[9:42] why it's so important, and I want to

[9:44] tell you how you can do it in your

[9:45] ordinary life. And I promise you that if

[9:48] you learn to savor your life,

[9:50] your life's going to change. Let's start

[9:51] off with some, you know, some basics of

[9:53] what savoring actually means. Savoring

[9:55] is it is to pay attention

[9:58] and to say, "I want to be doing this

[10:01] right now. I want to be fully absorbed

[10:04] in this thing right now." That's what

[10:06] savoring really is. So, you savor the

[10:08] experience of eating a piece of

[10:10] chocolate. You don't just gobble it up.

[10:14] You actually put it in your mouth and

[10:15] you taste it on your tongue, and you

[10:17] feel the texture of the chocolate, and

[10:18] you're conscious of it. Say, "That's

[10:21] that's smooth that or that's sweet." Or

[10:23] whatever it happens to be. That's what

[10:24] savoring really is all about. Or if you

[10:26] savor moments with your beloved before

[10:29] you say goodbye, you're experiencing the

[10:31] look in her eyes

[10:33] and the the smell of her skin,

[10:35] and you're conscious of that. That's

[10:37] what savoring really is.

[10:39] Now, there's been a lot of research on

[10:41] how that affects you psychologically,

[10:44] how that affects you

[10:45] neurophysiologically.

[10:47] And it's pretty interesting what

[10:49] researchers have come up with. When

[10:50] you're savoring, when you're paying

[10:51] attention, when you're immersive, when

[10:53] you're here now

[10:55] on something neutral, positive, or

[10:57] perhaps even negative, I'll get to that

[10:59] later, you're actually it it stimulates

[11:01] the reward processing centers in your

[11:04] brain. Your brain's ventral striatum.

[11:06] There's two parts of your limbic system

[11:08] that principally are responsible for you

[11:10] feeling pleasure. One is the ventral

[11:12] striatum, and the other's called the

[11:13] ventral tegmental area. You tap those

[11:15] things, you know.

[11:16] Now,

[11:17] they're very thrifty, which means there

[11:19] are lots of ways to tap it. If you say,

[11:21] if my wife says to me, "I just love you

[11:23] so much." It will tap these pleasure

[11:26] centers, and I'll say,

[11:27] "Joy." Right? That's positive emotion.

[11:30] If I had a huge bump of cocaine, it

[11:32] would do the same thing because of my

[11:34] thrifty brain. By the way, I don't do

[11:35] that. But you get the point that I'm

[11:37] actually trying to make.

[11:38] So,

[11:39] when you savor, you will actually

[11:42] stimulate that ventral striatum, that

[11:44] part of your brain that and and there's

[11:45] interesting research on that that of

[11:47] course, as always, I'm going to put in

[11:48] the show notes. This is a paper called

[11:50] savoring the past, positive memories

[11:52] evoke values representation in the

[11:54] striatum from neuron, which is a

[11:56] terrific journal, neuroscience journal.

[11:59] So, all you have to do to do that is to

[12:02] pay attention and say, "I want to be

[12:04] paying attention to this. I like paying

[12:06] attention to this." And then really

[12:08] look, like I was looking at that tree

[12:09] that day.

[12:11] You can even savor completely ordinary

[12:13] things like,

[12:15] "Right now, I am walking to the post

[12:17] office."

[12:18] That's the essence of what the great

[12:20] Vietnamese Buddhist monk Thich Nhat

[12:23] Hanh, of course, one of the most famous

[12:25] Buddhist in the world, um a Theravada

[12:27] Buddhist monk, Vietnamese, when he wrote

[12:29] his famous classic, The Miracle of

[12:31] Mindfulness, which starts off with this

[12:33] just explanation, this description of

[12:36] washing the dishes. When I'm washing the

[12:37] dishes, I should be fully present in the

[12:39] act of washing the dishes. What he's

[12:40] saying is savor washing the dishes.

[12:44] Don't rush through it. Be fully present.

[12:47] Be saying, "This is what I'm doing now.

[12:48] I like the fact that I'm savoring this.

[12:51] I like the fact that I'm fully present."

[12:53] And that will

[12:55] stimulate, once again, I'm here to tell

[12:56] you that's going to stimulate your

[12:57] pleasure centers. You're going to get

[12:58] pleasure from washing the dishes, but

[13:01] only if you savor washing the dishes.

[13:03] The second thing that does, this is an

[13:04] interesting study from 2022, is it

[13:06] lowers symptoms of depression and

[13:08] increases higher levels of reported

[13:10] happiness. Probably that's related to

[13:12] the first effect that I talked about

[13:14] because when you when you stimulate the

[13:16] parts of the limbic system that elicit

[13:18] the feelings of joy,

[13:19] that's not consistent with the the the

[13:22] affective pain that we actually get,

[13:24] which is the activation of that the

[13:26] anterior cingulate cortex, a different

[13:28] part of the limbic system. And third, it

[13:31] it leads to these

[13:33] higher levels of reported happiness in

[13:36] in not in looking at people's brains,

[13:39] but just asking for

[13:41] people's experiences.

[13:43] There's one study where researchers

[13:45] asked human subjects to record the

[13:46] frequency and intensity of their daily

[13:49] positive experiences.

[13:51] Half of the subjects in these

[13:53] experiments were asked to savor

[13:55] savor their events in their lives, to be

[13:57] fully present, to be paying attention.

[14:00] And they found that these subjects were

[14:01] significantly happier after the

[14:03] experiment than those who were not given

[14:05] any specific instructions. In other

[14:07] words, if I just remind you to be fully

[14:08] present, you're going to be happier.

[14:11] You're going to enjoy your life more.

[14:13] This is especially clear for people who

[14:15] experience Here's our Here's the irony.

[14:18] For people who experience fewer positive

[14:19] events. In other words,

[14:22] if you're living a life that is tough

[14:24] and you're going through a really tough

[14:25] time right now, and you savor the

[14:28] moments that you like,

[14:30] you know, this all of us go through

[14:31] these things. We're really stressed out

[14:32] or really really too busy or

[14:35] but there's going to be a moment like,

[14:36] you know, sun coming through the clouds

[14:38] a little bit, you stop and you say, "Oh,

[14:39] yeah.

[14:40] Sunshine on my face." And you savor it,

[14:43] that will have a disproportionately

[14:45] joyful impact on you. The less good

[14:48] there is, the more good you get.

[14:51] That's one of the benefits of savoring.

[14:53] It also leads to happier memories later

[14:55] on, which is interesting that the more

[14:57] that you savor the present, the more

[14:59] you're going to remember the present

[15:01] when it becomes the past, because you

[15:03] lay down more intense memories in the

[15:06] hippocampus of your brain. The episodic

[15:07] memories are actually more distinct when

[15:09] you savor them. It It makes perfect

[15:11] sense, doesn't it? You remember the

[15:13] things where it feels like time slowed

[15:14] down because you were fully present. By

[15:16] the way, this is one of the reasons that

[15:17] when when you're in the middle of a car

[15:19] accident, it feels like time slows down,

[15:21] because you're laying down hugely

[15:23] complex memory tracks in those moments.

[15:26] You're savoring the experience of

[15:28] getting T-boned by a semi or something,

[15:31] which, you know, not so great, I

[15:32] suppose.

[15:34] Actually, more on that later because I

[15:36] want to tell you how negative events can

[15:38] be savored much to your advantage as

[15:40] well, but we're not there yet. So, savor

[15:42] more, have happier memories later. Now,

[15:44] this is important. This one's really

[15:45] important to me personally. I'll tell

[15:46] you why. I don't have very many happy

[15:48] memories. It's not like I had some

[15:50] trauma, some terrible childhood, but

[15:53] I don't have happy memories. I just

[15:54] don't. I don't like remembering the

[15:56] past. I don't like looking at childhood

[15:58] photo albums. I don't like it. I don't

[16:00] like looking at old videos. Just

[16:02] bugs me. It bothers me. It makes me

[16:04] uncomfortable to do that. I mean, I

[16:06] practically don't drive looking in the

[16:07] rearview mirror. I'm a dangerous driver.

[16:09] But, I mean, I go through life not

[16:11] looking in the rearview mirror. It's

[16:12] through the through the windshield of

[16:13] the car. It's just for some reason

[16:15] that's how I'm I'm wired. I don't like

[16:18] talking about the good old days. And so,

[16:19] it's hard for me to keep up with my old

[16:21] friends, as a matter of fact, because

[16:22] it's just past. I don't know. I mean, I

[16:24] have this one set of really, really

[16:26] happy memories. When somebody says,

[16:27] "What are your happiest memories from

[16:28] childhood?" They're all the same thing.

[16:30] I used to go down to the Oregon coast

[16:32] with my Aunt Marie.

[16:34] Um and

[16:35] Lincoln City. Lincoln City, Oregon. And

[16:38] it's funny because those of you who've

[16:39] been a long-time

[16:41] uh viewer of this show, you know that

[16:42] I'm great friends with Rainn Wilson, the

[16:44] actor. And um

[16:45] his wife grew up going to the Oregon

[16:47] coast in the exact same places as me.

[16:49] And we reminisce about that, actually,

[16:51] which is sweet and and and really good.

[16:53] But but generally, I don't like it. I

[16:54] don't like that. And what I've learned

[16:56] from the literature, this is how I try

[16:57] to engineer my own life is by by using

[16:59] the research to live better, is right

[17:01] now what I'm trying to do with my life

[17:02] is savor more now because I want better

[17:05] memories. I I don't want to be

[17:07] the kind of guy that can't

[17:09] remember the past in a positive way. So,

[17:11] why is it hard? Why don't we naturally

[17:13] do it? If this were such a great thing,

[17:14] then we'd be savoring everything all the

[17:16] time, and life would be sweet, right?

[17:17] Well, it's hard because we're not

[17:19] evolved to savor anything. We're evolved

[17:22] to rush through everything and pay

[17:23] attention to the negative. That's what

[17:25] we're designed to do. Now, why? You as a

[17:29] viewer of the show, you know that I rely

[17:31] a lot on evolutionary, biological, and

[17:33] psychological um arguments and and

[17:35] because they're compelling and because

[17:37] they're morally right. We have brains

[17:39] that were designed in more or less their

[17:41] current form something like 250,000

[17:43] years ago in the late Pleistocene era.

[17:46] And that was a dangerous time to be Homo

[17:48] sapiens. You know, you had to pay

[17:49] attention a lot or you're going to be a

[17:51] wild animal's lunch. There was no law.

[17:54] Somebody could come in, you know,

[17:56] take your buffalo jerky and animal skins

[17:59] and you know, kill you summarily if

[18:00] you're not paying attention. So, we have

[18:02] more brain space dedicated to negative

[18:04] emotions than positive emotions. That's

[18:06] what gives us what we call the

[18:07] negativity bias in our lives. Negativity

[18:10] bias means that life isn't that great

[18:11] all the time, but it it we're more

[18:14] likely to get to tomorrow.

[18:16] We're more likely to survive the night.

[18:18] That makes perfect evolutionary sense

[18:21] that your suspicious, nervous inner

[18:24] troglodyte

[18:25] is trying to survive and pass on your

[18:27] genes. So, you're not a saber-tooth

[18:28] tiger's lunch, but

[18:30] that negativity bias is now maladapted.

[18:33] It's basically an error that we would do

[18:35] that, that we would not savor, but

[18:37] rather that we would be suspicious and

[18:39] vigilant and trying to get into the

[18:41] future as quickly as possible. As a

[18:43] survival tactic that doesn't actually

[18:44] lead us to happiness. One quick note,

[18:46] Mother Nature who did that doesn't care

[18:48] if we're happy. That is an important

[18:50] thing to keep in mind. Mother Nature

[18:52] wants us to survive and pass on our

[18:53] genes.

[18:54] But that's why we have a wonderful

[18:56] prefrontal cortex so that we have

[18:57] decisions

[18:59] we can make conscious decisions not just

[19:01] to live according to our animal

[19:02] impulses, but to live up to our moral

[19:04] aspirations. That's the beautiful thing

[19:06] about being human. That even though I

[19:08] have a negativity bias, I can override

[19:10] it with my consciousness.

[19:12] And that's what we're talking about

[19:12] here. Savoring is rebelling against

[19:15] yourself.

[19:17] And oh, how freeing that is, isn't it?

[19:20] To resist and up

[19:21] your worst impulses. It's an error

[19:23] because

[19:24] a negative disposition, it's it's

[19:26] maladaptive today because a negative

[19:28] disposition makes us error-prone in our

[19:30] predictions. You're always going to

[19:31] over-predict the worst. You're going to

[19:33] be against assume the worst all the

[19:34] time. That's a heck of a way to live.

[19:37] And it lowers our quality of life, to be

[19:38] sure, of course. Lots of interesting

[19:40] work on this, by the way. I'll put it in

[19:42] a

[19:42] a great article in the notes.

[19:44] Titled, "The Brain Is Adaptive, Not

[19:46] Triune: How the Brain Responds to

[19:48] Threat, Challenge, and Change." And and

[19:49] that's in Psychology, Therapy, and

[19:51] Psychobiotics. It's a nice article.

[19:53] So, savoring is the secret to great

[19:54] happiness, but it doesn't come

[19:56] naturally. How are you going to savor

[19:58] your life more? And and that's what I

[20:00] want to tell you now. What are the

[20:01] techniques for actually savoring more?

[20:03] How What are the techniques for

[20:04] overriding your negativity bias, your

[20:07] tendency to rush into the future, to not

[20:09] pay attention, savor the ordinary

[20:11] moments of your life that you actually

[20:13] need?

[20:14] And I'm going to give you three ways to

[20:15] do it. Three ways that you can savor

[20:17] your life more. Number one. Technique

[20:19] number one for savoring your life. Do it

[20:22] in all three

[20:24] time zones.

[20:25] Okay, now, what do I mean by that? I

[20:27] don't mean literal time zones.

[20:29] I'm talking about savoring the past,

[20:33] savoring the present, and savoring the

[20:34] future. This comes from the work of a

[20:36] the psychologist Fred Bryant

[20:38] who created something called the

[20:39] Savoring Beliefs Inventory, which asks

[20:42] people to to talk about their tendency

[20:44] to seek and enjoy positive experiences

[20:46] and memories.

[20:47] A- And so, how does he talk about it?

[20:49] Richness of reminiscence. In other

[20:51] words, what do I need to do as somebody

[20:53] who struggles with the past?

[20:55] Is think back to the past and think,

[20:58] "What was good about that?" And you know

[20:59] what? I just did that in the opening of

[21:00] the show, didn't I? I mean, I could have

[21:02] talked about the fact that my mom was

[21:03] sad all the time. It seemed to be as a

[21:06] little kid sometimes.

[21:08] I- wasn't sad all the time. She was

[21:10] painting beautiful paintings and those

[21:12] were moments of bliss for her and I

[21:13] remembered that on purpose. Why? Because

[21:15] I was savoring the memory of me savoring

[21:18] the present.

[21:20] This recursive structure created by time

[21:23] travel in the prefrontal cortex. It's a

[21:24] miracle, isn't it? Able to edit my

[21:26] memory in this particular way, in a

[21:28] positive way. Richness of reminiscence

[21:31] is doing exactly that. It's to savor the

[21:33] past on purpose by paying attention to

[21:36] the the positive parts. And by the way,

[21:37] the editing of memory is a very

[21:39] interesting area of research.

[21:41] You know, you can say,

[21:42] "Oh, yeah, you know, Thanksgiving of,

[21:45] you know, 1996, that's when, you know,

[21:47] you know, Uncle Chet, he, you know,

[21:49] got so drunk and he barfed in the front

[21:51] yard and and went and beat up the

[21:52] neighbor."

[21:54] There was something good that happened

[21:55] that day, too, probably.

[21:57] I'm just going to guess.

[21:58] Um, second time zone is the present and

[22:01] that's the degree of conscious

[22:03] enjoyment. That's really kind of the

[22:04] main focus of what we're talking about

[22:06] here, savoring the present, being here

[22:09] fully, thinking about the good that is

[22:12] in this, the experience, the full

[22:13] experience.

[22:15] You know, that's that's that that full

[22:17] experience is has almost theological

[22:18] overtones. The the great uh Catholic

[22:21] saint Irenaeus of the 2nd century,

[22:23] his most famous quote is that

[22:25] the glory of God is a man fully alive.

[22:28] And to be fully alive is to be fully

[22:31] present. Why? Because only in the

[22:33] present can you love. You can't

[22:36] love in a different time. You can't love

[22:38] in the past or love in the future. Love

[22:40] is now.

[22:41] If you're not here now, you're not

[22:43] loving. By the way, important for your

[22:45] relationships. Why should you savor your

[22:48] marriage?

[22:49] Because she needs love and so do you.

[22:52] And then here's the third time zone, the

[22:53] future.

[22:55] And that's

[22:56] something to look forward to. That's

[22:57] keenness of anticipation. Now, that

[22:59] could this a little All can go a long

[23:01] way. According to Marty Seligman at

[23:03] University of Pennsylvania, the average

[23:05] Homo sapiens spends 30 to 50% of the

[23:08] time thinking about the future because

[23:11] it's incredibly adaptive. You you

[23:12] practice future scenarios, see the

[23:15] dangers, come back to the present, and

[23:16] don't choose those roots and those paths

[23:18] into the future. That's how we That's

[23:20] why human beings are so awesome is

[23:22] because we're able to make mistakes in

[23:25] our minds and not make them in real

[23:26] life.

[23:27] And so, the average person is literally

[23:28] 30 to 50% of the time in the future, but

[23:31] the average striver, and I'm looking at

[23:33] you,

[23:34] and I'm kind of looking in the mirror,

[23:36] spends something like 80% of their time

[23:37] in the future.

[23:39] These are estimates. Your results may

[23:40] vary as they say in the commercials.

[23:42] But, if you're 80% of your time in the

[23:44] future and it's all castles in the sky,

[23:46] this can go a long way. But, if you're

[23:48] the kind of person who lives with a

[23:49] little bit of dread,

[23:51] then thinking about things that you can

[23:52] look forward to is all about the

[23:54] savoring of the future. So, you got to

[23:56] figure out is that your challenge or

[23:57] not. If it's not your challenge, good.

[23:59] If it is, that's what to do. You don't

[24:02] have to really choose. I recommend that

[24:03] you choose all three, but I do recommend

[24:05] that you think once again, as I'm

[24:06] emphasizing here, that one of these

[24:08] things is harder for you and that's what

[24:10] you you should actually work on. If you

[24:12] have a hard time being here now, then

[24:13] present savoring is important. If you

[24:14] have a hard time in the past, you need

[24:16] to edit your memories. That's me.

[24:18] If you have a hard time actually getting

[24:19] out of the future, right? Or if you have

[24:21] a hard time actually not being in the

[24:22] future because you have so much dread,

[24:24] then that's what you need to is to find

[24:25] something to look forward to.

[24:27] What do you need to do? What's your

[24:28] challenge? What's the time zone in which

[24:30] you need to savor? Go do that.

[24:32] That's number one. Number two

[24:34] is to expand your repertoire of savoring

[24:37] techniques. This is great stuff from

[24:39] from 2010, where psychologists found

[24:42] four savoring techniques that were

[24:43] really, really effective. So, here's

[24:44] your savoring chops. Here's what Here's

[24:47] how we're going to put it together.

[24:48] Number one is what they call behavioral

[24:50] display, which means expressing positive

[24:53] emotion with nonverbal behaviors. Here's

[24:55] the deal.

[24:56] Smile even if you don't feel it. I think

[24:58] I've mentioned on the show before the

[24:59] Duchenne smile, which is the only smile

[25:02] that's actually associated with true

[25:03] human happiness. It involves two sets of

[25:05] muscles in the face, the zygomaticus

[25:07] major and the orbicularis oculi muscles.

[25:09] You can actually simulate that by

[25:11] holding a pencil in your teeth like

[25:13] this.

[25:14] Uh and kind of uh

[25:16] because happiness is seen in the eyes

[25:17] and not in the mouth. That's the

[25:19] Duchenne smile. That was invented That

[25:21] was not That was named discovered and

[25:23] named by a physiologist named Duchenne

[25:25] because he wanted the happy smile to be

[25:26] named after himself, of course.

[25:28] But you can do that, by the way. I mean,

[25:30] you can put the pencil in your molars

[25:32] and go grin in the mirror.

[25:34] That way, you'll you'll fool your brain.

[25:36] You'll be happier because of this

[25:37] behavioral display, because of what

[25:39] you're doing. This is a This is actually

[25:40] a savoring technique in its own way.

[25:43] Smile more. Pretend you're happier. Go

[25:46] act happier.

[25:47] Behavioral display is number one way to

[25:49] to to savor. When you're doing

[25:51] something, behave

[25:54] with joy.

[25:55] Second,

[25:56] it'd be present, which is mindfully

[25:58] focusing on the pleasant experience. And

[25:59] what that means is saying to yourself,

[26:01] "I am doing this thing. I am sitting on

[26:04] the train looking out at a beautiful

[26:07] seascape."

[26:08] If that's what it is. Being present

[26:10] means actually saying the thing to

[26:11] yourself because you want to bring it

[26:13] from your subconscious into your

[26:15] prefrontal cortex, into your you know,

[26:17] consciousness, where you're really

[26:18] thinking about something. And the way to

[26:20] do that is by saying it. And and it's

[26:22] it's really unbelievably effective.

[26:24] There's a famous piece of avant-garde

[26:26] music from the 1970s by a a

[26:29] French composer named Alvin Lucier

[26:31] called I Am Sitting in a Room. And the

[26:34] whole thing is just I Am Sitting in a

[26:35] Room. And he talks about sitting in the

[26:37] room. It's just like studying savoring

[26:38] and

[26:39] over and over and over and over again. I

[26:41] thought, "How silly?" And now I'm

[26:42] thinking, "I kind of like it."

[26:45] So, say what you're doing to yourself.

[26:47] That's number two. Number three is

[26:48] capitalizing, which means talking about

[26:52] and celebrating positive experiences

[26:53] with others.

[26:54] So, don't just say it to yourself, say

[26:55] it to other people. Talk about the

[26:57] experience that you're actually having.

[26:59] Notice things to other people.

[27:01] Which makes this even more

[27:03] conscious, even more concrete, even more

[27:05] permanent. And last but not least is

[27:07] what they call positive mental time

[27:09] travel. Which is, once again, vivid

[27:11] reminiscence or anticipation of positive

[27:13] events, just what I talked about in the

[27:14] last one. So, those are your four

[27:17] techniques, your repertoire for

[27:18] savoring.

[27:20] Number three, I'm going to talk about

[27:21] how all this works for me. Right? Okay,

[27:23] so I'm This is kind of how I'll put it

[27:25] together. I promised you three, it's

[27:26] actually two, but now I'm going to talk

[27:27] about how I'm trying to do this in my

[27:29] own life. Here's how I do it. I use the

[27:32] research that I'm talking about by

[27:33] starting my morning

[27:35] with a quick reflection on two or three

[27:37] things that I'm looking forward to.

[27:39] Right when I wake up in the morning, the

[27:40] first thing that I do is I I say a

[27:42] prayer.

[27:43] That's how I start my day.

[27:45] Um at some point in the show I'll give

[27:47] you my daily prayer, um if you're

[27:48] interested. Put it in the notes if you

[27:50] are, or if you're not, say don't do

[27:51] that, okay? But then I reflect on two or

[27:53] three things I'm really looking forward

[27:55] to. And for me it'll be my morning

[27:56] workout routine. I just I want to do it,

[27:58] man. I'm just super grateful to wake up

[28:01] and be able to get out of the gym, even

[28:02] when I'm tired.

[28:03] Um getting to this podcast.

[28:06] Having dinner with my wife, whatever

[28:07] it's going to be, whatever that day is

[28:08] going to bring. Just kind of looking

[28:09] ahead a little bit and savoring that.

[28:12] I imagine each of these events vividly

[28:14] for a few seconds, and I make an effort

[28:15] to smile when I'm doing it.

[28:17] Because what I'm doing I'm

[28:18] neurocognitively programming myself to

[28:20] savor that thing, to remember it more,

[28:24] to imprint it in a positive way, so that

[28:26] the episodic memory of that event, when

[28:28] it actually becomes the past, will be

[28:30] positively valenced. Boy, that was a lot

[28:33] of jargon in that last sentence. Forgive

[28:34] me for that. And then finally, before I

[28:36] go to bed, I think back vividly on each

[28:38] one of these experiences, when it is now

[28:40] a memory with a sense of gratitude, and

[28:42] I'll express that gratitude with whoever

[28:44] I'm with, and it's almost always with my

[28:46] wife. At luck, when I'm going to sleep

[28:47] is either with my wife or I'm alone.

[28:49] Now, if I screw this up, um I fail to

[28:52] carry this out because my caveman limbic

[28:54] system wants to hijack the process and

[28:56] wants me to worry about somebody looting

[28:58] my cave and stealing my jerky and animal

[29:01] skins.

[29:02] And so, I start again.

[29:04] And And that's how I try to live. Before

[29:05] it's too good.

[29:07] One last note. I promised you I was

[29:08] going to talk about savoring bad things,

[29:10] too.

[29:11] The research focuses entirely on

[29:14] savoring pleasant events and

[29:16] experiences.

[29:17] But, there are difficult parts of your

[29:18] life, and if you savor them correctly,

[29:21] these can be unbelievably enriching, as

[29:23] well. And here's how I recommend you do

[29:24] that. Here's how you savor the bad.

[29:27] I've mentioned this briefly, but I want

[29:28] to bring it up again in the show.

[29:31] I keep a failure journal.

[29:33] Look, everybody has a lot of failure in

[29:34] their life, disappointment in their

[29:35] life. Lots of things are happening you

[29:37] don't like.

[29:38] When something bothers me,

[29:40] I write it down.

[29:42] Now, sometimes I keep it electronically,

[29:44] and sometimes I keep it in pencil and

[29:45] paper. It's actually better in pencil

[29:47] and paper, you're more likely to

[29:48] remember it. But, I I leave two blank

[29:50] lines

[29:51] under each entry.

[29:53] And I come back to the first one after a

[29:54] month.

[29:56] I go back and I read the thing that

[29:57] bothered me. It It might be something

[29:59] stupid, right?

[30:00] It It might be something kind of

[30:01] important. But, I come back and I say,

[30:03] after a month, after that first blank

[30:05] line, and I write down what I learned

[30:07] in the intervening period

[30:09] thanks to that bad experience. There's

[30:10] always something.

[30:12] It might be, you know, I thought that

[30:14] the argument that I had with somebody I

[30:15] care about,

[30:17] which really bummed me out. I thought it

[30:19] was going to bum me out for a long time,

[30:21] but actually stopped thinking about it

[30:22] almost immediately and didn't hurt the

[30:23] relationship. I learned that. How

[30:25] interesting. Then, after another month,

[30:27] I'll go back to the second blank line

[30:29] that I left after the entry, read it

[30:31] again, and read the thing I learned,

[30:34] and then write something positive,

[30:36] something good that happened as a result

[30:38] of the experience. I might say, "We

[30:40] ended up making amends, and our

[30:41] friendship is actually stronger as a

[30:43] result of that. A good thing happened as

[30:45] a result of our ability to make amends,

[30:47] which which deepened our relationship.

[30:49] Now, trust me, if you give it a bit of

[30:50] thought, you'll have something

[30:51] worthwhile to say about almost negative

[30:53] any negative event. You're not going to

[30:54] say I'm glad it happened,

[30:56] but you might.

[30:58] And you're going to get benefit from

[30:59] learning and benefit in in creating a

[31:02] more positively valenced memory from

[31:05] that, which is a form of savoring of

[31:07] something negative, which will add depth

[31:10] to your life, learning to your life,

[31:11] growth to your life.

[31:13] And that's something that makes every

[31:15] minute of your life worthwhile. I'll

[31:17] just finish with a couple of questions.

[31:19] Um, this comes from Eugene Zhao. Thanks

[31:21] for the email. How should someone

[31:23] earlier in their career

[31:25] think about intentionally maintaining

[31:27] and investing in relationships when so

[31:29] much of the feedback and momentum is

[31:30] pulling them toward work? Okay, yeah.

[31:32] Yeah, yeah, I get it, Eugene. We're all

[31:36] strivers, aren't we? Workaholics, I get

[31:38] it. And the answer to that is actually

[31:40] the work of Josef Pieper. I've done a

[31:43] podcast before on the importance of

[31:45] leisure. Josef Pieper said that there's

[31:47] three kinds of leisure. They do not

[31:49] include chilling on the beach. Cuz I

[31:51] tell you, fellow strivers, you go to the

[31:52] beach and you like the first couple of

[31:54] hours you're like, "This is awesome.

[31:55] It's so nice and I'm warm." By the third

[31:57] hour you're like, "I want to go back to

[31:58] work. I want to go back to work." Why?

[32:00] Because your monkey mind is going to be

[32:01] back in the office or in front of your

[32:03] laptop or wherever it is. This is how

[32:04] you're wired, I get it. Josef Pieper,

[32:07] the German philosopher, said that you

[32:08] should engage your leisure your leisure,

[32:11] which is defined as generative positive

[32:15] activity for which they don't pay you.

[32:17] That's leisure. Three kinds of things.

[32:19] Deepening yourself spiritually,

[32:21] deepening your relationships, and

[32:24] learning something deeply. That's the

[32:26] three things to do. And so, that's

[32:28] actually how to think about that, how to

[32:29] not go back with your monkey mind to the

[32:31] office is because you're dedicating

[32:32] yourself to something that's meaningful

[32:34] under these circumstances. And you need

[32:36] that kind of leisure. William Page

[32:38] writes in to the office hours email

[32:40] address. How would a person raised in a

[32:42] non-religious family choose a religion

[32:44] to begin your recommendation to start

[32:45] first practicing?

[32:47] That's good.

[32:48] That's good. I mean, it's funny because

[32:50] it almost sounds like, "Oh man, there's

[32:51] just so many choices out there." It's

[32:53] like going to the the supermarket and

[32:55] deciding what kind of breakfast cereal

[32:56] and and William, I know that's not what

[32:58] you mean, but you know, look, it's a

[32:59] it's a it's a huge world out there,

[33:01] right? The most important thing that

[33:02] you're telling me is that you want

[33:03] something, that you know there's

[33:05] something deeper and that you're looking

[33:06] for something.

[33:08] Here's the algorithm.

[33:09] Start by reading. Then start by

[33:10] observing. Like a front row seat.

[33:14] And then start by practicing a little.

[33:16] And only then start believing and last

[33:18] but not least maybe start feeling.

[33:20] That's the way to think about it. A lot

[33:21] of people when they're when they're

[33:22] looking for they know they need some

[33:24] sort of a faith or life philosophy at

[33:27] least or

[33:28] coherent spirituality they say, "Well, I

[33:30] got to I got to feel something." No, no,

[33:31] no, no, that's the wrong way to think

[33:33] about it.

[33:34] Feelings are just the activity of your

[33:35] limbic system.

[33:36] That's not how you should pursue your

[33:37] marriage either is by saying, "I got to

[33:39] feel it all the time." You're going to

[33:40] end up divorced. No, no. It's really all

[33:43] about finding something that you can

[33:44] practice every day, believe a lot and

[33:46] occasionally feel. That's your marriage

[33:48] and that's your the religion that you'll

[33:50] actually find if that's what you're in

[33:51] the market for.

[33:53] And the way to do that is by doing the

[33:54] work, is by learning, which is by

[33:56] reading and then observing because it's

[33:58] not not enough just to read, you have to

[33:59] observe and then actually experimenting

[34:01] with practice. From there belief will

[34:03] come and occasionally feeling as well.

[34:05] Good luck on your journey. Last but not

[34:07] least and I don't know how to pronounce

[34:09] this one. I'm sorry, Maciej Buzuk.

[34:12] Close enough. In your research and

[34:14] experience, what is the most important

[34:16] what is the most important for someone

[34:18] in a situation of high competence,

[34:20] genuine contribution, but a persistent

[34:22] inability to translate inner value into

[34:24] outer reward? Now, this sounds an awful

[34:26] lot

[34:27] like you've got an adolescent kid who is

[34:31] unbelievably smart. I'm just guessing

[34:32] here. Unbelievably smart, really, really

[34:35] creative, but not posting.

[34:38] Like in school and in life, not maybe

[34:40] launching as a young adult.

[34:42] And the answer to that is fundamentally

[34:45] to help that person, even if it's you,

[34:47] to find calling. And the way to find

[34:49] calling is the two questions of meaning.

[34:51] This is the meaning exam that I've

[34:52] talked about on the show before.

[34:54] Think deeply about this. Where do I need

[34:56] to go and what do I need to do to find

[34:58] the answers to the two questions, why am

[35:00] I alive and for what would I die?

[35:02] Why am I alive?

[35:03] And for what would I die?

[35:05] Maybe that's who created you, maybe it's

[35:07] what you're on earth to do.

[35:08] And most importantly, for what would you

[35:09] give your life? What are you going to

[35:10] do? Where are you going to go? What are

[35:12] you going to read? Who are you going to

[35:13] ask? What experiences are you going to

[35:15] have so you can find the answers to

[35:16] those two questions?

[35:17] When you do, what you will find is your

[35:20] calling. That's what you're supposed to

[35:22] be doing and that will solve the problem

[35:25] of high competence and low performance,

[35:28] virtually always. We're done.

[35:30] Um, let me know your thoughts at office

[35:31] hours at arthurbrooks.com. Like and

[35:33] subscribe on Spotify and Apple and

[35:35] YouTube and and leave a comment. We want

[35:38] to hear it. Negative, positive, we like

[35:39] it all. Follow me on Instagram,

[35:41] LinkedIn, the other platforms. There's

[35:42] all kinds of content over there that's

[35:44] in shorter form, but it will reward your

[35:46] scrolling as opposed to frittering away

[35:48] your time, I promise. Order the meaning

[35:49] of your life, my new book, to learn more

[35:51] about all the topics I'm talking about

[35:53] here. And and last but not least, um,

[35:55] happy Mother's Day. See you next week.

Arthur Brooks
ArtistArthur Brooks

Seattle-born musician and composer who blends classical and contemporary music with social science, exploring happiness, community, and human connection through albums, books, and…

View profileWebsite
Explore Topics
SavoringNegativity-biasPresent-momentHappinessMindfulness

Got Questions?

Frequently Asked Questions

In his Office Hours episode, Brooks defines savoring as deliberately noticing and lingering over experiences, whether they are good, neutral or even bad. He argues that most people miss their happiness because they are not fully present for their own lives. Savoring is the practice of bringing full attention to an experience so it registers.
Brooks describes negativity bias as a built-in tendency to focus on what could go wrong. Because of it, we tend to overlook positive experiences unless we make an effort to notice them. Savoring is therefore a deliberate counterweight rather than something that happens automatically.
Brooks suggests savoring across the past, present and future. You can revisit good memories, give full attention to what is happening now, and look forward to upcoming events. Most people use only one of these channels, so widening the set can increase enjoyment.
Brooks argues that savoring applies to hard experiences too, and that bringing deliberate attention to them can help support growth. He does not suggest that suffering is good. He frames it as meeting difficulty with the same attentiveness that helps someone find meaning in a hard moment.
Brooks's approach suggests a simple starting point: pick one good memory to revisit, one ordinary task to do with full attention such as washing dishes, and one upcoming event to look forward to. Brooks describes looking forward as a practice he uses himself, and presents the three techniques as small, repeatable habits.
Brooks traces the idea to his mother, a mixed-media artist in the Pacific Northwest. As a teenager he asked her how to improve as an artist, and she told him to look deeply at a subject, stare at it, notice its nuances, and only then try to draw it. He says her studio was where her life visibly began each day.

Continue Reading

More from Arthur

View All
Why Your Free Time Reveals Your Values: A Guide to Leisure
Inspire

Why Your Free Time Reveals Your Values: A Guide to Leisure

Arthur Brooks argues that what you do when no one is paying you says more about who you are than your job does. Here is his framework for te…

1 min read
Three Questions to Test Whether Your Life Matches Your Beliefs
Inspire

Three Questions to Test Whether Your Life Matches Your Beliefs

Arthur Brooks offers three questions for checking whether daily life matches what you believe: coherence, purpose, and significance. Here is…

1 min read
Why Spiritual Seeking Can Keep You From Finding It
Inspire

Why Spiritual Seeking Can Keep You From Finding It

Eckhart Tolle argues that the spiritual search can hide the deep I, which is already present in the now. He reads the Buddha's tree, the 6:3…

1 min read
Staying Grounded When Overwhelm Shuts Down Practice
Inspire

Staying Grounded When Overwhelm Shuts Down Practice

Tara Brach answers the question many practitioners carry: what happens to the spiritual path when life overwhelms us? Her answer is small do…

1 min read

Keep exploring

Continue your journey

More wisdom and gatherings from across the BrightStar directory.

More Articles

Browse the full library of teachings, interviews, and guides.

Back to all articles →

Teachers & Artists

Explore the lineages, musicians, and guides of the conscious world.

Explore artists →

Find an Event

Kirtan, retreats, sound baths, breathwork, festivals — happening soon.

Browse events →