What is Men’s Circle?
A men’s circle is a facilitated or peer-led gathering—typically four to twenty men meeting weekly, biweekly, or monthly—that provides a confidential container for emotional exploration, accountability, and masculine initiation. Participants sit in circle formation, often opening with ritual (drumming, invocation, or check-in rounds), and practice witnessing each other’s stories without judgment, advice-giving, or problem-solving. The core disciplines include speaking from personal experience (“I” statements), honoring confidentiality, and making space for emotional expression that many men rarely access in daily life.
Unlike therapy groups led by licensed clinicians, most men’s circles are peer-facilitated and draw on mythopoetic psychology, archetypal frameworks (warrior, king, lover, magician), and indigenous-inspired ritual rather than clinical intervention. They operate on the premise that modern men have been disconnected from initiatory rites of passage and need communal spaces to process grief, shame, father-wounds, and relationship struggles in the company of other men.
Origins & Lineage
The men’s circle movement emerged from the mythopoetic men’s movement, active in the United States from the early 1980s through the 1990s. Poet Robert Bly (1926–2021) led the mythopoetic men’s movement, and his book Iron John: A Book About Men (1990) spent 62 weeks on The New York Times Best Seller list. The term “mythopoetic” was coined by professor Shepherd Bliss, meaning “to re-mythologize” or “re-story” masculinity.
Inspired by how feminists and folklorists such as Marie-Louise von Franz had used myth and legend to empower women in the mid-20th century, Bly envisioned a similar project to positively reimagine masculinity. He urged men to recover a pre-industrial conception of masculinity through spiritual camaraderie with other men in male-only gatherings. Bly drew heavily on Jungian psychology, Joseph Campbell’s hero’s journey, and Grimm’s fairy tale “Iron John” to articulate archetypes of mature masculinity.
Parallel to Bly’s gatherings, in the mid-1980s, three men from Milwaukee—Ron Hering, Rich Tosi, and Bill Kauth—created the New Warrior Training Adventure (NWTA), a weekend initiation experience that spawned ongoing men’s groups. The training was first held in Wisconsin in January 1985, and in February 1998, the New Warrior Network changed its name to The ManKind Project. Close to 2,000 men participate annually in the NWTA, joining almost 80,000 men who have completed it since 1985.
The New Warrior Training is a direct outgrowth of the feminist movement; feminism in the 1970s and 1980s asked society to re-evaluate how it defined the roles of men and women. Other key influences included Michael Meade, poet Sam Keen, and Jungian analysts Robert A. Johnson and James Hillman.
How It’s Practiced
Men’s circles typically follow a consistent structure: participants arrive, silence phones, and sit in a circle (often on cushions or chairs without tables). An opening ritual—lighting a candle, sounding a bell, drumming, or reading poetry—marks the transition from ordinary time into sacred time. A facilitator or “circle keeper” holds the container by tracking time, inviting speaking turns, and intervening if conflict or advice-giving disrupts the witness mode.
Most circles use a talking piece (a stone, stick, or feather passed hand-to-hand) to ensure only one man speaks at a time. Common formats include:
- Check-in rounds: Each man briefly shares his current state (feelings, struggles, wins).
- Deep dives: One or two men take extended time (20–45 minutes) to work on a specific issue while others listen.
- Structured processes: Guided exercises like “writing a letter to your father,” reenacting a difficult conversation, or embodying an archetype.
- Closing: A brief sharing of gratitude, commitments, or reflections before departure.
Mythopoetic groups often used Native American rituals such as drumming, chanting, and sweat lodges, done with the aim of connecting spiritually with a lost deep masculine identity. This appropriation has been widely critiqued; contemporary circles increasingly acknowledge the problematic history and either avoid indigenous-inspired elements or work directly with indigenous teachers in reciprocal relationships.
Emotional expression is central: men are encouraged to cry, rage, express shame, and access vulnerability. The circle witnesses without trying to “fix” the speaker. Confidentiality is paramount; the phrase “what’s said in circle stays in circle” is nearly universal.
Men’s Circle Today
Men’s circles have proliferated globally, now encompassing secular, spiritual, therapeutic, and activist orientations. They are found in:
- ManKind Project groups: Men’s groups meet in over 120 communities across the USA, with international chapters in 26 countries.
- Independent circles: Many facilitated by coaches, therapists, or elders trained in Gestalt, somatic therapy, or men’s work lineages.
- Retreat centers: Esalen, Kripalu, and other centers host men’s intensives featuring circle work alongside wilderness rites, breathwork, and bodywork.
- Online platforms: Video-based circles emerged during the COVID-19 pandemic and remain accessible to geographically isolated men.
- Niche communities: Circles for fathers, veterans, LGBTQ+ men, men of color, and men recovering from addiction.
Contemporary leaders include Richard Rohr (Center for Action and Contemplation), Boysen Hodgson, Eivind Figenschau Skjellum, and organizations like the Illuman (contemplative men’s spirituality) and the Sacred Sons.
Common Misconceptions
Men’s circles are not therapy groups, though therapeutic healing often occurs. They lack clinical diagnosis, treatment plans, or licensed oversight. Men in acute mental health crisis are typically referred to professional care.
They are not anti-feminist or a retreat into patriarchal power, though early mythopoetic circles faced this criticism. Feminists rightfully criticized the mythopoetic movement because of its universal claims about the male psyche and its silence on issues about women’s rights. Modern circles increasingly integrate pro-feminist, anti-racist, and LGBTQ±affirming frameworks, though this varies widely by facilitator.
They are not religious, though many incorporate spiritual practices. Circles may include Christians, Buddhists, atheists, and pagans; the shared container is psychological and relational, not doctrinal.
Finally, men’s circles are not primarily about “men behaving badly” or indulging aggression. Stereotypical treatments—‘naked men drumming in the woods’—became staples in reporting about Bly and the men’s movement, but the work centers emotional literacy, grief processing, and accountability.
How to Begin
For those new to men’s circles, start by:
- Reading foundational texts: Robert Bly’s Iron John (1990), Sam Keen’s Fire in the Belly (1991), or The Way of the Superior Man by David Deida (though the latter has faced criticism for gender essentialism).
- Attending a public event: The ManKind Project offers weekend trainings (New Warrior Training Adventure); search “NWTA” plus your region. Many retreat centers host open men’s gatherings.
- Joining an existing circle: Websites like Evryman, the ManKind Project locator, and local men’s work facilitators list ongoing groups. Most welcome drop-ins or offer trial sessions.
- Starting your own: Gather 4–8 trusted men, agree on weekly or monthly meetings, and use a simple format: check-in, timed sharing, closing. Books like The Circle Way by Christina Baldwin and Ann Linnea provide structure.
- Hiring a facilitator: Many coaches and therapists specialize in men’s work and can guide an initial series of gatherings until the group self-facilitates.
Men’s circles require commitment (showing up even when uncomfortable), vulnerability (speaking truth rather than posturing), and patience (deep trust builds over months, not weeks). The work is not about fixing masculinity but about inhabiting it more fully—integrating shadow, honoring lineage, and learning to serve family, community, and earth from a grounded, mature masculine presence.
