BrightStar

Parcourir tous les Events

Découvre des rassemblements conscients

events

Yoga
Meditation
Breathwork
Qigong
Tai Chi
Sacred Music
World Music
Medicine Music
Sound Healing
Ecstatic Dance
Destinations populaires
BaliSedonaLos AngelesCosta RicaNew YorkSan FranciscoAustinMiamiJoshua TreeTulum
Voir toutes les catégoriesVoir toutes les destinations

Explorer toutes les fonctionnalités

Des outils puissants pour développer tes événements

Fonctionnalités de la plateforme

Tarification dynamique intelligente
Catégories de billets
Places assignées
Récupération des paniers abandonnés
Récupération des visiteurs
Dons & Prix variables
Système d'affiliation
Scanner de billets
Codes promo
Questions personnalisées
Partage de billets
Ventes additionnelles & Options
Analyses & Rapports
Séquences d'emails
Liste d'attente / Notifier / Rappeler
Personnes & Lieux
Artists & TeachersEvent OrganizersVenues & StudiosKnowledge BaseGlossaryInspiration
Voir toutes les fonctionnalitésÀ propos
TarifsBlog
Language
Saved events
Parcourir tous les événements

events

YogaMeditationBreathworkQigongTai ChiSacred MusicWorld MusicMedicine Music

Destinations populaires

BaliSedonaLos AngelesCosta RicaNew YorkSan Francisco

Personnes & Lieux

Artists & TeachersEvent OrganizersVenues & StudiosKnowledge BaseGlossaryInspiration

Fonctionnalités de la plateforme

Tarification dynamique intelligenteCatégories de billetsPlaces assignéesRécupération des paniers abandonnésRécupération des visiteursDons & Prix variablesSystème d'affiliationScanner de billetsCodes promoQuestions personnaliséesPartage de billetsVentes additionnelles & OptionsAnalyses & RapportsSéquences d'emailsListe d'attente / Notifier / Rappeler
Voir toutes les fonctionnalitésÀ propos
TarifsBlog
ConnexionChercheursCréateurs
  • Parcourir tous les Événements
  • Pour les chercheurs
  • Yoga
  • Méditation
  • Breathwork
  • Qi gong
  • Tai-chi
  • Musique sacrée
  • Musiques du monde
  • Musique médecine
  • Soins sonores
  • Danse extatique
  • Retraites
  • Ateliers
  • Toutes les catégories →
  • Bali
  • Sedona
  • Los Angeles
  • Costa Rica
  • Tulum
  • Byron Bay
  • San Francisco
  • Austin
  • New York
  • San Diego
  • Denver
  • Seattle
  • Portland
  • Miami
  • Toutes les villes →
  • Be Found
  • Sell Globally
  • Pour les créateurs
  • Pour les équipes
  • Pour les écrivains
  • Pour les enseignants
  • Pour les artistes de kirtan
  • Pour les studios
  • Pour les festivals
  • Pour les centres de retraite
  • Pour les associations
  • Ambassadeur de marque
  • Études de cas
  • Billetterie gratuite
  • Elevate
  • Amplify
  • Réseau de 500K+ acheteurs
  • Récupération des paniers abandonnés
  • Tarification dynamique intelligente
  • Catégories de billets
  • Événements récurrents
  • Places assignées
  • Système d'affiliation
  • Liste d'attente / Notifier
  • Scanner de billets
  • Widget intégrable
  • Diffusion d'événements
  • Messagerie
  • Intégrations
  • Rapports
  • Toutes les fonctionnalités →
  • À propos
  • L'écosystème
  • Blog
  • Glossaire
  • Inspiration
  • Centre d'aide
  • Contact
  • Documentation API
  • Ressources de marque
  • Carrières
  • Presse
  • Conditions d'utilisation
  • Politique de confidentialité

Événements

  • Parcourir tous les Événements
  • Pour les chercheurs
  • Yoga
  • Méditation
  • Breathwork
  • Qi gong
  • Tai-chi
  • Musique sacrée
  • Musiques du monde
  • Musique médecine
  • Soins sonores
  • Danse extatique
  • Retraites
  • Ateliers
  • Toutes les catégories →

Destinations

  • Bali
  • Sedona
  • Los Angeles
  • Costa Rica
  • Tulum
  • Byron Bay
  • San Francisco
  • Austin
  • New York
  • San Diego
  • Denver
  • Seattle
  • Portland
  • Miami
  • Toutes les villes →

Pour les créateurs

  • Be Found
  • Sell Globally
  • Pour les créateurs
  • Pour les équipes
  • Pour les écrivains
  • Pour les enseignants
  • Pour les artistes de kirtan
  • Pour les studios
  • Pour les festivals
  • Pour les centres de retraite
  • Pour les associations
  • Ambassadeur de marque
  • Études de cas
  • Billetterie gratuite
  • Elevate
  • Amplify

Fonctionnalités

  • Réseau de 500K+ acheteurs
  • Récupération des paniers abandonnés
  • Tarification dynamique intelligente
  • Catégories de billets
  • Événements récurrents
  • Places assignées
  • Système d'affiliation
  • Liste d'attente / Notifier
  • Scanner de billets
  • Widget intégrable
  • Diffusion d'événements
  • Messagerie
  • Intégrations
  • Rapports
  • Toutes les fonctionnalités →

Entreprise

  • À propos
  • L'écosystème
  • Blog
  • Glossaire
  • Inspiration
  • Centre d'aide
  • Contact
  • Documentation API
  • Ressources de marque
  • Carrières
  • Presse
  • Conditions d'utilisation
  • Politique de confidentialité
BrightStar
© 2026 BrightStar. Tous droits réservés.
Inspire

Inner Change as theFoundation for Systems Change

Plum Village
Plum Village
Sep 24, 2026
8 min de lecture
À regarder · 7

Kate Raworth came to economics with a singular mission: to save the planet. She believed rigorous study of economic systems would equip her to reshape public policy and engineer the change the world urgently needed. But after years of work within that paradigm, she found herself stuck halfway—caught between systems change and the conceptual frameworks that govern how we think about economy, value, and human purpose. The breakthrough came not in a textbook but in silence, in encounter with Plum Village, the monastery founded by Vietnamese Zen master Thich Nhat Hanh. There, she discovered what the title of this dialogue names directly: inner change for systems change—a reordering of where the work must begin.

Brother Phap Linh, a Zen Buddhist monk at Plum Village, arrived at monasticism through a parallel urgency. Twenty or twenty-five years ago—as scientific awareness of ecological polycrisis deepened and accelerated—he faced the same question that drew Raworth: What is the appropriate response? Not denial, not escape, not bypass, but genuine transformation. The conversation between Raworth and Brother Phap Linh unfolds as a meeting of two people who started from opposite angles and converged on the same insight: that the systems we wish to change are manifestations of the consciousness, language, and habits we carry within ourselves.

Lecture · 7 sections

Why Inner Work and Systems Change Are Not Separate

The question surfaces frequently in Plum Village retreats, especially among activists and systems-change practitioners: Why spend time on inner transformation when the planet is burning? The question itself reveals the split that keeps us trapped. Brother Phap Linh and Raworth propose something radical: that this split is false.

The issue runs deeper than motivation or moral courage. It is structural. The systems we inhabit—economic, political, cultural—are expressions of a particular worldview, a fundamental narrative about who and what we are. In the dominant Western paradigm that shapes global economics, the story is one of separation: there is me, and there is the world, and I am essentially apart from it. From that foundational story, everything else follows. We organize economies as extraction, calculate value as profit accumulation, and treat the living world as a resource to be optimized. These are not accidental features; they are logical consequences of a worldview structured around separation.

Raworth describes it with precision: "There's me and there's world and I'm separate from it, and I can understand these as entities." Once you accept that premise, the economic logic becomes inescapable. You organize corporations to pursue profit. You structure countries around growth metrics. You build institutions that reflect and reinforce the same separatist logic that birthed them.

The Language We Breathe

One of the most unsettling insights both speakers touch on is the degree to which the systems we want to change are literally embedded in language—in the words we use, the metaphors we inherit, the narratives through which we frame reality. To change the system, you must first step outside the water you're swimming in, to borrow Raworth's image. But language is that water. You can't see it because you're inside it. Most attempts at policy change, technological innovation, or even "paradigm shift" fail because they stay within the linguistic and conceptual boundaries of the existing worldview. You're rearranging the furniture while the structure of the house remains intact.

This is where contemplative practice becomes not a luxury or a retreat from urgency, but a prerequisite. The three trainings that lie at the heart of Buddhist practice—mindfulness, concentration, and insight—are not consolations. They are methods for seeing through the patterns of thought and language that keep us locked in the paradigm we want to transform. When you sit with your breath, when you observe the arising and passing of sensations and thoughts without grasping or aversion, you're not escaping the world; you're training the mind to perceive differently. And perception, once altered, permits action to change.

From Separation to Interbeing

The alternative worldview both speakers point toward—drawn from Plum Village's adaption of Thich Nhat Hanh's teaching of interbeing—is not metaphorical. It is a direct recognition of ecological and material reality. You are not separate from the world. Your body is composed of the same elements as the earth, the air, the water. Your breath participates in the same exchange of gases as the forest. Your food carries the sun's energy, the soil's minerals, the labor of others. The notion of absolute separation, when examined closely, is empirically false. It is a hallucination maintained by particular habits of attention and language.

When you practice mindfulness consistently—when you train yourself to notice the felt sense of being alive, the sensation of breath, the weight of your body on the ground—you begin to experience, directly and not as an abstraction, the continuity between self and world. Brother Phap Linh's opening meditation guided participants through this: noticing contact with the earth, the support of the ground, the feeling of life throbbing in every cell of the body. This is not poetry. It is attention to what is actually present. And from that grounding, from that direct experience of interconnection, a different way of acting in the world becomes possible.

Redefining the Superpower

One of Raworth's most striking formulations is this: In the face of vast, overwhelming, exponential crisis—climate, biodiversity collapse, systemic injustice—individuals often feel powerless. We're told the problem is too large, too complex, requiring only top-down policy and corporate transformation. But this frames power in the conventional sense: the ability to coerce, to command resources, to impose will from above. Raworth calls attention to a different superpower, one that has been inside us all along: the capacity to shift our own consciousness, and thus our own relationship to action. When millions of people begin to experience themselves not as separate consumers or competitors, but as participants in an interdependent web of life, the ground shifts. Not metaphorically—politically, culturally, economically.

The practice of mindfulness and the cultivation of joy—the speakers emphasize this point—are not distractions from the work. They are fuel for it. When you're operating from a baseline of anxiety, overwhelm, and separatist logic, you'll innovate within those constraints. You'll optimize extraction, you'll refine exploitation, you'll find clever ways to defer collapse. But when you find joy in connection, when you discover that presence itself is a form of abundance, a different suite of solutions becomes imaginable. The shift isn't incremental; it's a reorientation of the entire frame.

The Assets Upon Which Everything Depends

Raworth brings her economic expertise to bear here. The current paradigm privileges the pursuit of profit by corporations and growth by nations. But this logic depends entirely on what economists call "externalities"—the assets that are treated as free or infinite: clean water, fertile soil, stable climate, the labor of underpaid workers, the unpaid care work done predominantly by women. In Raworth's elegant formulation, these assets "everything depends on them and we're not even counting them." They are the foundation upon which the entire economic system rests, yet they are invisible in the accounting.

To rebuild systems that actually serve life—both human and more-than-human—means making the invisible visible. It means redefining wealth not as accumulation for its own sake but as sufficiency within the living world's means. This requires not just new policy papers but a fundamental shift in how we think and perceive. And that shift, both speakers argue, must begin within.

The Practice: Staying Connected to the Ground

Brother Phap Linh opens the event with a guided meditation that sets the tone for everything that follows. Participants are invited to feel their contact with the earth, to notice their breath, to arrive in the present moment—fully. He describes the role of sustained practice throughout the session: "We might have some concepts and some thoughts and some ideas. We might get very stimulated but all the time we can just stay connected to the breath to the sensation of settling in arriving in every moment."

This is methodological. The concepts matter—Raworth's economic analysis, the Buddhist philosophy of interbeing, the critique of separatist logic. But if those concepts remain abstract, they become another layer of thinking layered atop the old paradigm. When you ground them in lived experience—in the felt sense of being alive, connected, held by the earth—they become real. They become something you can act from.

The invitation, then, is not to choose between inner work and systems change, between meditation and activism, between the personal and the political. It is to recognize that these are not opposites but aspects of a single movement: the transformation of consciousness that permits transformed systems. As ecological economist and Zen practitioner work through this dialogue, the path becomes clearer. Change the mind, and you change what becomes possible. Change what becomes possible, and you change the world.

Where to go from here

For those drawn to explore this integration more deeply, Plum Village offers the seven-week Zen and the Art of Saving the Planet (ZASP) online course, which combines guided teachings, meditations, and live events with monastic teachers. The course runs October 18–December 6, and over 7,500 people from 120+ countries have participated in previous offerings. Use the code "inner change" for a special offer. Learn more at plumvillage.org/zasp. Kate Raworth's Doughnut Economics provides the economic framework for thinking beyond growth; the conversation here shows how inner practice and policy analysis meet.

Comments

Loading the conversation…

Transcript

[0:03] [music]

[0:10] [music]

[0:18] [music]

[0:19] Sometimes you don't know

[0:22] which way [music] you should go.

[0:26] Sometimes you can't see

[0:29] who you're [music] meant to be.

[0:34] Every time the sun rises,

[0:38] every time the moonlight shines,

[0:41] you say I see how

[0:44] I find I try.

[0:48] Leave my die.

[0:51] Breathe my sun.

[0:54] Smile. I cry.

[0:58] I try. I try.

[1:01] I try try. [music]

[1:03] I try.

[1:04] I try try. I try try try.

[1:08] I try try try.

[1:14] Perfect.

[1:21] [music]

[1:31] [music]

[1:36] [music]

[1:41] >> Sometimes you [music and singing] don't

[1:42] know.

[1:48] Hello everyone and welcome. It's so

[1:52] wonderful to be here together with so

[1:54] many of you dear friends. Um you are

[1:58] joining the inner change for systems

[2:00] change online event um with Kate

[2:04] Rayworth and brother Faplin. Um we're

[2:08] yeah we're really grateful to you all

[2:10] for joining us um for this wonderful

[2:12] event. Um we're going to be together for

[2:15] 1 hour and 15 minutes al together. Um

[2:18] and we've got such a inspiring

[2:21] discussion and experience planned. Um

[2:25] thank you all those joining on Zoom who

[2:27] are saying hello in the chat box. It's

[2:29] beautiful to see you joining us from all

[2:31] over the world. And thank you also those

[2:34] joining the live stream on YouTube. Um

[2:37] welcome to everyone. Um in a moment

[2:40] we're going to close the chat box on

[2:42] Zoom um because we're going to arrive

[2:45] together at this event with a guided

[2:48] meditation practice just a short

[2:50] grounding guided meditation practice

[2:52] from dear brother Faplin. So without

[2:55] further ado I will hand over to you dear

[2:57] brother.

[3:01] Thank you so much, Flo. Um, just got to

[3:05] make the mouse accessible so that I can

[3:09] switch on

[3:12] uh this right sound setting.

[3:16] Oops.

[3:16] >> You've turned off your video, brother.

[3:18] >> I have.

[3:20] >> You're back.

[3:22] >> And and off again. Here we go. All

[3:24] right. Original sound

[3:27] so that we can hear the bell. So dear

[3:30] friends, thank you so much for

[3:34] being here in this moment.

[3:38] Let's just feel what it's like to be

[3:42] here in our bodies,

[3:45] in our sensations

[3:51] all together.

[3:55] You might like to just bring your

[3:57] attention to your contact with the chair

[4:02] cushion, the ground.

[4:05] Just feel your orientation in space.

[4:07] Feel the up down axis.

[4:11] Feel the mass of mother earth supporting

[4:14] us,

[4:18] connecting us.

[4:23] And just notice

[4:25] the feeling of the inb breath,

[4:33] the feeling of the outreath

[4:38] as it flows

[4:41] naturally.

[4:45] Just enjoying the sensations of the inb

[4:49] breath and the outreath.

[4:58] We can also allow our minds to be guided

[5:04] back into the present moment

[5:08] uh by gluing ourselves to the sound of

[5:10] the bell. We let the sound of the bell

[5:14] and sensations of the breath

[5:17] become our whole shared world.

[5:29] [bell]

[5:31] [music]

[5:48] >> [bell and music]

[6:05] [bell]

[6:11] [bell and music]

[6:28] >> Breathing in,

[6:30] we can feel

[6:33] life in every cell of our body.

[6:38] Breathing out,

[6:40] we allow ourselves to enjoy

[6:43] the feeling of being alive.

[6:47] The thrum and the hum of life in every

[6:50] cell.

[7:04] Breathing in. Just allowing ourselves to

[7:08] settle in, to sink in to that sensation

[7:12] of life in our body.

[7:17] Breathing out.

[7:20] Just enjoying that feeling of sinking

[7:24] in,

[7:26] settling.

[7:31] There might have been a lot of things

[7:32] going on in our day in the moments

[7:34] before.

[7:37] Right now, we're just allowing our whole

[7:40] being to arrive.

[7:46] Breathing in.

[7:50] I feel that I have arrived

[7:56] in the here and the now.

[8:00] Breathing out.

[8:02] I enjoy

[8:04] the feeling of being at home

[8:08] in the here and the now.

[8:18] Thank you everyone. I'm going to hand

[8:21] back to Flo. Um and we can keep sinking

[8:26] in throughout the session. It might uh

[8:28] we might have some concepts and some

[8:30] thoughts and some ideas. We might get

[8:32] very stimulated but all the time we can

[8:35] just stay connected to the breath to the

[8:38] sensation of settling in arriving in

[8:41] every moment.

[8:44] Thank you.

[8:47] >> Thank you dear brother Fepllin um for

[8:51] that beautiful practice and reminder to

[8:54] be here now together. Um and welcome

[8:57] again everyone um to this online event

[9:00] in a change for systems change with Kate

[9:03] Rayworth and brother Faplin who you just

[9:05] heard from with that guided practice. Um

[9:09] so I'm just going to share a little bit

[9:10] about what we are going to expect before

[9:12] handing over to our wonderful speakers

[9:15] for today's event. Um this event was

[9:19] actually inspired um by the Zen and the

[9:22] art of saving the planet online course.

[9:25] So we wanted to share a little bit about

[9:27] the course right from the outset. Um

[9:30] it's yeah wonderful to have so many of

[9:32] you joining us today and um some of you

[9:35] may be alumni of the course and some of

[9:38] you may be hearing about it uh for the

[9:40] first time and you're all very welcome.

[9:42] Um but for those of you that don't know

[9:44] about the course it's a real uh deep

[9:47] sevenweek online journey um that we're

[9:49] running again from the 18th of October

[9:51] until the 6th of December. And it really

[9:54] offers an opportunity to yeah connect

[9:57] and learn together. Um we have many live

[10:00] events with monastic teachers similar to

[10:03] this one. Um now uh we have guided

[10:06] guided teachings, practices and

[10:08] meditations as part of the course and

[10:10] it's also a real opportunity to connect

[10:12] with a a wide global community. So we've

[10:15] already had over 7 and a half thousand

[10:17] people travel through this course from

[10:20] over 120 countries. And as I say, many

[10:23] of you uh may be joining us um as ZASP

[10:25] alumni today. Um for those that haven't

[10:28] done the course before, you can learn

[10:30] more about it via plumvillage.org/zasp.

[10:33] Um and we'll share information in the

[10:35] follow-up to this event. And at the end

[10:37] of today's event, we're going to be

[10:38] sharing a special gift to support you to

[10:41] join on this deeper journey. Um but for

[10:44] now I would love to turn back to today's

[10:47] event um and introduce our wonderful

[10:50] speakers who it really is such an honor

[10:52] to be able to introduce um Kate Rayworth

[10:56] who's the author of Donut Economics who

[10:58] many of you will recognize and know well

[11:00] and of course Brother Fatlin who we just

[11:03] had that wonderful practice from who is

[11:06] a Zen Buddhist monk in Plum Village. and

[11:09] Kate and brother Fatlin are actually

[11:11] friends together on the path as well. So

[11:13] it's such a special occasion to be able

[11:15] to bring them together for this event.

[11:17] So now I would love to fully hand over

[11:20] to you both to take it from here. Thank

[11:22] you so much.

[11:25] >> Thanks so much Flo

[11:27] >> and it's it's really wonderful to be

[11:29] here with you brother uh in this

[11:31] conversation.

[11:32] >> Absolutely such a such a joy. Um,

[11:37] >> yes. Where are we going to start?

[11:39] >> We're going to start. Yeah, here's where

[11:40] we're going to start. We are coming from

[11:42] very different places. I studied

[11:44] economics because I wanted to change the

[11:47] world, help save the planet as is named

[11:50] in the course and I wanted to learn

[11:53] economics to be the tool of public

[11:56] policy that I wanted to engage with. So

[11:58] I really started with systems change and

[12:01] in in in my journey and frustration with

[12:04] economics I tried to go into paradigm

[12:06] change but it was coming from the system

[12:09] getting into the concepts uh

[12:13] and and still getting halfway there and

[12:16] my encounter with Plum Village takes me

[12:18] to a very different place which is

[12:20] captured in the name of this webinar

[12:21] right inner change for systems change. I

[12:24] started with system change.

[12:26] Plum village starts somewhere else.

[12:28] >> Right. Well, in a sense like when you

[12:30] know when I first encountered Thai and

[12:32] Plum Village, I think I had some of the

[12:35] same questions. Maybe not particularly

[12:37] through the lens of economics, but I had

[12:40] the awareness I had of the impending

[12:42] poly crisis and the already happening

[12:44] poly crisis is maybe 20 years ago or 25

[12:48] years ago and and then more and more the

[12:50] more we know about it. um the harder it

[12:53] seems. Um and so that's you know my

[12:57] reason for becoming a monk in Plum

[12:58] Village was also to do with what's the

[13:01] appropriate response you know what what

[13:04] can we do about this um not running away

[13:06] from it not hiding from it not trying to

[13:08] bypass it like what what's the response

[13:11] >> and what we're going to hopefully do in

[13:13] this workshop is to uh sort of present

[13:17] to you one way to understand the theory

[13:22] of change that we um that underlies all

[13:27] of our offerings in Plumbed. So all of

[13:28] our retreats and of of course the ZASP

[13:31] online course um why do we think that

[13:34] there's a connection between this deep

[13:36] inner work of inner transformation and

[13:39] systems change? Why are these not two

[13:41] separate areas? And we encounter this

[13:43] this question very frequently in our in

[13:45] our retreats and especially with people

[13:47] who are engaged in systems change. And

[13:49] very often you know the inner work feels

[13:51] good. we get to a place you know we meet

[13:53] our suffering and we start feeling

[13:55] better we you know everything's working

[13:58] and then the question comes up but what

[14:00] about systems change so uh we want to

[14:03] take that question head on in this

[14:05] session

[14:06] >> and for this webinar we invited people

[14:08] to send in their questions

[14:11] >> many have come in I just want to share

[14:13] as somebody who never normally sees the

[14:15] questions that are asked and shared with

[14:17] the monastics of Plum Village I

[14:20] I've been really struck and actually has

[14:22] made me go very quiet and I just want to

[14:24] acknowledge all the questions that

[14:25] people in this webinar have sent in uh

[14:27] because they're profound uh they are

[14:30] people we can imagine what some of them

[14:33] are they are people who've been striving

[14:36] for many many years and feeling that the

[14:38] the speed of change is not matching the

[14:40] urgency of the times how do I keep going

[14:43] with stamina without experiencing

[14:44] burnout how do I speak to people who

[14:46] don't understand this as I read those I

[14:49] felt

[14:51] both the the beauty of uh the trust and

[14:54] the care that people are bringing their

[14:56] questions to the monastics

[14:59] but also I I'll be really honest that it

[15:01] touched that many of these questions

[15:03] touched in me something that I often

[15:04] don't allow myself to look at every day

[15:06] or to feel every day because it's too

[15:08] much so I'm feeling it in seeing

[15:11] people's questions and I'm just aware

[15:13] that many people who are joining us

[15:14] today online are feeling this too this

[15:16] is what's brought this group of people

[15:18] together now around how Buddhism can

[15:21] help us think about the art of saving

[15:24] the planet. Uh the the responsibility of

[15:27] that and I hope what we're going to

[15:29] share um as you just said is one way of

[15:32] of engaging with this

[15:35] >> and that's extraordinary in itself that

[15:38] so many people I mean I think three and

[15:39] a half thousand people signed up for the

[15:41] webinar. I'm not sure how many are here

[15:43] now but certainly over a thousand it

[15:45] seems um with more following uh on the

[15:48] live stream on YouTube. So that in

[15:50] itself is kind of amazing good news you

[15:53] know that we're all we all care and we

[15:57] care so deeply and that's really

[15:58] reflected in the questions and it is as

[16:00] Kate says it's it's really

[16:04] it's really humbling you know to be

[16:05] entrusted with such profound questions

[16:09] >> and um you know what we offer uh is is

[16:13] kind of like the first pass you know

[16:16] it's some it might address some of the

[16:18] themes that were there through the

[16:20] questions. Um, but please know uh we

[16:24] can't of course address every question.

[16:26] We'll we'll do our absolute best uh to

[16:28] to speak to the broader themes that

[16:30] emerged. Um and then uh in the the the

[16:35] ZASP course also creates opportunities

[16:37] for for those for those big questions to

[16:39] come in through live events uh with the

[16:42] monastics um as well as in the smaller

[16:46] sharing groups uh throughout the course

[16:48] and in the reflection questions and so

[16:50] on. So whatever we don't answer now um

[16:54] you know

[16:56] there are other opportunities and yeah

[16:59] >> so the way we're going to share the the

[17:01] framework that we want to share we've

[17:02] had a chance to sit down together at at

[17:04] my kitchen table some weeks ago and

[17:06] actually draw a a a conceptual framework

[17:09] that we want to talk our way into

[17:11] tonight and we've got a wonderful scribe

[17:14] here who's going to come and say hello

[17:15] it's not because this is economics it's

[17:17] not the invisible hand of the market

[17:19] that Adam Smith so famous famously

[17:22] created. It's the invisible hand of my

[17:23] daughter, my daughter Siri, who is going

[17:26] to be scribing for us, drawing a picture

[17:28] as we talk. So, she's going to share her

[17:31] screen in a moment, and you will see it

[17:33] pop up.

[17:34] >> Hopefully, you'll see like a blackboard,

[17:36] which she will be drawing on, and you're

[17:37] able to move a dial if you want to make

[17:39] us bigger and smaller in relation to

[17:41] that blackboard as it comes. And and

[17:44] please know that you know the diagram

[17:46] that we're going to unfold for you uh

[17:49] over the next few minutes um is not to

[17:53] be taken as a kind of like this is the

[17:55] final explanation of you know all of

[17:59] Buddhism and all of Plum Village and uh

[18:02] theory of change and so it's just one

[18:04] sketch of it. Um, so, so we we offer it

[18:08] in that spirit of, you know, here's

[18:11] something that we came up with together

[18:13] that that speaks to how we're

[18:15] understanding the connection between

[18:17] systems change and and inner change. Um,

[18:21] but it's all work in progress. Um, so uh

[18:25] and yeah, there are other ways to to

[18:28] represent this. Okay. [snorts]

[18:31] >> Right.

[18:33] >> So, where do we start? you know in the

[18:35] Buddhist um world uh you know we we rely

[18:41] a lot on the methodology that the Buddha

[18:44] offered us which is the you know the

[18:46] basic one is the four noble truths and

[18:49] we start by you know the Buddha sort of

[18:52] tells us well the first noble truth is

[18:54] there is suffering so I invite you to uh

[18:57] to to not take his word for it and

[19:00] please check right right now is it true

[19:04] [laughter]

[19:05] um when I check uh I generally find it

[19:08] to be true and of course we can notice

[19:11] that there's individual you know

[19:13] personal suffering and there's enormous

[19:15] collective suffering so we are bringing

[19:18] the situation into the room into our

[19:22] awareness

[19:23] >> let's just acknowledge the situation

[19:27] >> this is uh the work the in the sense the

[19:30] point of the first novel truth is not to

[19:32] say everything is suffering But just

[19:34] there is suffering

[19:37] >> and

[19:37] >> and I'm going to give a name to that

[19:39] this situation right we uh

[19:42] >> it has come to be called the the poly

[19:44] crisis many people are using this phrase

[19:46] um so just to name the situation that we

[19:48] feel internally but is very vivid

[19:50] externally a poly crisis being

[19:53] when multiple different crises that

[19:55] apparently of different origins but of

[19:57] course everything is interconnected

[19:59] crises that are occurring simultaneously

[20:03] such that they have reinforcing feedback

[20:06] and effects on each other that they seem

[20:08] to buffer each other into ever greater

[20:11] uh extremes. So just to name some

[20:13] aspects of the poly crisis from climate

[20:16] and ecological breakdown that we know is

[20:19] occurring creating food and water crisis

[20:22] with the super El Nino that we already

[20:25] know is embedded connecting with uh

[20:29] economic crisis and extreme deprivation

[20:31] colliding with extreme wealth. Right?

[20:34] that one one is generating the other the

[20:36] rise of extreme wealth in the world

[20:38] today and the damages that this can

[20:40] have. Connecting with financial

[20:43] instability,

[20:44] rising authoritarianism in many

[20:46] countries,

[20:48] >> connecting with disruptive exponential

[20:50] technologies such as artificial

[20:52] intelligence that are likely

[20:56] transforming the role of humans, our

[20:58] sense of ourselves and our sense of our

[21:00] value and our role in the world. This is

[21:02] enough. Any one of these is enough to

[21:04] say, okay, this is this is an urgent

[21:07] major crisis that we need to tackle.

[21:09] They're occurring together. I want to

[21:11] add one thing, which is that many people

[21:13] who live in the global majority world,

[21:16] and I'm talking about those outside of

[21:17] the West, may say, hm, what you're

[21:19] describing sounds like a reality we've

[21:21] known for many, many decades, even

[21:23] centuries. So, I just want to

[21:24] acknowledge that there are people who

[21:26] have communities and cultures who have

[21:29] lived with poly crisis.

[21:31] >> Yeah. for for millennia.

[21:35] What's happening now is that it's

[21:37] literally being globalized and many of

[21:39] us in the west are experiencing that for

[21:42] the first time and thus it gets given a

[21:45] name.

[21:46] >> So I just want to acknowledge that this

[21:47] is not entirely new. So poly crisis and

[21:51] we feel it viscerally in our bellies. We

[21:53] feel it as a tight knot and the sense of

[21:54] overwhelm that is written into so many

[21:56] people's questions.

[21:57] >> That's it. So yes, this potty crisis,

[22:00] although we're describing this sort of

[22:02] vast sort of global situation, has all

[22:04] of these inner dimensions in the sense

[22:06] that we we're constantly on the verge of

[22:10] burnout uh or deep into burnout. Maybe

[22:13] we we feel overwhelmed, we feel

[22:15] powerless to change the situation. There

[22:17] may be despair, there may be anxiety,

[22:20] there may be loneliness. All of these

[22:21] things are reflections of this this

[22:25] massive situation that that we face.

[22:28] Um and let's just notice the effect on

[22:32] us right now as we name the suffering.

[22:35] You know, we we we bring it into

[22:37] awareness.

[22:39] That can be a lot. So, you know, please

[22:42] just

[22:44] recognize the the feelings in your body

[22:46] and we can we can regground ourselves.

[22:48] We can you know it can the feelings can

[22:51] be very strong here but but I think our

[22:53] toes generally are are okay even with

[22:57] poly crisis toes toes are very happy you

[23:00] know uh our contact with the ground even

[23:02] when we're thinking about poly crisis

[23:04] our contact with the ground is very very

[23:06] stable it actually is kind of a safe

[23:09] place to go with our awareness

[23:10] especially when we start to feel

[23:11] overwhelmed. So we can always kind of

[23:13] recenter, regground and and come back to

[23:16] the sensations of the breath and and so

[23:18] on if that feels comfortable. So um the

[23:22] next thing that we do uh as uh Buddhist

[23:25] practitioners is we you know we've

[23:28] acknowledged that there is suffering and

[23:29] then um we start getting curious about

[23:32] it and we ask well how did this

[23:34] suffering come to be? Um where did it

[23:38] come from?

[23:40] Uh, does this suffering have roots?

[23:44] Um,

[23:46] and I just noticed that

[23:48] maybe others are somehow uh drawing on

[23:53] the on the blackboard. So, if you could

[23:55] refrain from drawing uh on the shared

[23:57] board, that would be wonderful. And

[23:58] maybe delete if uh what you have drawn

[24:01] if if you did by accident.

[24:04] Um

[24:05] but yeah so so this this is the second

[24:08] noble truth the roots of suffering and

[24:09] and in a sense the what the Buddha tells

[24:12] us is if we understand the roots of

[24:14] suffering deeply enough um then

[24:18] something good is going to happen. So,

[24:21] so we when we're looking at this bigger,

[24:23] you know, this vast situation, uh, the

[24:26] global situation, we can ask, well, how

[24:29] has it come around? Uh, and and so one

[24:32] level of analysis sort of lower down the

[24:34] roots of that are in our institutions,

[24:37] for example.

[24:39] And, um,

[24:43] but our institutions didn't come out of

[24:45] nowhere.

[24:47] So they uh they are as they are. Um that

[24:53] [clears throat] that might be like our

[24:54] schools, our governments, uh our um

[24:58] are excuse me, uh our courts, um our

[25:04] international trade agreements, all of

[25:07] these things, they're based on um

[25:10] behavioral norms and practices and laws.

[25:14] So, so that's in a sense like a deeper

[25:16] root. Uh, so we we we're going to look

[25:20] into the roots of our institutions and

[25:22] then the roots of the roots of our

[25:24] institutions.

[25:26] Um, so what do we find as we dig in even

[25:31] deeper beneath, you know, how did these

[25:35] collective agreements come about, these

[25:36] behavioral norms, practices, laws, so

[25:40] on. Um they all

[25:44] you know in a sense are based on uh our

[25:48] shared beliefs

[25:49] um the stories that we hold together in

[25:53] our in our culture uh in our and in our

[25:55] cultures in our global culture and our

[25:58] worldviews.

[26:00] Um so

[26:03] when we are interested in paradigm

[26:05] change we want to know like how let's

[26:08] change we we we kind of know we should

[26:09] change this paradigm. this paradigm is

[26:11] hurting us. But um it's not enough just

[26:15] to say oh let's have a new paradigm. We

[26:17] have to know well how did this paradigm

[26:19] come about? And the paradigm itself

[26:21] rests on yet deeper layers. And and

[26:24] please like just to be clear like this

[26:26] is just one layering of this cake. You

[26:29] know we could have different layers of

[26:31] analysis. And I'm not suggesting that

[26:33] the causality is only linear in the

[26:36] sense that this causes that causes that

[26:37] causes that. there's feedback and feed

[26:40] forward at every level. So this is just

[26:43] a sketch. Uh don't take it too

[26:46] literally.

[26:48] But underneath our our beliefs, our

[26:51] stories, our worldviews,

[26:53] um I like to think about, you know, what

[26:57] are the patterns? uh the patterns of

[27:00] feeling, the sort of um yeah, structures

[27:04] of feeling, patterns of feeling,

[27:06] thinking, and even perceiving that we

[27:08] hold. They're kind of like our habits,

[27:10] our habits of feeling, our habits of

[27:12] perception, our habits of thinking that

[27:13] become invisible to us, but that very

[27:16] much shape our our worldview. Um and of

[27:20] course, you know, there is a vast

[27:22] diversity of worldviews. Um, but in in

[27:25] the terms of this kind of analysis,

[27:28] we're we're trying to see if we can feel

[27:31] into what might be a dominant worldview.

[27:34] And it doesn't mean that we agree with

[27:36] it, right? In fact, we almost certainly

[27:37] don't. But we have to acknowledge that

[27:40] there is a worldview

[27:42] that somehow exists in this shared space

[27:46] of our of our institutions, our norms,

[27:48] our education system and so on. And it

[27:51] might be hurting us. it might actually

[27:53] be causing suffering. So we've got down

[27:56] to this layer of patterns of feeling,

[27:58] thinking, perceiving.

[28:00] And I think one way to understand how

[28:02] those habits of perception, of thinking,

[28:04] of feeling come about is to look into

[28:07] the way um that language the the role

[28:11] that language plays uh in in the coming

[28:16] to be of our thoughts and our

[28:19] perceptions and our feelings. Uh because

[28:21] we might notice that as we go about our

[28:23] day um a lot of the time we're we're

[28:26] kind of navigating our life through

[28:30] language through the narration of

[28:32] experience

[28:34] um and uh you know even our perceptions

[28:37] are quite uh bound to linguistic

[28:42] structures um yeah so that's worth

[28:45] looking at as a potential cause of

[28:47] suffering and then um but I think even

[28:50] we can go even deeper

[28:52] And maybe underneath

[28:55] the structures of, you know, maybe now

[28:58] we're talking about the dominant

[28:59] languages. So, so we could talk about,

[29:02] you know, the European languages that uh

[29:04] tend to dominate a lot of our discourse,

[29:07] our international agreements and and so

[29:09] on. So, of course, there are other

[29:11] structures of language that might serve

[29:12] us better, but the ones that we're kind

[29:15] of saddled with for the moment are very

[29:18] like nounheavy. uh for example. And that

[29:22] that structure itself might depend on a

[29:24] yet deeper layer um which for now we're

[29:28] just going to call the fundamental

[29:30] feeling of separation,

[29:33] right? Which is also the feeling that

[29:35] we're kind of on our own. That that I'm

[29:38] in here and the world is this big scary

[29:41] place where I have to survive and I

[29:43] might be threatened. I might be in

[29:44] danger. Um I might have to compete. Uh,

[29:47] but there's me and there's world and I'm

[29:49] separate from it. [snorts] And again, I

[29:51] know we almost certainly don't agree

[29:53] with that, but we have to recognize that

[29:56] it is that it's there uh and it shows up

[30:00] a lot in our in the way our world uh

[30:03] >> kind of is organized.

[30:05] >> Thank you for setting that out. Uh, I

[30:07] found the first time you I heard you

[30:09] specify these different layers, I found

[30:11] it so helpful to help me separate out

[30:15] the different layers of my critique of

[30:18] and frustration with the economic

[30:20] mindset that I was taught. So in the

[30:23] spirit of bringing economics together

[30:24] with the this foundational concept

[30:27] approach to Buddhism and uh change I'm

[30:31] going to run through these with some

[30:33] examples from mainstream economics and I

[30:35] hope that they really resonate with many

[30:36] many people in the webinar. So I'm going

[30:39] to go back. So if the situation is one

[30:40] of poly crisis and this suffering has

[30:43] roots I mean you're inviting us to start

[30:45] with institutions. So to really to

[30:47] observe the entities that we see in the

[30:50] world and I want to pick out three kinds

[30:52] of institutions that I I see. One is the

[30:54] nation state. So nations u right we've

[30:57] divided the world into these political

[30:59] entities and we think economically if

[31:02] you want to take a kind of macro unit of

[31:05] analysis it's the nation that becomes

[31:07] the how how is that nation growing? How

[31:09] is that nation doing? Adam Smith wrote

[31:11] about the wealth of nations. So this is

[31:13] a a major entity of institution

[31:17] within that economically there are

[31:19] companies and I'm saying the word

[31:21] companies in very intentionally uh this

[31:24] could include private businesses or it

[31:26] could include corporations owned by

[31:28] shareholders. There's a wonderful irony

[31:30] with the world the word companies it

[31:32] literally compound. It means to break

[31:35] bread with but actually what companies

[31:37] do is make dough as it were in slang

[31:40] right so they're they're very profit

[31:41] oriented and so the the companies that

[31:43] we have have a profit primacy as in the

[31:47] their primary f intention of these

[31:50] entities of these institutions is to

[31:52] generate profit. This is what makes a

[31:55] company and that matters. And then I

[31:57] want to add here the institutions of

[31:59] finance because I think the design of

[32:01] finance, the creation of finance, the

[32:03] creation, the power to create money and

[32:05] the the character it's given deeply

[32:08] shape our companies and then how nations

[32:12] uh prioritize companies in their pursuit

[32:14] of profit. So that's at an institutional

[32:17] level. If we go down a level, I found

[32:19] this really helpful to think about what

[32:21] are the behavioral norms and practices

[32:22] that we see enacted out by these kinds

[32:25] of institutions. And it an expression

[32:27] that brother spirit shared with me some

[32:29] weeks ago was these are forms of

[32:31] institutionalized combat.

[32:34] Now we know that we have

[32:35] institutionalized combat in sport. We

[32:37] love it. People love having a team and

[32:39] the teams play against each other and

[32:41] one team wins and one team loses. And

[32:43] there's clearly something deeply in us

[32:44] that loves competition and it can be

[32:47] really healthy. But it seems that we

[32:50] have the western economic approach and

[32:52] paradigm and enactment has taken

[32:54] institutionalized combat and brought it

[32:57] into economic structures. So we have

[33:00] companies competing against each other.

[33:02] We have nations competing each other. I

[33:04] mean look at the AI race that's on right

[33:07] now. But we've also brought it into

[33:10] politics. And as a British person, I can

[33:12] say I see our our political parties

[33:14] literally are seated opposite each

[33:16] other, shouting at each other. Other

[33:18] countries have organized it a little

[33:20] more sensibly, but still it's party

[33:22] versus party. It's very combat driven

[33:25] approach to politics and in law, you

[33:28] know, who's going to win the case. So,

[33:30] we've brought combat uh

[33:32] institutionalized into the the heart of

[33:35] our behavioral norms and practices. it

[33:37] is inherently competitive

[33:39] >> and we and there's an assumption that

[33:42] it's that that's a good thing that that

[33:44] combat or competition is going to drive

[33:46] innovation. Um it's going to keep making

[33:49] things better. It's going to make us

[33:51] perform better. So it's also in our

[33:53] education. Every exam is a kind of

[33:55] >> right,

[33:56] >> you know, ritualized combat in a sense

[33:58] maybe implicitly. You we're competing

[34:00] with literally everybody else in the

[34:02] country, you know, at our end of school

[34:04] exams. Uh, and we're alone. It's like

[34:07] alone against the world.

[34:08] >> Yeah.

[34:09] >> Yes. And so under these norms that we

[34:13] don't even notice sometimes that we're

[34:14] in this institutionalized combat, what

[34:16] are the beliefs and stories and

[34:17] worldviews that sit underneath them

[34:20] >> coming out of the western economic

[34:22] mindset and indeed the practice which

[34:24] now dominates the world? There are of

[34:25] course so many. I want to pick out

[34:28] three. And the first one is the

[34:31] self-interested human. that the that the

[34:33] notion that that we as humans our our

[34:35] primary trait is self-interest. And

[34:37] here's a little drawing of a rational

[34:40] economic man who how he's characterized

[34:42] in mainstream western economics. He's a

[34:45] the me, the ego. This is my

[34:47] self-interest. I engage with the world

[34:49] through the market. I'm calculating in

[34:50] my head, but I'm driven by my

[34:53] self-interest to pursue what matters and

[34:56] is valuable to me. So the

[34:58] self-interested human of rational

[35:00] economic man which is placed at the

[35:02] heart of that competitive um engagement.

[35:05] The second one I want to bring is

[35:08] ownership of assets. Ownership. So the

[35:12] idea that we as humans who if we're

[35:15] lucky we live maybe

[35:18] 80 90 maximum you know a hundred years

[35:21] but that we little beings who are

[35:22] temporarily not soil in the words of

[35:25] Robin W Kimmera that we could claim to

[35:27] own trees that live for 300 years or own

[35:30] land that has been here for billions of

[35:32] years. the notion of ownership. And I've

[35:35] chosen the word assets here, not only

[35:37] because it's so prevalent in mainstream

[35:39] financial talk, but because I I looked

[35:41] up the the root of the word asset, and

[35:45] it comes from old French ass, which

[35:48] means literally enough. So there's

[35:50] something very ironic.

[35:51] >> Wow.

[35:52] >> That the word assets, assets are used to

[35:55] get more, right? To we use acids, we

[35:57] sweat our assets. And yet the origins of

[36:00] the word acid itself is This is enough.

[36:03] This satisfies. So something very

[36:06] twisted has happened in the western

[36:08] mindset and language to turn enoughness

[36:11] into the thing we sweat for more.

[36:14] The third one I'll add here is

[36:16] accumulation.

[36:18] The notion and I'm going to bring a bit

[36:20] of old hose pipe here. The notion that

[36:22] that growth is good, right? And this is

[36:24] this is the shape of progress. It looks

[36:26] like an ever exponentially growing curve

[36:30] going up. But we hear it in every

[36:31] politician's speech and every

[36:32] economist's advice. Growth is good. More

[36:36] is better. Accumulation, it is at the

[36:39] the heart of capitalist economies,

[36:41] right? We sweat our assets to accumulate

[36:44] more. We use our companies to generate

[36:46] the profit that will give us that

[36:49] moreness.

[36:50] >> Yeah.

[36:52] >> Often we we stop here and and and

[36:54] explore this um and and and critique

[36:56] economics through this. And I I do a lot

[36:58] of this myself, but it's really

[36:59] interesting to go this level below that

[37:01] brother spirit's inviting. What is the

[37:03] the pattern of feeling, thinking, and

[37:05] perceiving? What's the deeper assumption

[37:08] that we we embody but often don't name?

[37:11] >> Right? Like if we really want to

[37:14] transform this paradigm, it might not be

[37:16] enough just to come up with a better

[37:18] paradigm and say this is a this is a

[37:21] better paradigm. We might actually need

[37:23] to understand how did this paradigm come

[37:26] about like can we can we uh accomplish a

[37:30] transformation even in ourselves at an

[37:33] even deeper level so that um

[37:38] so the new paradigm emerges naturally

[37:40] from that it doesn't have to be imposed

[37:42] and it's not a conceptual thing it's a

[37:43] natural sort of emergent thing

[37:46] >> so here okay so so inviting us to go

[37:49] deeper I'm going to bring here I think

[37:51] one of the deep patterns of feeling,

[37:54] thinking and perceiving is the notion of

[37:56] externalities which is at the heart of

[37:58] western economic thought that of course

[38:00] there are impacts beyond but they're

[38:02] impacting others and the very notion of

[38:05] externalities creates an othering. And I

[38:08] don't mean others as in celebrating

[38:11] diversity. I mean as in demarking

[38:13] difference.

[38:14] >> Uh this and and distance, right? This

[38:17] this is uh this object is owned here.

[38:20] It's valued here. Here it may be given

[38:22] monetary value. I can value this object

[38:25] and there are other things I can

[38:26] separate from it and that are distinct

[38:28] from it. That's a really important point

[38:31] part of property.

[38:33] >> This is my property that is other.

[38:36] >> Yeah.

[38:37] >> And it's related to map making as well I

[38:39] think in interesting ways when it

[38:40] concerns land. Um, which is another sort

[38:43] of maybe a little rabbit hole, but just

[38:44] the fact that the idea that we can make

[38:46] an abstract representation of reality on

[38:48] a piece of paper, draw a line and then

[38:51] say, "Well, this is mine.

[38:54] It's it's a wild idea really when you

[38:57] look at it."

[38:59] Yes. And un

[39:03] the structure of language. So, this is

[39:04] that beautiful invitation to try and

[39:06] step out of the water of our own

[39:07] language. And I think for many people,

[39:08] I'm going to bet for many people on this

[39:10] call, the work of Robin Wal Kimmera

[39:12] >> teaching us uh to to to hear and see

[39:16] with her pottomy indigenous culture that

[39:20] she has been reacquiring

[39:22] is to realize that the language and the

[39:24] language I'm speaking right now that

[39:26] we're listening and speaking in English

[39:27] language particularly

[39:30] picks out entities, picks out objects

[39:33] and things. We name things. We are very

[39:35] nounheavy language which of course helps

[39:38] us distinguish this object from that

[39:41] object and create boundaries around

[39:43] things that we can point to and pick up

[39:45] and own as property and buy and sell

[39:47] these distinct objects. And again we

[39:51] only we can only sometimes hear it when

[39:53] we step out of it and hear that other

[39:55] languages think differently. Robin

[39:56] Wimmerro famously said there is a there

[39:59] is a a word of to be obey

[40:02] >> which is so alien to the English

[40:04] language because we we turn a noun

[40:06] instead of a being in a flowing process.

[40:09] >> So I'm going to stop there because uh

[40:11] this is what what helped me unpick the

[40:15] economics that I learned to get down to

[40:17] the structure of language and and the

[40:19] teachings of Plum Village really helped

[40:20] me think about it. But never in my

[40:23] economics education did we talk about

[40:24] the fundamental feeling of separation.

[40:26] So brother

[40:27] >> take us there.

[40:29] >> Thank you Kate. Okay. So, as you can

[40:31] see, I I hope you know, as we we we're

[40:34] really kind of establishing that there

[40:37] there are these connections between the

[40:39] the vast situation that we find

[40:41] ourselves in and sometimes feel

[40:43] overwhelmed by and and our own habits in

[40:47] a sense of of feeling, of perceiving, uh

[40:50] the language that we use, the way that

[40:52] we think around the world, about the

[40:53] world. Um and so uh

[41:00] why have we added this layer of the

[41:02] fundamental feeling of separation and

[41:04] what can we do about it? I think it

[41:05] might be again that in this community we

[41:08] might sort of feel like yes that's the

[41:09] thing we want to get rid of. Um, but I

[41:11] want to be very careful there not to

[41:14] demonize it and just to recognize that

[41:17] all of us went through this experience

[41:20] of being born.

[41:22] And the moment our umbilical cord was

[41:25] cut

[41:27] was a very dangerous moment. Um, we

[41:32] suddenly we've been looked after, we've

[41:35] been nourished, we've uh by by our

[41:38] mother. Our our mother has eaten for us.

[41:40] She she's breathed for us. She's kept

[41:43] the temperature stable for us. She's

[41:45] created this uh palace in I think in

[41:48] Chinese and Vietnamese the womb is

[41:49] called the palace of the child. Uh it's

[41:52] so comfortable. Everything is perfect.

[41:55] Um and suddenly we're out and the lights

[41:58] are bright and the air is harsh and you

[42:00] know there are foreign hands on us and

[42:03] who knows it's it could be it's an

[42:05] absolutely terrifying moment and then

[42:06] suddenly we're cut off. We are alone in

[42:09] that moment and we could die if we don't

[42:12] take that first breath.

[42:15] We die

[42:17] and that must be absolutely terrifying.

[42:21] Um so there is very naturally an

[42:25] original fear

[42:27] um that might still be within us at some

[42:30] level and that fear is necessary because

[42:32] it it it it pushes us to do something

[42:35] about it. uh we're afraid to die. Um and

[42:38] we don't want to die. Uh so there's also

[42:40] a desire. There's a desire to live. And

[42:43] so we we're going to make the effort.

[42:45] We're going to cough out the amniotic

[42:46] fluid from our lungs. We're going to

[42:47] take that first breath. It's hard. It's

[42:49] probably unpleasant. We cry. It's maybe

[42:51] painful.

[42:53] Um it's a very very powerful sort of

[42:55] formative experience that we all have to

[42:57] go through. And there's nothing wrong

[42:58] with it in a sense.

[43:00] All of that is

[43:03] is beautiful is is part of life. Um and

[43:07] and of course underlying that original

[43:09] fear and uh original desire is our

[43:12] survival instinct. Very very powerful.

[43:14] We want to live. Again nothing wrong

[43:17] with that potentially. Um and even maybe

[43:21] deeper than the survival instinct itself

[43:23] is is vitality.

[43:26] It's our life force. Um and this is in

[43:29] all living beings. Uh all living things

[43:31] want to live. Um it's a very very

[43:36] powerful thing. Um and maybe you know in

[43:40] our in our meditation as we go deep and

[43:42] we start to get in touch with these very

[43:45] powerful forces, it's not to sort of

[43:47] shut them down and and and say, "Oh,

[43:49] I've got to be very, you know, calm and

[43:52] not have any desire and not want to do

[43:54] things and not have any energy and I've

[43:56] got to stay still.

[43:57] I think that might be a mischaract

[43:59] characterization of you know what the

[44:01] Buddha was inviting us to do.

[44:04] And you know my teacher Thai uh would

[44:07] ask us very frequently this question or

[44:09] sort of challenge us. He said go into

[44:11] the forest

[44:13] sit at the foot of a tree and find out

[44:16] what is your deepest desire.

[44:21] And this question in a sense should

[44:24] terrify us. It certainly terrified me.

[44:27] Uh so I very naively if says to do

[44:31] something I okay well I suppose I have

[44:33] to do it. So I literally did it. I went

[44:35] into the forest long before I became a

[44:37] monk sat at the foot of a tree and I

[44:39] asked myself okay can I find out right

[44:42] now what is my deepest desire? [snorts]

[44:46] And of course that what I was afraid to

[44:49] discover

[44:52] was you know what was with me is like

[44:55] what if my deepest desire is actually

[44:57] just to survive to survive and to win to

[45:01] compete to reproduce to find comfort and

[45:04] shelter and maybe

[45:07] yeah um pleasure and you know to be

[45:12] loved but basically just to survive.

[45:15] um and uh survive and thrive kind of

[45:18] like what if that's it? What if that's

[45:19] really who I am?

[45:22] um and all of this other stuff, you

[45:24] know, that I think maybe I, you know,

[45:25] want to be a nice guy and do good things

[45:27] and save the planet and stop the poly

[45:29] crisis and maybe that I've just fooled

[45:31] myself and actually at root what I

[45:34] really want is just to live and you know

[45:37] maybe at any cost to you know that it

[45:41] that might be the case right and you

[45:43] know when I sat down in that meditation

[45:46] I wanted to I need I sort of felt like I

[45:49] need to risk that that's the answer

[45:52] >> for that question to be real,

[45:55] I need to risk that that's what I'll

[45:57] find out. But what I found was something

[45:59] completely different, which stunned me.

[46:01] I didn't really know that this might,

[46:04] you know, be there.

[46:06] What I found was, of course, I want to

[46:08] survive. Of course, there's that desire

[46:10] to to reproduce, to have children, to to

[46:13] thrive, to win, to be loved, all of

[46:15] those things. Of course, that's all

[46:16] there. And there's nothing wrong with

[46:17] any of that. It's all fine part of life.

[46:19] That's one manifestation of our

[46:21] vitality, of our life force. But I found

[46:23] something else. And to me, it became

[46:26] very clear in that meditation that it

[46:27] was even more powerful than the desire

[46:31] to survive. And and and now, you know,

[46:34] as we were making this diagram, I sort

[46:36] of realized this is also a manifestation

[46:39] of vitality. So we can feel the power of

[46:43] the life force within us of that

[46:45] vitality. And maybe we can open our mind

[46:49] to the possibility that it can go a

[46:51] different way. And the the other way,

[46:54] the thing that I found was this wild

[46:57] desire in me for all things to be well,

[47:01] for all beings throughout all time and

[47:03] space to be at peace, to be well, to be

[47:07] happy, not to suffer. And I call that

[47:11] like one way I like to talk about it is

[47:13] the will to the good. there's just this

[47:17] and it's a bit irrational like it

[47:18] doesn't make a lot of sense. It doesn't,

[47:20] you know, it's not evolutionary

[47:22] evolutionarily

[47:24] uh logical for me to care. But we can

[47:28] all observe you, you see uh an ant

[47:31] struggling or a spider struggling to get

[47:33] out of a sink,

[47:34] you help it. You don't want the spider

[47:36] to suffer. It doesn't make any

[47:37] difference to you. It's doesn't help

[47:39] you. Doesn't make you more money or, you

[47:42] know, but but we do it like that's a

[47:44] part of us. And I think what we've been

[47:45] told a little bit maybe and maybe with a

[47:48] lot of authority by the dominant

[47:50] paradigm is that yes, you know, that's

[47:52] part of us. We are sort of slightly

[47:53] empathic, but it's probably very small.

[47:56] And really what's stronger is the

[47:58] survival instinct and our selfishness

[48:00] and our drive for competition and all

[48:01] that. But what I'm saying and I think

[48:04] what we can really test for ourselves is

[48:06] actually let's check. Let's find out.

[48:08] And I know, you know, when I test, and I

[48:11] still do, what I find is it's the other

[48:14] way around. This is stronger. The will

[48:17] for all things to be well, um for others

[48:21] not to suffer, uh for myself not to

[48:24] suffer, for suffering to be eased and

[48:26] held and transformed is so so so

[48:29] powerful. And and that are so there's

[48:32] nothing wrong with our energy, right?

[48:34] There's nothing wrong with the kind of

[48:36] vitality we have. But you know in in the

[48:38] process of deepening in meditation we

[48:40] should have more energy not less right

[48:43] >> um and it's just like the question is

[48:46] where do we channel that energy where

[48:47] does it where does it go

[48:49] >> so I think this gives us um a way and

[48:52] you know we could talk about like what

[48:54] are the practices that allow us to get

[48:55] in touch with this

[48:57] >> um and um

[49:00] uh you know that's sort of throughout

[49:02] plum village retreats and the zast

[49:04] course and so on but right for now we're

[49:06] just to sort keep building out this uh

[49:09] this picture.

[49:10] Um I think the the result of channeling

[49:13] our energy that way is that we start

[49:18] getting

[49:19] a feeling for our interconnectedness,

[49:22] not as a concept.

[49:25] Um but we actually start realizing

[49:29] I in a sense like I care about suffering

[49:32] throughout all of time and space because

[49:33] I am all of time and space. like it's

[49:36] that's why it matters so much. It's like

[49:38] it's so powerful because it's me. It's

[49:41] my body. It's I I'm not separate from

[49:43] any of it. So I call that in a sense

[49:45] that we start to feel little glimmerings

[49:48] of our interbeing nature. And what

[49:50] results from that is we start to have

[49:54] less fear.

[49:56] We feel less fear. Maybe we even touch

[49:58] non fear because if we're not separate

[50:01] then you know our own death it's it's

[50:04] not as bad as we thought because we're

[50:07] also this. We are this but we're also

[50:09] this. So the disappearance of this

[50:13] you know [clears throat] and we could

[50:14] have a little bit of that or more of

[50:15] that. And we also start to find more joy

[50:20] and ease in letting go. Like letting no

[50:22] go not as a big sacrifice and something

[50:24] very harsh and difficult but letting go

[50:26] because it's like oh I have enough. I am

[50:29] [clears throat] enough. I'm all this. I

[50:31] am you know

[50:33] I don't need to accumulate things. I can

[50:35] I can live with this. It's so and it's

[50:38] very joyful. So, so this in a sense is

[50:40] the beginning of what the Buddha maybe

[50:44] called the third noble truth which is

[50:45] well-being [snorts] uh suka uh joy and

[50:49] ease. Um so so we you know we've got to

[50:54] the roots of of our suffering. We found

[50:57] that maybe we can direct that energy in

[51:00] a different way and we start actually to

[51:01] feel better because and we feel less

[51:04] alone. We feel connected. We're less

[51:06] afraid. uh we don't need as much. Um and

[51:11] uh yeah, so here we are. We're at the

[51:12] third noble truth. And um and then what

[51:16] happens? We go back up the other side.

[51:18] We're going to start going back up these

[51:20] these layers and see like, you know, it

[51:22] doesn't have to be that we that we get

[51:24] completely enlightened for all of this

[51:26] to happen. We we it's enough just to get

[51:27] a little a little taste, a little

[51:29] glimmer through through the practices of

[51:31] mindfulness, concentration, insight. And

[51:35] you know we can go more into that in

[51:37] other sessions on other courses and

[51:39] retreats and so on.

[51:40] >> Um and um yeah and then and then other

[51:45] things start to flow from that. We have

[51:47] a we start to have a different feeling

[51:49] for the role of language in our life.

[51:51] Maybe we start reaching for new

[51:54] language. And I think that's what my

[51:55] teacher did um when he was trying to

[52:00] help us in a in a sense like uh he was

[52:03] trying to give us a new language for

[52:05] this new way of perceiving this new way

[52:07] of feeling. Um and so he offered us the

[52:10] word into being,

[52:12] >> right? And so this is this is a really

[52:15] good start. you know, we we have um

[52:18] already the sense that uh all things are

[52:22] have a kind of interbeing nature.

[52:24] Nothing really can be separated from

[52:26] from the web. So that word uh whilst

[52:29] it's still a concept, still a word, we

[52:31] don't want to get caught in it, but it

[52:33] starts to give us a new way to to

[52:35] perceive um and we start seeing things

[52:38] more in terms of their relations um with

[52:42] each other, with ourselves, with our

[52:44] feeling uh with our feelings um and so

[52:48] this uh starts to structure our

[52:51] experience differently. And then

[52:54] what do you think cape happens you know

[52:57] once we start actually experiencing this

[53:00] this this level of connection uh to

[53:04] ourselves to each other to the cosmos to

[53:06] nature particularly once we start

[53:08] actually perceiving through the lens of

[53:10] of interbeing of our interconnection

[53:13] >> um what what patterns of thinking

[53:17] feeling perceiving might arise from that

[53:19] and then what beliefs and stories and

[53:20] worldviews and what new paradigms are

[53:23] waiting to emerge.

[53:24] >> Yeah, thank you for all of that. The

[53:26] richness of that. I want to I want to

[53:27] share. I love I love the celebration of

[53:30] vitality here.

[53:31] >> Uh I have a lot of energy. I have a lot

[53:33] of I I really feel that sense of

[53:35] vitality and life force and

[53:39] and also in myself and I and I can see

[53:41] it in others. Which way are we going to

[53:42] go? Right? We we all know we can be

[53:45] collaborative, competitive and and I

[53:46] just want to go back to actually to Adam

[53:48] Smith himself in his book the theory of

[53:50] moral sentiments in 1759. He wrote and

[53:53] you literally he wrote in these two

[53:55] directions these arrows you mentioned he

[53:57] said that self-interest is the virtue

[54:00] most useful to the individual but our

[54:03] humanity justice generosity and public

[54:06] spirit are our virtues most useful to

[54:09] others. So right there he saw this sort

[54:12] of which way are we going to go people?

[54:14] Which way are we going to go? Now

[54:15] economics actually pulled the very

[54:17] self-interest version out of Adam Smith.

[54:19] But if if anyone reads his writing, he

[54:21] was so into the public, the generous,

[54:23] the human, the just, the the relational,

[54:25] right? All of those words are

[54:27] relational.

[54:28] >> And maybe we can help him a little bit

[54:30] upgrade his quote.

[54:32] >> Say our what did he say? Our public

[54:33] spirit.

[54:34] >> He said humanity, justice, generosity,

[54:36] and public spirit. Those are not only of

[54:40] benefit to others, they are also of most

[54:42] benefit to ourselves.

[54:43] >> Beautiful. Thank you. And when I first

[54:47] encountered the work of Tiknahan Thai uh

[54:51] this word into being it's it's that

[54:54] beautiful thing with with one word

[54:55] somebody goes

[54:57] here's a new world view and suddenly

[55:00] inviting you to see the relations

[55:02] between the rel so relation being the

[55:05] fundamental unit in the world rather

[55:07] than a thing. So suddenly you're looking

[55:08] at the spaces in between the fingers

[55:10] rather than the fingers. You're looking

[55:11] at relations and connections. This was

[55:14] totally mind-blowing for me to encounter

[55:16] this and and it creates this joyful new

[55:20] new kind of economic thinking that I

[55:22] wish in this webinar I know many many

[55:24] people could joyfully uh bring an

[55:26] alternative economic vision up this side

[55:28] which I'm going to do. So in instead of

[55:31] entities and things we have relations

[55:33] and interbeing as a foundation for what

[55:37] what we what we know is in the world

[55:40] what we what what matters and what we

[55:42] center. So instead of focusing on

[55:44] externalities,

[55:45] I'm going to use a wonderful word

[55:47] brought in by a friend of mine, Indie

[55:48] Joha. He talks about entanglements. And

[55:50] I'm just going to grab here.

[55:53] >> This plant, this plant which lives in my

[55:56] study is not a single object. Is an

[55:58] entanglement of a fern, with soil, with

[56:02] bacteria, with the sunlight, with the

[56:04] water. It's entangled with me actually

[56:06] because if I don't water it, it won't.

[56:08] So it's deeply entangled

[56:11] >> like everything around us once you once

[56:14] you start looking at the entanglements

[56:16] it's it's

[56:17] mindblowing.

[56:19] >> I was with Indie Johar last week and and

[56:23] um I offered another new word maybe

[56:26] which is internalities.

[56:28] >> Oh

[56:29] >> not just externalities. And we were

[56:31] talking about for example like the

[56:32] effect of um rainfall in Indonesia on uh

[56:36] the weather in Australia for example.

[56:39] And that in a sense like we we all of

[56:41] our nation states which are which govern

[56:44] themselves decide on you know make their

[56:47] economic policies as if they are

[56:49] separate actually depend and are

[56:53] intimately connected to atmospheric

[56:55] rivers

[56:56] >> which are driven by um evaporation from

[56:59] the rainforest primarily the Amazon I

[57:02] think the Congo basin and Indonesia and

[57:05] we all need those

[57:07] >> yes

[57:08] >> rainforest to generate the atmospheric

[57:09] rivers for all of our crops to be grown

[57:12] and so on. So, so those are not

[57:14] externalities. Those are internalities

[57:17] >> beautiful

[57:17] >> that we don't cost just as we don't cost

[57:20] the externalities. We don't account for

[57:21] them. We just assume that they're there.

[57:24] But everything depends on them and we're

[57:25] just ignoring them and of course they're

[57:26] now starting to fail.

[57:28] >> Beautiful. And as you just said, we

[57:29] don't cost. And so instead of talking

[57:31] about monetary value, let's and and I

[57:32] haven't found a good term for this, but

[57:35] for for now holistic value that is in in

[57:39] the interconnections of all those

[57:40] internalities.

[57:42] >> Talking of entanglement, we are

[57:44] unfortunately very entangled with the

[57:46] clock right now. So I'm going to take us

[57:50] quite fast up this new side and and

[57:52] everything that I'm bringing here and

[57:54] that we've discussed. I invite everyone

[57:56] uh on this webinar to know that this is

[57:58] of course the emergent possibility that

[58:00] many many people here are helping to

[58:03] create shape envision name make possible

[58:06] make visible in the world. So I'll just

[58:08] bring some some words to to uh give an a

[58:13] positive um opposition to what's on the

[58:16] other side. So instead of accumulation

[58:18] and growth is good, let's celebrate

[58:20] enoughness

[58:21] >> and that balance is good. Enoughness and

[58:24] of course that's for me that was at the

[58:26] heart of creating this concept of the

[58:27] donut where we meet the needs of all

[58:30] within the means of the living planet

[58:31] and we find balance so that there is

[58:34] enough for all within the means of the

[58:36] planet. The planet has enough uh balance

[58:40] and integrity and humans have enough. So

[58:43] opposing the endless growth pursuit

[58:45] towards an enoughness

[58:47] um a new very different meaning of

[58:49] assets. So we steward assets, right? We

[58:53] who what hubris to think that a a

[58:55] temporary human can own beings and and

[58:59] cre creations of this earth of

[59:01] millennia. We steward we receive assets

[59:05] that it is our role and responsibility

[59:07] to pass them on in at least as good a

[59:09] state that we found them. So I and of

[59:11] course stewardship is rising in the

[59:13] space of new economic thinking. It's

[59:16] beautifully coming out of everything

[59:18] that's just been described about the

[59:19] interrelatedness of things. We are

[59:20] stewarding this earth as responsible

[59:23] beings within it. And then instead of

[59:25] being told that we are self-interested

[59:27] humans, we are pro-social beings. And

[59:30] all the science shows us we are the most

[59:33] pro-social of all mammals. We have to

[59:35] tap into our care, our love, our

[59:37] willingness to cue, to share, to assist

[59:40] others beyond our kin. It's a a human

[59:42] superpower. We have to tap into

[59:45] understanding that version of ourselves.

[59:47] And how then do we design our behaviors

[59:49] and norms and practices and this this I

[59:52] get very excited about. Uh the work of

[59:54] Ellen Ostramm has I think been

[59:56] foundational for many people when she

[59:58] says the commons, don't tell me the

[1:00:00] commons are tragic. The commons can be a

[1:00:02] triumph if the correct norms and

[1:00:05] principles and rules are in place to

[1:00:07] protect that pro-social side of us so

[1:00:10] that nobody feels that we're going to be

[1:00:12] cheated by a self-interested character

[1:00:15] coming in and um you know overturning

[1:00:18] the collective value we're creating. We

[1:00:20] can create we can create shared value

[1:00:22] when we put in place good values that

[1:00:25] hold us together. So, Ellen Ostramm's

[1:00:28] core design principles. But I do want to

[1:00:30] mention here the the a really valuable

[1:00:33] tool that I learned through the plum

[1:00:36] village practice that I know is

[1:00:37] introduced in the ZASP course of

[1:00:39] beginning a new which is a beautiful

[1:00:42] practice between two people when we have

[1:00:44] bumped into each other. Uh we have

[1:00:47] misunderstood each other, we have hurt

[1:00:48] each other, we have fallen out of

[1:00:50] connection for getting back into

[1:00:52] connection. It's something I use very

[1:00:54] often in my life to reset profoundly

[1:00:57] relationships. So again, the teachings

[1:01:00] of Plum Village really help us with this

[1:01:02] organized reconciliation. It's such a

[1:01:04] beautiful contrast to institutionalized

[1:01:07] combat because we do bump into each

[1:01:09] other. We show up with our baggage. We

[1:01:10] all have our buttons that can be

[1:01:12] pressed. We have our biases. We need

[1:01:14] ways of reconciling and reconnecting

[1:01:17] with one another in our in our human uh

[1:01:20] vulnerability to misunderstand and

[1:01:23] misconrue. So those are key

[1:01:26] >> and then I'm going to lift us up here to

[1:01:29] what kind of institutions then this is

[1:01:30] this is the space of search

[1:01:33] >> we can gesture towards believing that we

[1:01:35] we should organize more around bio

[1:01:36] regions. Earth herself being the biggest

[1:01:39] bio region. The whole planet is of

[1:01:41] course the bio region of concern but bio

[1:01:43] regions rather than political divisions

[1:01:45] that we organize in organizations that

[1:01:48] have purpose primacy rather than profit

[1:01:50] primacy. So it could be a business it

[1:01:52] could be a business but it's driven

[1:01:53] firstly by its purpose not by the

[1:01:56] pursuit of profit. And instead of

[1:01:58] finance we find some new form of flows

[1:02:00] that many people are now working on. How

[1:02:02] do we redesign finance so we recognize

[1:02:05] what's needed is flow in life

[1:02:07] >> different kinds of resource flow. And

[1:02:09] this all contributes towards well if we

[1:02:11] want to get out of poly crisis and we

[1:02:13] want to come with new words

[1:02:15] a beautiful vision of poly thriving and

[1:02:18] that's got a fractalness in it that the

[1:02:20] earth is thriving that people in

[1:02:22] different bio regions [clears throat]

[1:02:23] are thriving that humans and the more

[1:02:24] than human are thriving and that within

[1:02:26] our own bodies that we can feel well and

[1:02:29] thriving

[1:02:31] [sighs]

[1:02:32] >> and we can only thrive together with all

[1:02:36] uh with all species with all nations

[1:02:40] um with all yeah with all our all our

[1:02:44] kithan kin uh human and more than human

[1:02:47] and I think um maybe I didn't mention

[1:02:51] the four the fourth noble truth which is

[1:02:53] the way uh the path the practice and

[1:02:56] Siri was kind enough to add it in there

[1:02:58] at the at the turn uh of the U so it's

[1:03:01] kind of like the you know we were

[1:03:04] looking diving down finding out what's

[1:03:06] at the root of um of suffering. And then

[1:03:09] we're we're finding well, we're starting

[1:03:12] to feel that well-being is possible, but

[1:03:13] there's also a way there's a way to

[1:03:15] bring that well-being more into the

[1:03:17] world and and for it to be held

[1:03:19] collectively as well in community. And

[1:03:22] there are that is in itself a very big

[1:03:25] area uh of um and sort of rich area of

[1:03:28] of practice. That's what we uh share

[1:03:32] also through all of our retreats and on

[1:03:34] the SAS course. It's the noble

[1:03:35] eight-fold path. It includes an ethical

[1:03:38] dimension. So we have our five

[1:03:40] mindfulness trainings which also are

[1:03:42] just another way in a sense to

[1:03:43] articulate and to make very um practical

[1:03:47] and realistic uh this theory of change

[1:03:50] like how do we do it in our daily lives.

[1:03:52] Um and it and the in the five

[1:03:54] mindfulness trainings in the text you'll

[1:03:55] find things that concern um you know us

[1:03:59] our intimate relationships our our

[1:04:01] feelings our relation to consumption and

[1:04:04] and and our habits our relationship to

[1:04:06] anger and speech and um and and so on.

[1:04:10] but also uh our relationship to the

[1:04:13] economic system, our you know our

[1:04:14] choices of what companies to invest in

[1:04:17] and why uh and um whether we are

[1:04:20] connected to systems of of oppression

[1:04:22] and exploitation

[1:04:24] um uh and and so on. So, so the five

[1:04:27] mindful strange is a very very beautiful

[1:04:30] kind of articulation of you know this uh

[1:04:33] the path the the how and it's a daily

[1:04:36] mirror also that we can sort of check in

[1:04:38] when we come up against you know tough

[1:04:41] choices like you know what do I do in

[1:04:44] this situation we could it's we can use

[1:04:46] it as as a sort of um compass to to to

[1:04:49] orient

[1:04:51] >> and there is so much more uh that could

[1:04:54] be said this is just the start this a

[1:04:56] sketch. This is just a sort of like you

[1:04:58] know one one lens through which we can

[1:05:01] we can see these practices. But we hope

[1:05:03] that um at least it it it sort of

[1:05:06] stimulates and uh and and and we hope

[1:05:09] also that it that that you felt um that

[1:05:12] your questions had been heard and that

[1:05:15] we're speaking to at least some of them.

[1:05:17] Um and I think like one one more maybe

[1:05:20] important thing to say um is that we

[1:05:23] actually have some evidence that our

[1:05:25] theory of change works. So what are we

[1:05:28] saying? We're saying that if we could

[1:05:31] get deep enough in ourselves with the

[1:05:35] practice of meditation to kind of help

[1:05:39] ourselves channel that vitality

[1:05:42] um not only towards our self-interest

[1:05:44] and survival which of course we're still

[1:05:47] going to have like we still need to know

[1:05:48] that we are to some extent separate that

[1:05:51] that's a that's a helpful lens still you

[1:05:53] know getting on and off buses you don't

[1:05:54] want to think you're one with the bus

[1:05:56] that could be very dangerous so so we do

[1:05:58] need to take care of ourselves as uh

[1:06:01] relatively separate uh individuals.

[1:06:03] That's that's a relevant framing some of

[1:06:05] the time. But there's this other framing

[1:06:07] where we start to see and really feel um

[1:06:10] our being in the world as as part of

[1:06:13] this vast net of inter relations. Um

[1:06:17] and uh

[1:06:19] >> you were going to say the research

[1:06:20] there's been some research conducted.

[1:06:22] >> Thank you Kate. I was totally lost my

[1:06:24] thread but exactly. So, so in a sense

[1:06:26] what we're saying is if we can get deep

[1:06:27] enough, we can change um our our

[1:06:31] worldview from one of separateness to

[1:06:34] one of that's sort of grounded on into

[1:06:36] being. Uh that's our that's our value

[1:06:39] proposition. We say like come to Plum

[1:06:41] Village or join the ZASP course and and

[1:06:44] this will happen. Now that's very

[1:06:46] different from saying come on a

[1:06:48] mindfulness retreat and learn how to

[1:06:50] manage your stress and to you know

[1:06:55] generate some you know I don't know

[1:06:57] handle your emotions you know do do some

[1:06:59] emotional kind of uh management this a

[1:07:02] very very different thing that we're

[1:07:04] offering and of course we are also

[1:07:05] teaching mindfulness we're also going to

[1:07:07] be able to relax and better handle

[1:07:10] stress and better handle our emotions

[1:07:12] all of those things are part of it but

[1:07:14] what we really up to is this very very

[1:07:17] deep shift of

[1:07:20] feeling and thinking perceiving from I'm

[1:07:22] alone and separate to oh I actually

[1:07:26] start to feel connected not just to you

[1:07:29] know we probably agree like conceptually

[1:07:31] that we're interconnected but but how

[1:07:33] often do we feel it how do how how often

[1:07:36] do we feel held in that matrix of

[1:07:38] interconnection so of course we can

[1:07:41] claim that this is going to work is

[1:07:43] going to work it's going to produce this

[1:07:44] feeling of uh interconnection and

[1:07:47] interbeing. But the question is does it

[1:07:49] right? Does it actually work? And this

[1:07:50] has been studied by the wonderful

[1:07:52] scientist Christine Vamsler from Lund

[1:07:55] University. She studied three separate

[1:07:58] cohorts um who went through the ZASP

[1:08:00] course with pre and post questionnaire.

[1:08:02] Had about n of 850 something. So about

[1:08:05] 850 people um you know gave uh you know

[1:08:10] responses to the questionnaire in a way

[1:08:11] that she could sort of ask these

[1:08:13] questions like did your climate anxiety

[1:08:16] measurably go down? Do you feel more

[1:08:19] trust? Uh uh do you feel more power? Do

[1:08:22] you feel more empowered? Do you have

[1:08:23] more a sense of agency? Um and are you

[1:08:27] starting to get glimmers of interbeing?

[1:08:28] And the results, which I'm not going to

[1:08:30] go into because Flo's reminding me we're

[1:08:31] out of time, were overwhelmingly that

[1:08:34] basically yes, this works. Like our

[1:08:36] theory of change does, you know, it does

[1:08:40] to a very great extent the thing that we

[1:08:42] hoped that it was doing and that we

[1:08:44] believed it was doing. Uh but it's very

[1:08:46] very wonderful to to have her her

[1:08:49] reflection on that and that she gets

[1:08:50] that that she gets that's what we're

[1:08:52] actually trying to do.

[1:08:53] >> Yeah. Um

[1:08:54] >> and I was I I don't think I was part of

[1:08:56] that study but I did do this course and

[1:08:58] I want to say that I found it uh really

[1:09:01] deeply connects with my the ecological

[1:09:04] concerns that bringing together the

[1:09:07] foundational teachings of Buddhism with

[1:09:10] that ecological starting point doing it

[1:09:12] together with other people who you know

[1:09:13] share that starting and entry point the

[1:09:15] live sessions I I loved with the

[1:09:17] monastics but I know that one thing that

[1:09:19] many many people value in the Aasp

[1:09:20] course is that you you're invited to get

[1:09:22] into small groups

[1:09:23] that you then you know connect with you

[1:09:26] have zoom sessions with you study

[1:09:28] together you learn together and it's

[1:09:30] that human connection and the listening

[1:09:31] and being heard by your small cohort

[1:09:34] that many many people come out and say

[1:09:36] this was really an important part and

[1:09:38] even though it was online I was so

[1:09:40] connected with real people on their own

[1:09:43] journeys and the comfort that we feel

[1:09:46] from knowing that others are

[1:09:47] experiencing some of the same things so

[1:09:49] I think it's a very beautifully designed

[1:09:50] course

[1:09:51] >> um from that respect And if anybody's

[1:09:53] thinking of it, I individually can

[1:09:55] recommend it very much.

[1:09:57] >> And and I think one more thing that

[1:09:59] Christine sort of revealed through her

[1:10:01] research is I mean that's the big

[1:10:04] proposition of this whole session in a

[1:10:06] sense that there is this powerful

[1:10:08] connection between the inner

[1:10:09] transformation and the outer change.

[1:10:11] Yes.

[1:10:11] >> And and there were like really strong

[1:10:14] indications like I don't want to

[1:10:15] overclaim it like it's worth reading the

[1:10:16] paper maybe you know you could just read

[1:10:18] the abstract and the discussion at the

[1:10:20] end. Uh it's very very beautiful. Maybe

[1:10:22] Flo can give us the link uh if for

[1:10:24] anybody who wants to to to read her her

[1:10:27] her sort of what her findings. Um but

[1:10:30] she found you know strong indications

[1:10:32] that that this does actually already

[1:10:34] start to ripple up into systems change.

[1:10:36] Um and there's some amazing examples of

[1:10:38] that. I mean in a sense Cristiana

[1:10:40] Faggeres and her work with the Paris

[1:10:42] climate agreement is already a powerful

[1:10:44] example of that. you know, she went to

[1:10:46] some retreats at our center in Germany

[1:10:47] and then in in in in Plum Village and

[1:10:50] she credits her ability um to help

[1:10:53] shepherd this massive international

[1:10:56] agreement, this cooperation, this, you

[1:10:58] know, collaboration um the deep

[1:11:01] listening, you know, to to the

[1:11:04] transformation um that she started

[1:11:06] experiencing uh through the Plum Village

[1:11:08] retreats. And now that's rippling out.

[1:11:10] That was one person but that has now

[1:11:13] reached you know what did clerk flow say

[1:11:16] nearly eight seven 8,000 people through

[1:11:19] zasp another at least a thousand through

[1:11:22] the climate retreats in plum village

[1:11:24] >> and so you know I think the evidence is

[1:11:27] going to start accumulating of of of

[1:11:29] like real concrete stuff that this is

[1:11:31] now uh allowing to to to to manifest uh

[1:11:35] in the world

[1:11:38] >> it's fantastic it's fantastic to hear

[1:11:40] that research. I'm sure we should hand

[1:11:42] back to flow to keep ourselves in flow

[1:11:44] of this session. Thank you, brother.

[1:11:47] >> Thank you, Kate. And thank you, Siri.

[1:11:49] >> Thank you, Siri.

[1:11:50] >> Thank you to our wonderful scribe.

[1:11:52] >> Great scribe.

[1:11:53] >> Thank you so much, Kate, brother. And of

[1:11:57] course, Siri, our wonderful scribe. Um,

[1:12:00] wow, what a beautiful uh rich sharing um

[1:12:04] yeah, that you've gifted us with today.

[1:12:07] Um and because we're running short of

[1:12:09] time, my dear colleague Sophie is just

[1:12:11] sharing a slide um with you now, dear

[1:12:14] friends. Um because we promised this, uh

[1:12:17] event would be 1 hour and 15 minutes and

[1:12:19] we don't want to go too much over to

[1:12:21] respect your time. Um but we would love

[1:12:23] to invite you all to join us to deepen

[1:12:25] this journey on the Zen and the Art of

[1:12:27] Saving the Planet online course. Um we

[1:12:30] would love to gift you um 20% off the

[1:12:34] standard rate of the course if you if

[1:12:36] you use the code inner change when you

[1:12:38] sign up for the course in the next 5

[1:12:40] days. Um that will be possible and we

[1:12:43] will email you all of the details

[1:12:45] including um the wonderful research that

[1:12:47] brother Fatlin referred to then um from

[1:12:50] Christine Bonsler who I know is on the

[1:12:53] call today as well and so wonderful to

[1:12:55] have you here Christine. Um but what we

[1:12:57] would love to do now is also we're gonna

[1:12:59] reopen the chat box. So um because Kate

[1:13:02] there shared some experiences that she

[1:13:04] had with the course and if you anyone

[1:13:06] wants to we've run out of time a little

[1:13:08] bit now but if anyone wants to share

[1:13:09] their words of thanks and or briefly

[1:13:11] their experiences with the course for

[1:13:12] alumni that are with us now that would

[1:13:14] be wonderful. And for anyone that hasn't

[1:13:16] done the course, please uh yeah, join us

[1:13:19] and and continue to explore many of the

[1:13:22] themes that have been um raised so

[1:13:25] inspiringly today by brother Patlin and

[1:13:28] Kate Rayworth. Um so yeah, I think that

[1:13:32] um we yeah, lovely to see your chat box

[1:13:34] messages coming in on Zoom. Um I think I

[1:13:37] would love to um hand the final word

[1:13:39] back to Kate and Brother Fatlin. Um if

[1:13:42] there's anything you would like to share

[1:13:44] just to uh thank everyone and say

[1:13:46] goodbye um before we unmute people so

[1:13:49] they can say goodbye themselves.

[1:13:50] >> I'd love to jump in and say this is a a

[1:13:53] pleasure and an honor for me to to join

[1:13:55] to bring the western mindset of

[1:13:57] economics through the beautiful funnel

[1:13:59] of plum villages into being

[1:14:02] enlightenment so that we can generate a

[1:14:04] new economy together. I've seen that

[1:14:06] some people have said, could we share

[1:14:07] the the the blackboard drawing?

[1:14:10] Absolutely. We will make sure that is

[1:14:11] shared. Um over to you, brother.

[1:14:14] >> Yeah. And I think um I think Kate

[1:14:16] already said it, but that you know,

[1:14:18] coming up the other side, what are the

[1:14:19] new emerging paradigms and and and so on

[1:14:23] like that's what we're going to do alto

[1:14:25] together like none nobody's going to

[1:14:27] come up with that on their own. Like we

[1:14:29] need everybody on board. Everybody's

[1:14:31] intelligence, creativity, and their

[1:14:33] insight, their wisdom. um for those uh

[1:14:37] new and also old paradigms maybe to

[1:14:39] emerge that the new could also be very

[1:14:41] ancient, you know. So we also need um

[1:14:44] other ways of knowing. We need the

[1:14:45] indigenous ways of knowing uh you know

[1:14:48] to to welcome them back into our

[1:14:52] collective shared understanding. Um uh

[1:14:55] and and also maybe even th those of us

[1:14:57] who who are kind of you know born in in

[1:15:01] Europe or in the US and and feel that we

[1:15:04] don't that we're not very rooted that

[1:15:05] we're not connected to our indigenity

[1:15:08] those threads it might be possible to

[1:15:10] reconnect with that too to to find the

[1:15:12] threads of wisdom in our bones in our

[1:15:15] deep roots. Um anyway so yes let's

[1:15:19] decolonize I see that coming up in the

[1:15:21] chat. I'm yeah we decolonize our

[1:15:23] thinking, decolonize our feeling um and

[1:15:26] of course decolonize all of our

[1:15:27] institutions um and and and so on and uh

[1:15:31] it's just so fun to do this work

[1:15:34] together and I I just want to say again

[1:15:36] don't take the I know we will share the

[1:15:38] blackboard don't take it too seriously

[1:15:41] it's just a version

[1:15:43] all work in progress and there will be

[1:15:45] many more iterations and also what we

[1:15:47] unfolded this day to today was was in a

[1:15:50] sense

[1:15:51] If we unpack this methodology through

[1:15:54] the lens of economics, this is how uh it

[1:15:57] it sort of shakes out. One way it shakes

[1:15:59] out, but we could we could do that

[1:16:01] through many other disciplines as well

[1:16:03] and and concerns. Um so so there's lots

[1:16:07] more there to to unfold

[1:16:09] >> and that might actually be a beautiful

[1:16:10] activity for many people on the webinar

[1:16:12] to take that framework and say they

[1:16:14] heard us make that what's their own

[1:16:16] disciplinary worldview journey to go on.

[1:16:20] Yeah. Yeah.

[1:16:20] >> And in a sense, that's also what I spent

[1:16:22] the last four years doing in this book

[1:16:24] that's going to come out next year

[1:16:26] called Wonder uh where science meets

[1:16:28] Zen. And and I'm I'm really trying to do

[1:16:31] that also for the whole of scientific

[1:16:34] materialism. It's like how do we, you

[1:16:37] know, get to the roots of scientific

[1:16:38] materialism and unpick it and allow a

[1:16:40] new scientific paradigm to to to emerge.

[1:16:44] Um yes. So that will come out next year.

[1:16:48] So so much richness still to come dear

[1:16:51] friends as you can hear. Um and we feel

[1:16:53] like this uh event as well as being an

[1:16:56] invitation to the zen and the out of

[1:16:57] saving the planet course is also yeah

[1:16:59] going to be the start of many many

[1:17:01] things uh many unfoldings. So, thank you

[1:17:03] so much again, Kate and brother. And um

[1:17:06] we've enabled Thank you so much for all

[1:17:08] of the beautiful messages in the Zoom

[1:17:09] chat as well. And dear friends on Zoom,

[1:17:12] we've made it possible for you to unmute

[1:17:14] yourselves if you would like to say

[1:17:15] goodbye.

[1:17:20] >> Bye everyone.

[1:17:24] Everybody nice.

Plum Village
ArtistPlum Village

Plum Village is the creator of Plum Village, a podcast exploring consciousness, spirituality, and personal transformation. With 1 episodes, they have created a valuable resource fo…

Voir le profilSite web
Explorer les thèmes
Inner-workSystems-changeMindfulnessEconomicsInterbeing

Des questions ?

Questions fréquemment posées

When you shift your fundamental worldview from separation to interbeing—recognizing you are part of an interdependent web rather than apart from the world—your choices and actions naturally align differently. Millions of people making this shift creates cultural momentum that makes new policies, institutions, and economic models imaginable and viable.
Meditation trains the mind to perceive directly rather than through inherited language and conceptual frameworks. Since current systems (extractive economics, environmental destruction) flow from a separatist worldview embedded in language, you need contemplative practice to step outside that thinking and imagine genuine alternatives.
Interbeing means recognizing you are not a separate entity but part of an interconnected whole. Practically: your body is made of elements shared with earth, your breath exchanges with forests, your food carries the labor and resources of others. This isn't metaphor—it's empirical reality when you pay direct attention.
According to this framework, activism without inner transformation tends to reinforce the old paradigm's logic—optimizing extraction, refining exploitation. Sustainable systems change requires both: the practice of perceiving differently, and the courage to rebuild structures aligned with that new perception.
Clean water, fertile soil, stable climate, women's unpaid care work, and underpaid labor are treated as free or infinite in capitalist accounting. They are invisible externalities—yet everything depends on them. Making them visible is foundational to redesigning economies that serve life rather than extraction.
No. The seven-week course is designed for anyone concerned with ecological and systemic change. It combines guided teachings with contemplative practices and live discussions with monastic teachers, creating a space to integrate inner reflection with systems thinking. Over 7,500 people from 120+ countries have participated.

Continuer la lecture

More from Plum

Voir tout
Stop Fixing, Start Feeling: The Path to Real Healing
Inspire

Stop Fixing, Start Feeling: The Path to Real Healing

When conflicts arise, we rush to fix them—but healing requires we slow down and feel first. A monastic teacher reveals the hidden cost of so…

1 min read
Liberation Through Grief and Self-Worth in Buddhist Practice
Inspire

Liberation Through Grief and Self-Worth in Buddhist Practice

Br. Phap Huu explores how recognizing our inherent goodness and learning to grieve openly within community liberates us from suffering and s…

1 min read
Living Gems Archive: Preserving Thích Nhất Hạnh's Dharma for the World
Inspire

Living Gems Archive: Preserving Thích Nhất Hạnh's Dharma for the World

Living Gems is a searchable digital archive of Thích Nhất Hạnh's teachings, built by Plum Village to preserve and share the dharma globally …

1 min read
Govinda Jaya: How Sacred Sound Awakens the Heart
Inspire

Govinda Jaya: How Sacred Sound Awakens the Heart

Radhika Das channels the liberating power of mantra through a luminous kirtan performance at Medicine Festival, invoking divine names to pur…

1 min read

Continue d’explorer

Poursuis ton chemin

Plus de sagesse et de rassemblements dans tout l’annuaire BrightStar.

Plus d’articles

Parcours toute la bibliothèque d’enseignements, d’entretiens et de guides.

Retour à tous les articles →

Enseignants et artistes

Découvre les lignées, les musiciens et les guides du monde conscient.

Explorer les artistes →

Trouver un événement

Kirtan, retraites, bains sonores, breathwork, festivals — bientôt près de chez toi.

Parcourir les événements →